Great place to relax, have a great meal with super service! Our waiter Dexter was the best!
Richard
Hidden gem! The outdoor seating by the pond was awesome, and the food was great: our party of three loved the Reuben, The Double Cheeseburger and the Turkey Suppah! The Manhattans were generous also! :)
John
We have been going for many years. Staff knows we are frequent customers. We have never been asked to pay a extra $2 for a substitution to a baked potato till last night. Service was good, food was good, just very disappointed being told to pay extra for potato!! May not go this often in future.
kh42
Food was good, atmosphere was nice- we had main dining room to ourselves as we were a large group. Dexter our waiter was great. Very contentious- put kids order in first,and did a great job. Had a lot of laughs with him.
Lisa
We attended their Sunday Brunch on Father's Day and it was scrumptious! They did a great job managing the large number of folks that attended. We'd definitely return if we were in the area.
Carol
We always love the sunday brunch at Eli's Tavern. The buffet is extensive and everything is delicious. The service is great too. Bloody Marys are excellent! Can't wait to go back.
R Peterson
Just awesome
Maria Vultao
If i could give this place a -10 i would. Not only was my food cold but the staff was incredibly rude. When I brought it up to the server she rolled her eyes at me, and management wasn’t any better. Don’t waste your time or money here.
Tim Tedford
Everything about this place was horrible. I made a google account just to write a terrible review. Do not go here ! And management is an absolute joke. I would give a 0 out of 5 if it would let me.
Management was absolute terrible to staff will not be back here.
Ed Montani
We go there at least twice a month but will not be going there much anymore as they have raised the price of drinks incredibly high $14.50 for a Captain Morgan and Diet Coke that is ridiculous and they did this on January 1st their slowest season…absurd. It’s unfortunate because we always enjoy the food, bartenders and the weight staff, but will not be paying those ridiculous prices for drinks. They are not even consistent with othe restaurants in the area.
Annmarie Perkins
I had to send my steak tips back twice, I asked for medium and it came back medium rare both times, my boyfriend enjoyed his prime rib
Katheryn Chasse
Linda and Prudence are the wonderful bartenders.!!
Noelle G.
Cozy place to get dinner and a drink after a day exploring the Cape. Our server (Kymani) was so incredibly sweet and attentive, and the food was delicious. We ordered the turkey supper, elote quesadillas, Jamaican stew and BLT and everything was outstanding, and the portion sizes were very generous. A word of advice - if you get the carrot cake, be prepared to split with the entire group because it is truly HUGE (not that I am complaining - enjoyed it for breakfast the next day!!) Wonderful experience overall.
Great place to relax, have a great meal with super service! Our waiter Dexter was the best!
Hidden gem! The outdoor seating by the pond was awesome, and the food was great: our party of three loved the Reuben, The Double Cheeseburger and the Turkey Suppah! The Manhattans were generous also! :)
We have been going for many years. Staff knows we are frequent customers. We have never been asked to pay a extra $2 for a substitution to a baked potato till last night. Service was good, food was good, just very disappointed being told to pay extra for potato!! May not go this often in future.
Food was good, atmosphere was nice- we had main dining room to ourselves as we were a large group. Dexter our waiter was great. Very contentious- put kids order in first,and did a great job. Had a lot of laughs with him.
We attended their Sunday Brunch on Father's Day and it was scrumptious! They did a great job managing the large number of folks that attended. We'd definitely return if we were in the area.
We always love the sunday brunch at Eli's Tavern. The buffet is extensive and everything is delicious. The service is great too. Bloody Marys are excellent! Can't wait to go back.
Just awesome
If i could give this place a -10 i would. Not only was my food cold but the staff was incredibly rude. When I brought it up to the server she rolled her eyes at me, and management wasn’t any better. Don’t waste your time or money here.
Everything about this place was horrible. I made a google account just to write a terrible review. Do not go here ! And management is an absolute joke. I would give a 0 out of 5 if it would let me.
Incredibly negative experience
Restaurantji Recommends
Management was absolute terrible to staff will not be back here.
We go there at least twice a month but will not be going there much anymore as they have raised the price of drinks incredibly high $14.50 for a Captain Morgan and Diet Coke that is ridiculous and they did this on January 1st their slowest season…absurd. It’s unfortunate because we always enjoy the food, bartenders and the weight staff, but will not be paying those ridiculous prices for drinks. They are not even consistent with othe restaurants in the area.
I had to send my steak tips back twice, I asked for medium and it came back medium rare both times, my boyfriend enjoyed his prime rib
Linda and Prudence are the wonderful bartenders.!!
Cozy place to get dinner and a drink after a day exploring the Cape. Our server (Kymani) was so incredibly sweet and attentive, and the food was delicious. We ordered the turkey supper, elote quesadillas, Jamaican stew and BLT and everything was outstanding, and the portion sizes were very generous. A word of advice - if you get the carrot cake, be prepared to split with the entire group because it is truly HUGE (not that I am complaining - enjoyed it for breakfast the next day!!) Wonderful experience overall.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Turkey Suppah, Carrot Cake
Loading...