i don’t ever write reviews but that was the worst milkshake i’ve ever had anywhere, coffee flavor-not even close to coffee and so much milk and was so thin like soda not a milkshake
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Karyn Martin
Fabulous little ice cream & candy shop! Ice cream is made on site and is delicious. Lots of candy options for those who are dairy free (no dairy-free options for scoops at this time.) don’t miss the chocolate treats on the highest top shelf. Try some of the more interesting flavors like lemon lavender or buttered banana!
Kt K
Amazing ice cream. I’m very picky and a bit of a self proclaimed ice cream connoisseur and this place has unique flavors, but the ice cream consistency is perfect. Some of my favorite ice cream in the United States. The brown sugar banana is my favorite and often sold out, which makes me sad. Staff is always soooo friendly, which is hard to find on the vineyard if I’m being honest.
J Acharya
Delicious Ice Cream
Austin c
Really good homemade ice-cream
Jasna Acharya
Delicious Ice Cream
Kathleen Rooney
HOSTILE TO FOOD ALLERGIES. Believing that “homemade ice cream” made on the premises was a good bet for telling us wether particular flavors had eggs or nuts we made two attempts here and in both cases, staff was unwilling to be helpful in any way, telling us, in one instance, that they “cross contaminate all the containers anyway so we shouldn’t try to find out ingredients.” Disgraceful. We have often found that one of our party can’t eat at a particular place but have never been met with rudeness. I guess the line out the door means more than being decent humans.
Ann Mahlitz
Yummy pistachio hot fudge sundae.
Kathy R
HOSTILE TO FOOD ALLERGIES. Believing that “homemade ice cream” made on the premises was a good bet for telling us wether particular flavors had eggs or nuts we made two attempts here and in both cases, staff was unwilling to be helpful in any way, telling us, in one instance, that they “cross contaminate all the containers anyway so we shouldn’t try to find out ingredients.” Disgraceful. We have often found that one of our party can’t eat at a particular place but have never been met with rudeness. I guess the line out the door means more than being decent humans.
Best ice cream on the island! Love the texture, taste and creative flavors! Excellent customer service. Visited 3x!
aborkowski914
If you are in Edgartown, stop the Scoop Shack! Yes it is pricey (EVERYTHING on MV is!) but the quality is worth it. My husband and I shared a double school cup of Half and Half and the portion was very generous and more than enough for the two of us to enjoy and made it a little for cost effective…they happily gave us two spoons.
Arun S
Nice ice creams, they follow allergy protocol and took care of our nut allergy needs.
Natalie Caldwell
Massive line but totally worth the wait. This is not your stereotypical ice shop with regular flavors so do be mindful of that. However, this is the creamiest and BEST ice cream in Edgartown.Another note - A little tough later in the night (after 9pm) because a lot of the flavors were out by the time we got there so come which multiple flavors in mind. HIGHLY recommend the strawberry (it was the real, not syrupy/fake kind). The maple walnut was great with big chunks of walnuts. And the cookies and cream had the most cookies in cream I have ever seen.
Blathers
Insanely good ice cream but the cone did not taste that great so can't give 5 stars. Go here but just don't get a sugar cone
Friggin delicious! That Rum Raisin. Lord.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
i don’t ever write reviews but that was the worst milkshake i’ve ever had anywhere, coffee flavor-not even close to coffee and so much milk and was so thin like soda not a milkshake
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Fabulous little ice cream & candy shop! Ice cream is made on site and is delicious. Lots of candy options for those who are dairy free (no dairy-free options for scoops at this time.) don’t miss the chocolate treats on the highest top shelf. Try some of the more interesting flavors like lemon lavender or buttered banana!
Amazing ice cream. I’m very picky and a bit of a self proclaimed ice cream connoisseur and this place has unique flavors, but the ice cream consistency is perfect. Some of my favorite ice cream in the United States. The brown sugar banana is my favorite and often sold out, which makes me sad. Staff is always soooo friendly, which is hard to find on the vineyard if I’m being honest.
Delicious Ice Cream
Really good homemade ice-cream
Delicious Ice Cream
HOSTILE TO FOOD ALLERGIES. Believing that “homemade ice cream” made on the premises was a good bet for telling us wether particular flavors had eggs or nuts we made two attempts here and in both cases, staff was unwilling to be helpful in any way, telling us, in one instance, that they “cross contaminate all the containers anyway so we shouldn’t try to find out ingredients.” Disgraceful. We have often found that one of our party can’t eat at a particular place but have never been met with rudeness. I guess the line out the door means more than being decent humans.
Yummy pistachio hot fudge sundae.
HOSTILE TO FOOD ALLERGIES. Believing that “homemade ice cream” made on the premises was a good bet for telling us wether particular flavors had eggs or nuts we made two attempts here and in both cases, staff was unwilling to be helpful in any way, telling us, in one instance, that they “cross contaminate all the containers anyway so we shouldn’t try to find out ingredients.” Disgraceful. We have often found that one of our party can’t eat at a particular place but have never been met with rudeness. I guess the line out the door means more than being decent humans.
Restaurantji Recommends
Best ice cream on the island! Love the texture, taste and creative flavors! Excellent customer service. Visited 3x!
If you are in Edgartown, stop the Scoop Shack! Yes it is pricey (EVERYTHING on MV is!) but the quality is worth it. My husband and I shared a double school cup of Half and Half and the portion was very generous and more than enough for the two of us to enjoy and made it a little for cost effective…they happily gave us two spoons.
Nice ice creams, they follow allergy protocol and took care of our nut allergy needs.
Massive line but totally worth the wait. This is not your stereotypical ice shop with regular flavors so do be mindful of that. However, this is the creamiest and BEST ice cream in Edgartown.Another note - A little tough later in the night (after 9pm) because a lot of the flavors were out by the time we got there so come which multiple flavors in mind. HIGHLY recommend the strawberry (it was the real, not syrupy/fake kind). The maple walnut was great with big chunks of walnuts. And the cookies and cream had the most cookies in cream I have ever seen.
Insanely good ice cream but the cone did not taste that great so can't give 5 stars. Go here but just don't get a sugar cone
Loading...