Anthony's Pizzeria

754 Plain St, Marshfield
(781) 837-4442

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Mohhamed Hijab

Listen, I’m from Iraq. I’ve seen regimes fall, leaders change, borders shift… but THIS pizza? Solid. Stable. Reliable. I've spent my whole life eating sheep meat and goat milk, if I found about this restaurant before I would've migrated to the US while ago.

Athena Stamatos

I'd been meaning to check out the pizza here forever, and boy oh boyyy did they not disappoint. I ordered the Hot Honey Rony Ricotta pizza and it was worth every penny. Imagine biting into beautiful clouds of mozzarella, buratta, and dollops of ricotta, then decorate that with honey drizzle and little rays of pepperoni happiness, and garnish that with the most flagrant basil. The Greek gods did not disappoint. Service was great too, and parking was easy. Looking forward to trying out more from their menu next time.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tyla Russell

Pizza slices bigger than you! Greek salad was great 👍🏻

Lucas Fitzpatrick

Anthony’s used to be my favorite pizza in town but they have completely changed their pies. Got it for the first time in about two years and it was so disappointing. It used to have a really thick crust but the new pizzas look completely different. Hope they bring back the way they used to make pizzas because this place went from the best to absolute worst pizza in town.

Food: 1

Pat Day

The best meatball sub in many years!!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Katherine Donnelly

You guys know how to do it! Perfect calzone! I could taste the love🪄

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ashley Jonhson

Extremely rude cashier.

Service: 1

Brannon Soter

Great food and service, recommend to anyone

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Leonardo Toscano

This place is a hidden gem! Awesome food and great service. Try the hot honey pepperoni slice. Looks like a piece of art taste like a piece of Heaven!

Nik Tsoukales

Best Pizza by far in the entire south shore. if you haven't gone, you're missing out. Word don't do these PIES the justice they deserve!! The south shore super slice is taking over one bite at a time baby!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jim Sickorez

Amazing pizza...The pictures are from our most recent take out order...We love the hot honey Roni ricotta!! A work of art!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

John Gray

One of the best pizzas around.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Wyatt Adams

Pizza was good by the slice, and the crust was perfect! Little expensive but worth the cost.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Philip Davis

Ordered sandwiches to go. Great variety, full fills, very fresh and tasty made while waited and a good variety of drinks.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

William Drozdal II

Had a rap kind of pathetic very loose, not made with what look like. Fresh ingredients ordered the pizza. A plain Cheese Pizza to be safe and lackluster sauce tasted like it was watered down. Sendoubt, I've been in the restaurant business. 50 years retired been there. Done that had everything and this is not really what I expected. 50 bucks gone down. The drain I will not be back. I think they should pick up. They're game and train.Maybe take some education courses.Cooking courses, presentation courses really not what I expected had to ask 2 or 3 × 4 napkins.They're look at you like.They're kind of stupid looking forward to that.Meanwhile checked it out

Loading...