After several of our vacation days eating out on Martha’s Vineyard and eating mediocre and expensive food this place hits the mark!! Halibut and the tuna were perfectly done with interesting and appropriate vegetables. The local kale salad with feta was a delight. Kudos to the chef!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Kale Salad, Tuna Special
Bill Melcher
We went for a drink at the bar after dinner, and our bartender and experience were excellent. We had a margarita and a martini, and both were made expertly. We saw him make a Manhattan for another patron, and it was stirred and garnished with an amarena. We hope to make it back tomorrow to try other craft cocktails.
Service: 5
Dawn Perry
We really enjoyed our meal there. We had the pork with the apple slaw and a wedge salad. Both were great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
M S (Sunders ont road)
A long day walking the island left me with a bit of a hunger. So headed out to a place recommended by a couple at breakfast this morning. And they were spot on. Had a nice local lager. Then the fried Brussels sprouts with Oysters. ? they were amazing. Tasted so good. Followed by the fish of the day. Though quite pricey it was well worth it. So even if the place had been a small hole in the wall the food would have made it worth the visit. But the place is a fun place. A bit rock and roll, live bands on the weekend, not when I was there. But it was a good place to sit and eat dinner. If you get a chance eat here do it. Don’t hesitate.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sarah
This place has a very cool atmosphere, designed like a rustic wooden barn, which adds a lot of charm. The menu is large and accommodating, offering plenty of options for everyone. While the cocktails were just okay, I'd recommend sticking to wine or beer. The highlight for me was the vegetarian curry—absolutely delicious! Overall, a great spot with a unique vibe.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Brussel Sprouts
Corey Patricia Thomas
LOVE this spot. The food was amazing! And Molly, our waitress, was amazing. Our drinks came out super fast and the food was delicious!!!!! Highly recommend the Port Hunter.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fresh Oysters, Burrata
NY chinchilla
Had the scallops and wedge salad. Was tasty but not memorable. The oysters were very nice! You decide if cost is worth it…
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Fresh Oysters
Jan Siderius
Cool restaurant with good food. The fluke with coconut was amazing! Very nice staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Lucy Barber
Fantastic restaurant with amazing food and super staff, the plant based menu is great! The spicy brussels sprouts and grilled corn were the best we've ever had. The curry bowl and tofu tacos were also super tasty. Very well thought out vegan options that were incredibly tasty. This was an amazing meal on the evening of my partners 50th birthday whilst celebrating in Martha's Vineyard.
Mauricio Ramirez
Excellent food, service and vibe. Do not miss this place in beautiful Edgartown. We will be back for sure. Parking is challenging. It gets full fast, reservations are necessary.
Parking: We parked at a nearby parking lot, about 2 blocks away. It was the last spot, I recommend to have a little extra time to hunt for parking elsewhere at the street.
Wheelchair accessibility: Street level, wheelchair friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fresh Oysters, Seafood Chowder, Burrata, Fish Tacos, Tuna Special
Food and service were outstanding. Reasonably priced. Ordered Oysters Rockefeller, wedge salad, and key lime pie. Molly our waitress was attentive and professional. Sitting on the sidewalk was quieter than inside and fun. Would very highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Harry Schechter
Problems always arise. It’s how they are handled where the true colors are shown.
Last night, I went with a group of 6 for dinner. The appetizers were good. We had the buffalo brussel sprouts and the fluke ceviche.
Dinner was not good. I had “The Tuna”. It came out looking quite appetizing. However, after tasting it, it was clear something was not right. Perhaps it had spoiled or was some other bad piece of fish, but it smelled bad. I didn’t eat any of it.
The server didn’t come back to check on the food until the rest of our group was done eating. At that point, I mentioned something was not right. They did not offer me another entree. They did not offer to take this off the bill. Not did anyone else from the restaurant come over to investigate.
There are so many other choices in Edgartown. Go somewhere else.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 1
Sophie Frank
Fun spot at night
Nicole Schubert
First of all, the front of house service was excellent. Sadly, the food was sub par overall. We sent back the buffalo brussel sprouts app. It was drowning in what tasted like Frank's Red Hot sauce and I found it inedible. They brought us a new order with the sauce on the side, but the brussel sprouts were so over-fried that you almost couldn't tell they were once green vegetables. For $28, the chicken sandwich should be very delicious, memorable even, and we thought it was just ok. The french fries were very overcooked. On a good note, I had the scallops special and it was very tasty for $52. Our cocktails were weak and not remarkable and almost $20 each. We walked out disappointed after spending $180 for two of us, with tip. Went to Mad Martha's for an ice cream cone to feel better about our evening.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
D S
The food here is excellent. We had four in our party. The tuna dish was delicious. One person had the hamburger and he thoroughly enjoyed his meal. The french fries are freshly cut. Balsamic dressing on the burrata was a little on the sweet side. This place is wonderful. Great service. Would definitely go back!
