The Terrace | Charlotte Inn

Always exceptional. One of our favorite places to dine when we are in the Vineyard. Elegant and discreet, feels like you have traveled back in time. Food is divine.

What a vibe!
It was one of the best experiences ever and definitely what we needed as someone who is working and living in a busy seasonal place.

The food and drinks were nothing short of exceptional. Every dish we tried was beautifully presented and full of flavor, clearly crafted with care and high-quality ingredients. The wine selection and cocktails were equally impressive—thoughtfully curated and expertly mixed.

The atmosphere is intimate and serene, with a timeless, old-world charm that sets it apart from anything else on the island. The décor is exquisite—classic yet cozy, with rich details that make you feel like you’ve stepped into another era. It’s the kind of place that instantly makes you slow down and savor the moment. If you have time, you should have a drink in the green room, before or after dinner, just to reflect a little bit.

What really elevates The Terrace, though, is the staff. Warm, knowledgeable, and genuinely welcoming, they strike the perfect balance between professionalism and friendliness. From the moment we arrived until the last course was served, we felt truly cared for. We are thankfull for everyone.

This is not just a restaurant—it’s an experience. If you’re on Martha’s Vineyard and looking for something special, The Terrace at the Charlotte Inn is a must. 10/10

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Excellent and perfect place. You made us feel like royalty. Your entire staff should be proud. Food was excellent.

The Terrace & their staff was the highlight of our time in Edgartown. We experienced one of the best meals that we have had in a while. The attention to detail and quality of service was second to none. We even came back for a second evening - they remembered us, our lovely conversations from the night before and even our orders (the gnocchi and martinis were so great we repeated the meal two nights in a row). We loved learning about the hotel, its history, and the way in which this is a special passion project for the owner - it truly shows in every detail. We appreciate the neat dress code as well as the reminder when calling to confirm the reservation.

Vince was particularly hospitable. He went above and beyond in helping us feel welcome and even arranged for us to enjoy drinks prior to our reservation in a beautiful corner of the hotel.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Absolutely delightful hotel and restaurant. From the ambience to the service we felt so welcomed and cared for. The prices definitely match the quality and the Dover sole was probably one of the best dishes I have had in my life, and I have been to over 30+ Michelin star restaurants. The staff was so welcoming and helpful without the feeling of pretentiousness. That is a delicate line to walk and they walked it with grace. Will come again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

A True Gem on Martha’s Vineyard – Refined, Relaxed, and Remarkably Delicious**

The Terrace is hands down our favourite spot on the island. It strikes a rare balance: refined without being stuffy, elegant without an ounce of pretension. Think English country club charm meets island calm — it’s beautiful, unique, and instantly welcoming.

The patio is pure magic — a serene escape from the Vineyard buzz, perfect for long dinners and easy conversation. The food? Simply the best we’ve had on MVY. Every dish is thoughtfully prepared, full of flavor, and presented with care. This isn’t just another “nice meal out” — it’s the kind of dining experience you remember long after the trip is over.

A huge part of what makes The Terrace special is the team. The waitstaff, many of whom come from Europe, are exceptional — smart, attentive, genuinely kind, and effortlessly professional. And then there’s Vincent, the manager, whose European charm and watchful eye elevate the whole experience. He makes you feel like a regular from your very first visit.

Whether you’re celebrating something big or just want an evening that feels like a treat, The Terrace delivers — every time. It’s not just fine dining; it’s dining done right.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We went here for our anniversary. This is a special place! The property is beautiful and the food and the service were excellent! Prices were on the high side but worth the ambiance and the treat.

While the atmosphere is beautiful, we were disappointed with the experience. The staff is very pretentious and called us before to make sure we were “familiar with the dress code.” This could be looked past except for the food was very expensive and not worth the price. It was quiet and stuffy in there. There were only a few options on the menu and nothing peaked our interest. The staff asked our friends if they were “familiar with their dress code and prices” when trying to make a reservation. If you are looking for a fun and tastey dinner this is not the place. If you are looking for a pretentious, expensive, and uppety, place then come here. Also, we were seated outside and asked to be moved. The staff told us they were booked and acted like it was an inconvenience to squeeze us inside. As the night went on we noticed that they were in fact, not fully booked and there were several empty tables.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 1

This restaurant should be the prototype of where a gourmet dinner evening should occur. The setting is elegant and beautiful. The staff is perfect with exquisite manners, care and skills. The food could not be better. The dishes are very well presented. The biggest plus is that there is no noise problem. Most restaurants today have horrendous noise levels making good conversation difficult. The Terrace is just right in every aspect of the ambience. This place is unquestionably the best restaurant on Martha's Vineyard. You will spend about $120/diner if you don't choose an expensive wine.

What an exceptional place! There clearly has been put a lot of thought into decorations and ambiance. From the moment you walk in it feels like you walk into another world with so much attention to detail.
Service and service was exceptional. Definitely recommend if you're looking for a special experience in Edgartown.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I recently revisited this restaurant after having a great experience there about a year ago. While the atmosphere remains absolutely stunning—beautifully designed and a pleasure to be in—the food and drinks were unfortunately disappointing this time around.

The dishes felt overpriced for what was served. There was little to no attention to presentation, and the flavors were nothing special. The flounder dish, in particular, tasted like something from a budget diner—not what you’d expect given the upscale setting and prices.

As for drinks, they were just as underwhelming as I remembered from our last visit. I ordered an Old Fashioned and was served a glass filled to the brim with ice, rather than the expected large, single cube that preserves the drink’s integrity. It felt careless.

It’s a shame because this place has real potential with its incredible ambiance. Sadly, the culinary side doesn’t live up to it .

A very subpar meal with wonderful ambiance. The terrace tables were in a lovely setting next to the fountain. The inside was well decorated with antiques.

The food, however, was borderline bad and the entire experience was not worth the high cost. Their pretentious dress code and cold staff would be something I could look past if the food was actually good but we were all left very disappointed.

The scallops were extremely salty, making them hard to eat. The chicken was the most insulting $56 dish I have ever seen. It looked so unappetizing which the rice, diced chicken, and sauce that were all the same color. The lobster was nothing special.

Two in our party ordered the lamb medium rare and both were well done. It was easy the worst lamb dish we have ever been served.

While the property is lovely, it is not worth the ridiculously high prices for poor food. We would not return.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 3

Everything was excellent except for the limited dessert selection.. Can hardly wait to return.

The Charlotte Inn is a true gem in edgartown and truly special place. The Terrace Inn is no exception with amazing food and service in a location and dining room to match. We ate in the garden which is magical and so peaceful and elegant. I have eaten in many three star Michelin restaurants but find the caring staff and warm heart of the island unmatched!

Exceeded my expectation! The timeless elegance, romantic atmosphere, and excellent service made my dinner at the Terrace an unforgettable experience. Thank you!