Smitty's Homemade Ice Cream

538 Falmouth Rd, Mashpee
(774) 392-2805

Recent Reviews

Shubhra Ramchandani

Service was very friendly. Large outdoor area with comfortable seating. Hours open don't match hours listed on website. Icecream quality is mediocre relative to other MA homemade ice-cream stores.

Alfred New

Delicious. Very interesting flavors. Celiac and Gluten-free friendly. Staff is very friendly.

Gia Baldassano

BRIDGET was so helpful!!! Stayed open a couple minutes late to help us out! Great ice cream!

Planet Ganju

I LOOOOVE their ice cream!!! The flavors are delicious, I ❤️ cookie dough!

Jessie K.

Cash only fyi. My favorite ice cream place; raspberry truffle is my go to. Line can look long but it moves pretty quickly

Scott J.

Fabulous, welcoming ice cream store with delicious ice cream, good portions, and lovely young college kids serving. The rasberry truffle and chocolate peanut butter are two highly recommended flavors. Even the dogs love their pops! Fun to sit outside on picnic benches. Highly recommended

Dawn Z.

Great ice cream. We didn't try them but they also have sundaes, frappes and more. Parking lot was large enough for us to park our truck camper and outdoor seating was clean and spacious.

Juliana

BEST COOKIE DOUGH! If you like your cookie dough ice cream with a ton of cookie dough pieces this is the place to go!!! They also have homemade waffle cones !

Wendi Bibo

So delicious! Our usual place was closed tonight but this will be our new go to! Cherry Amaretto was the best!!!!

Sandra Wilcox

Cash only! Terrific variety of ice creams on different cones or dish.

Paul Thompson

Great ice cream and flavors. Good staff. Quick service.

Lisa Haley

Excellent ice cream, good sizes great service.

J K.

I had ordered chocolate walnut ice cream (my favorite) earlier in summer and it was excellent...lots of walnuts. I ordered it today and after a few mouthfuls I thought they gave me the wrong ice cream...just plain chocolate (which I do not like plain) and thought a saw something after double checking the flavor. there was the tiniest piece of walnut. I then tasted it again and found another very tiny piece. They now have cut back to the point you can say there are no walnuts. My palate lost complete interest in it...for 8.00 including a tip I will never go back. buyer beware

Lindsey Fuchs

Our favorite ice cream place on the cape! Lots of flavors of hard ice cream to choose from and all of the ones we have tried are rich and fresh. Cookie dough has a generous amount of dough pieces. My son loved his soft twist.

Lisa

Delicious ice cream in amazing and abundant flavors! Suggest skipping dessert at restaurants within Mashpee Commons and going here after dinner instead. Your mouth and tummy will thank you.

Load More