After several of our vacation days eating out on Martha’s Vineyard and eating mediocre and expensive food this place hits the mark!!
Halibut and the tuna were perfectly done with interesting and appropriate vegetables. The local kale salad with feta was a delight. Kudos to the chef!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Kale Salad, Tuna Special
We went for a drink at the bar after dinner, and our bartender and experience were excellent. We had a margarita and a martini, and both were made expertly. We saw him make a Manhattan for another patron, and it was stirred and garnished with an amarena. We hope to make it back tomorrow to try other craft cocktails.
Service: 5
We really enjoyed our meal there. We had the pork with the apple slaw and a wedge salad. Both were great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A long day walking the island left me with a bit of a hunger. So headed out to a place recommended by a couple at breakfast this morning. And they were spot on. Had a nice local lager. Then the fried Brussels sprouts with Oysters. ? they were amazing. Tasted so good. Followed by the fish of the day. Though quite pricey it was well worth it. So even if the place had been a small hole in the wall the food would have made it worth the visit. But the place is a fun place. A bit rock and roll, live bands on the weekend, not when I was there. But it was a good place to sit and eat dinner. If you get a chance eat here do it. Don’t hesitate.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place has a very cool atmosphere, designed like a rustic wooden barn, which adds a lot of charm. The menu is large and accommodating, offering plenty of options for everyone. While the cocktails were just okay, I'd recommend sticking to wine or beer. The highlight for me was the vegetarian curry—absolutely delicious! Overall, a great spot with a unique vibe.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Brussel Sprouts
LOVE this spot. The food was amazing! And Molly, our waitress, was amazing. Our drinks came out super fast and the food was delicious!!!!! Highly recommend the Port Hunter.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fresh Oysters, Burrata
Had the scallops and wedge salad. Was tasty but not memorable. The oysters were very nice! You decide if cost is worth it…
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Fresh Oysters
Cool restaurant with good food. The fluke with coconut was amazing! Very nice staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Fantastic restaurant with amazing food and super staff, the plant based menu is great! The spicy brussels sprouts and grilled corn were the best we've ever had. The curry bowl and tofu tacos were also super tasty. Very well thought out vegan options that were incredibly tasty. This was an amazing meal on the evening of my partners 50th birthday whilst celebrating in Martha's Vineyard.
Excellent food, service and vibe. Do not miss this place in beautiful Edgartown. We will be back for sure. Parking is challenging. It gets full fast, reservations are necessary.
Parking: We parked at a nearby parking lot, about 2 blocks away. It was the last spot, I recommend to have a little extra time to hunt for parking elsewhere at the street.
Wheelchair accessibility: Street level, wheelchair friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fresh Oysters, Seafood Chowder, Burrata, Fish Tacos, Tuna Special
Restaurantji Recommends
Food and service were outstanding. Reasonably priced. Ordered Oysters Rockefeller, wedge salad, and key lime pie. Molly our waitress was attentive and professional. Sitting on the sidewalk was quieter than inside and fun. Would very highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Problems always arise. It’s how they are handled where the true colors are shown.
Last night, I went with a group of 6 for dinner. The appetizers were good. We had the buffalo brussel sprouts and the fluke ceviche.
Dinner was not good. I had “The Tuna”. It came out looking quite appetizing. However, after tasting it, it was clear something was not right. Perhaps it had spoiled or was some other bad piece of fish, but it smelled bad. I didn’t eat any of it.
The server didn’t come back to check on the food until the rest of our group was done eating. At that point, I mentioned something was not right. They did not offer me another entree. They did not offer to take this off the bill. Not did anyone else from the restaurant come over to investigate.
There are so many other choices in Edgartown. Go somewhere else.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 1
Fun spot at night
First of all, the front of house service was excellent. Sadly, the food was sub par overall.
We sent back the buffalo brussel sprouts app. It was drowning in what tasted like Frank's Red Hot sauce and I found it inedible. They brought us a new order with the sauce on the side, but the brussel sprouts were so over-fried that you almost couldn't tell they were once green vegetables.
For $28, the chicken sandwich should be very delicious, memorable even, and we thought it was just ok. The french fries were very overcooked. On a good note, I had the scallops special and it was very tasty for $52.
Our cocktails were weak and not remarkable and almost $20 each.
We walked out disappointed after spending $180 for two of us, with tip. Went to Mad Martha's for an ice cream cone to feel better about our evening.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
The food here is excellent. We had four in our party. The tuna dish was delicious. One person had the hamburger and he thoroughly enjoyed his meal. The french fries are freshly cut. Balsamic dressing on the burrata was a little on the sweet side. This place is wonderful. Great service. Would definitely go back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...