Kids really enjoyed the ice cream. The black sesame ice cream was very good. Unfortunately, they were sold out of Matcha. My only complaint is that I wish they take credit card.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jan Siderius
Excellent spacious ice cream parlor with lots of amazing flavors and beu friendly staff. Must stop when in
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Brian Fitzpatrick
Not homemade. Expensive and small portions of run of the mill Gifford’s ice cream. You can buy this at Stop & Shop. They charge $9 for 8 oz here! It’s decent ice cream but this is a rip off.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 1
Rachel Burnard
Very mediocre ice cream and average / OK at best. I would not recommend this place for ice cream or go back myself. There is better ice cream in Oaks Bluff. This place is also overpriced - one scoop (size small) costs $7. Service is good - very quick and efficient employees that help long lines go quickly!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Dominique Nerriere
Great location with a nice ice cream selection. Very friendly owner
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
jack phelan
We’ve been having ice cream in edgartown for my entire life. Go here instead of Mad Martha’s. Scoops is better. Soft serve is great and rhetorical black raspberry is delicious. Ambiance is meh at scoops but Mad Martha’s totally removed all the fun decorations that used to make it more fun and make up for worse ice cream.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Caroline Miller
They really don't have nondairy ice cream. They have sorbet. Disappointing after driving all the way here and parking very far away
Jane Ma Nolan
I stopped by for ice cream twice last week with my husband and want to shout out the nice young lady who was working both evenings we visited! She was so friendly, welcoming, and helpful to us and our dog! The ice cream is good too (we tried the strawberry cheesecake, cookie dough, and other flavors), and the homemade waffle cones ($1.50 extra - a bargain for the quality) are the best ones we’ve ever eaten: they are buttery, decadent, and somehow don’t get soggy!In addition to hard ice cream, the shop also sells a variety of soft-serve ice cream flavors, a sugar-free hard ice cream flavor (coffee at the time we visited), some sorbet, and sodas.Overal, highly recommend! We will be back!Cash only and there is an ATM inside.
Ryan Meo
My favorite ice cream in Edgartown. It has that homemade taste made with love & experience. Look for the owner,depicted in paintings through the store, quietly observing from a bench inside.
John Hobby
Best ice cream on the island- cones are made (on site) to perfection. If you want the salted caramel, come early!
Sorbet ice cream ( wildberry and lemonade) both are good , they accept cash only and there is ATM inside their store. They have a variety of flavors and you can taste if you want.
Jeff F
Both my wife and my ice cream was very, very good (she had chocolate and I had black raspberry). I just docked one star because the waffle cones were a bit soft (I prefer them crisp).
Sandra Rea-McGinty
Huge disappointment. The server girl was nice. But come on...$11.50 for a single scoop of ice cream with hot fudge and whipped cream????? Insane.
Muneerah
Sorbet ice cream ( wildberry and lemonade) both are good , they accept cash only and there is ATM inside their store. They have a variety of flavors and you can taste if you want.
Jeff Fairbairn
Both my wife and my ice cream was very, very good (she had chocolate and I had black raspberry). I just docked one star because the waffle cones were a bit soft (I prefer them crisp).
Kids really enjoyed the ice cream. The black sesame ice cream was very good. Unfortunately, they were sold out of Matcha. My only complaint is that I wish they take credit card.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent spacious ice cream parlor with lots of amazing flavors and beu friendly staff. Must stop when in
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Not homemade. Expensive and small portions of run of the mill Gifford’s ice cream. You can buy this at Stop & Shop. They charge $9 for 8 oz here! It’s decent ice cream but this is a rip off.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 1
Very mediocre ice cream and average / OK at best. I would not recommend this place for ice cream or go back myself. There is better ice cream in Oaks Bluff. This place is also overpriced - one scoop (size small) costs $7. Service is good - very quick and efficient employees that help long lines go quickly!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Great location with a nice ice cream selection. Very friendly owner
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
We’ve been having ice cream in edgartown for my entire life. Go here instead of Mad Martha’s. Scoops is better. Soft serve is great and rhetorical black raspberry is delicious.
Ambiance is meh at scoops but Mad Martha’s totally removed all the fun decorations that used to make it more fun and make up for worse ice cream.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
They really don't have nondairy ice cream. They have sorbet. Disappointing after driving all the way here and parking very far away
I stopped by for ice cream twice last week with my husband and want to shout out the nice young lady who was working both evenings we visited! She was so friendly, welcoming, and helpful to us and our dog! The ice cream is good too (we tried the strawberry cheesecake, cookie dough, and other flavors), and the homemade waffle cones ($1.50 extra - a bargain for the quality) are the best ones we’ve ever eaten: they are buttery, decadent, and somehow don’t get soggy!In addition to hard ice cream, the shop also sells a variety of soft-serve ice cream flavors, a sugar-free hard ice cream flavor (coffee at the time we visited), some sorbet, and sodas.Overal, highly recommend! We will be back!Cash only and there is an ATM inside.
My favorite ice cream in Edgartown. It has that homemade taste made with love & experience. Look for the owner,depicted in paintings through the store, quietly observing from a bench inside.
Best ice cream on the island- cones are made (on site) to perfection. If you want the salted caramel, come early!
Restaurantji Recommends
Sorbet ice cream ( wildberry and lemonade) both are good , they accept cash only and there is ATM inside their store. They have a variety of flavors and you can taste if you want.
Both my wife and my ice cream was very, very good (she had chocolate and I had black raspberry). I just docked one star because the waffle cones were a bit soft (I prefer them crisp).
Huge disappointment. The server girl was nice. But come on...$11.50 for a single scoop of ice cream with hot fudge and whipped cream????? Insane.
Sorbet ice cream ( wildberry and lemonade) both are good , they accept cash only and there is ATM inside their store. They have a variety of flavors and you can taste if you want.
Both my wife and my ice cream was very, very good (she had chocolate and I had black raspberry). I just docked one star because the waffle cones were a bit soft (I prefer them crisp).
Loading...