Surprisingly disappointed, first time I've ever not finished an ice cream in a homemade waffle cone; this cone was gritty and tasted like a Biscoff cookie, not the usual light vanilla waffle flavor.
Alexzondra DuPree
My go to ice cream stop on the Vineyard every summer season. Love the wonderful balkan ladies behind each ice cream scoop or acai bowl. Thank you to each and everyone of you for all the sweet treats and good laughs. Till next summer ladies! Vidimos!
Samantha Karchmer
The ice cream flavors are excellent, and I especially recommend the homemade waffle cone. Unfortunately, my experience was overshadowed by the extremely rude treatment we received from a young woman working behind the counter. I rarely ever leave reviews like this, but the level of unprofessionalism was beyond unacceptable.
We arrived around 10 p.m. The doors were propped wide open, lights were on, music was playing loudly, and several other customers were inside. When we approached the counter, the woman greeted us curtly. When my partner asked for an extra moment to decide on a flavor, she snapped, “We’re trying to close,” and grimaced.
I ordered the black sesame soft serve in a cone. She attempted to make it, then abruptly said the machine was broken, hitting it several times in frustration. Instead of offering an alternative, she just stared at me with a rude expression. My partner, so put off by her demeanor, decided not to order at all. When we paid, she tossed our change at us as we left.
The ice cream itself was wonderful, but the hostility of the service completely ruined what should have been a pleasant evening walk in Edgartown.
Anastassiya Petrova
Loved it! Lots of classic flavors, topping and the star of the show - homemade cone. So soft yet crunchy, reminded me of childhood.
Jen Nelson
Fantastic ice cream. Cash only, no credit cards.
Anja Šimpraga
The ice cream was the best I have ever tried! Girls Anica, Anja and Marina were amazing.
Cheers To You Inc
Outstanding homemade ice cream, 5 stars!
Maggie J
This was the only ice cream shop in Edgartown that we had yet to try so we decided it was finally time. The shop has never been very crowded when we walk by but on the evening of July 3rd (a Thursday), the spot was bopping. One of the main reasons for our visit was that this is one of the only places where you can get froyo in the area. We did not get ice cream so I can’t speak to that but the frozen yogurt was good. It wasn’t our favorite ice cream shop in the neighborhood and it was a little annoying that it’s cash only.
ali rose
yummy and loaded my whipped cream love it
Rui Higuchi
Kids really enjoyed the ice cream. The black sesame ice cream was very good. Unfortunately, they were sold out of Matcha. My only complaint is that I wish they take credit card.
Excellent spacious ice cream parlor with lots of amazing flavors and beu friendly staff. Must stop when in
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Brian Fitzpatrick
Not homemade. Expensive and small portions of run of the mill Gifford’s ice cream. You can buy this at Stop & Shop. They charge $9 for 8 oz here! It’s decent ice cream but this is a rip off.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 1
Rachel Burnard
Very mediocre ice cream and average / OK at best. I would not recommend this place for ice cream or go back myself. There is better ice cream in Oaks Bluff. This place is also overpriced - one scoop (size small) costs $7. Service is good - very quick and efficient employees that help long lines go quickly!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Dominique Nerriere
Great location with a nice ice cream selection. Very friendly owner
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
jack phelan
We’ve been having ice cream in edgartown for my entire life. Go here instead of Mad Martha’s. Scoops is better. Soft serve is great and rhetorical black raspberry is delicious. Ambiance is meh at scoops but Mad Martha’s totally removed all the fun decorations that used to make it more fun and make up for worse ice cream.
Surprisingly disappointed, first time I've ever not finished an ice cream in a homemade waffle cone; this cone was gritty and tasted like a Biscoff cookie, not the usual light vanilla waffle flavor.
My go to ice cream stop on the Vineyard every summer season. Love the wonderful balkan ladies behind each ice cream scoop or acai bowl. Thank you to each and everyone of you for all the sweet treats and good laughs. Till next summer ladies! Vidimos!
The ice cream flavors are excellent, and I especially recommend the homemade waffle cone. Unfortunately, my experience was overshadowed by the extremely rude treatment we received from a young woman working behind the counter. I rarely ever leave reviews like this, but the level of unprofessionalism was beyond unacceptable.
We arrived around 10 p.m. The doors were propped wide open, lights were on, music was playing loudly, and several other customers were inside. When we approached the counter, the woman greeted us curtly. When my partner asked for an extra moment to decide on a flavor, she snapped, “We’re trying to close,” and grimaced.
I ordered the black sesame soft serve in a cone. She attempted to make it, then abruptly said the machine was broken, hitting it several times in frustration. Instead of offering an alternative, she just stared at me with a rude expression. My partner, so put off by her demeanor, decided not to order at all. When we paid, she tossed our change at us as we left.
The ice cream itself was wonderful, but the hostility of the service completely ruined what should have been a pleasant evening walk in Edgartown.
Loved it! Lots of classic flavors, topping and the star of the show - homemade cone. So soft yet crunchy, reminded me of childhood.
Fantastic ice cream. Cash only, no credit cards.
The ice cream was the best I have ever tried! Girls Anica, Anja and Marina were amazing.
Outstanding homemade ice cream, 5 stars!
This was the only ice cream shop in Edgartown that we had yet to try so we decided it was finally time. The shop has never been very crowded when we walk by but on the evening of July 3rd (a Thursday), the spot was bopping. One of the main reasons for our visit was that this is one of the only places where you can get froyo in the area. We did not get ice cream so I can’t speak to that but the frozen yogurt was good. It wasn’t our favorite ice cream shop in the neighborhood and it was a little annoying that it’s cash only.
yummy and loaded my whipped cream love it
Kids really enjoyed the ice cream. The black sesame ice cream was very good. Unfortunately, they were sold out of Matcha. My only complaint is that I wish they take credit card.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent spacious ice cream parlor with lots of amazing flavors and beu friendly staff. Must stop when in
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Not homemade. Expensive and small portions of run of the mill Gifford’s ice cream. You can buy this at Stop & Shop. They charge $9 for 8 oz here! It’s decent ice cream but this is a rip off.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 1
Very mediocre ice cream and average / OK at best. I would not recommend this place for ice cream or go back myself. There is better ice cream in Oaks Bluff. This place is also overpriced - one scoop (size small) costs $7. Service is good - very quick and efficient employees that help long lines go quickly!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Great location with a nice ice cream selection. Very friendly owner
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
We’ve been having ice cream in edgartown for my entire life. Go here instead of Mad Martha’s. Scoops is better. Soft serve is great and rhetorical black raspberry is delicious.
Ambiance is meh at scoops but Mad Martha’s totally removed all the fun decorations that used to make it more fun and make up for worse ice cream.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Loading...