Good pizza and the options the offer are quite nice. The only problem I have with them sometimes is the wait it's the longest for any pizza place I have been too
KX
Pros:* Fresh ingredients with amazing quality! I rarely ever visit a pizza place with this much care in the ingredients used.* Fun themed pizzas like fig and honey!* Slight spicy kick in some of their pizzas, which I loved. Doesn't make the pizza bland, and was a joy to taste and eat.Cons:* The dough was chewy (it's not hard). I struggled eating the crust. I placed a slice in microwave, covered it with a wet paper towel, and set the timer for 30 seconds. This resulted in a pillowy soft crust that I like.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Danny Fish
I really don't know how it's taking me this long to get to this dang place. And I live 15 minutes away. What a little gem. Had the prosciutto/fig pizza and it was perfect. But it didn't end there. The chicken wings are some of the better wings I've ever had. Perfectly cooked. You have a choice of sauces and I highly recommend the sautéed onions. Plus, they've got a killer beer selection, and the place has such a great, homey feel. I just loved it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Danny F.
How in the hell do we live in Sandwich and are just getting to this place? Sooooo good. Had the fig/prosciutto pizza and ooh la la. But it didn't end there. The wings were some of the best I've ever had. Absolutely perfectly cooked. You have a choice of dips, but I highly recommend the sautéed onions. This is a killer spot I can't wait to go back to.
Andrew Ambrosio
5 Stars in Friendliness & 5 Stars as a Long Islander trying pizza here for the first time!!??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stuart Smith
My favorite pizza joint in Cape Cod. Cool vintage theme inside with lots of awesome memorabilia. Show up to the counter, place your order, pay and sit down and they deliver the pizza to your table so, simple service but man are the pizzas good. Personally I enjoy the Goddess - the banana peppers make it so good and the steakenator if you are hungry is delicious.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
E P.
I had high hopes for this place, however, it fell a bit short. The service was quick and friendly which was nice, but the food left something to be desired. The large pizza was $28- I thought, this going to be good. The crust was nice and crunchy but flavorless and the toppings were soggy. The boneless "chicken wings" were huge, the order came with four, again very wet, The meat was very tender but no crunch at all. Just soggy meat. For an extra charge they offer sauced which is essentially the tenders being drizzled with sauced right in the container, not tossed. Pretty disappointed with our first time here. The prices are a little outrageous. May try one more time and see if it was an off night.
Jason Cleary
Is this place ever opened? I’ve tried going here about a dozen times and it’s always closed. How do they make money to stay open? I have no idea. Maybe the pizza is good for the cape but I wouldn’t know bc they’re never opened. (This review is on a Sunday at 4pm and there closed)
Service: 1
Mary B.
Delicious pizza and subs! Just wish they could extend their hours! Definitely the place to go for great food!
Georgianna Radford
Use to love this place till I found out they don’t give there workers the tips and they keep them for themselves… and I have also heard that they use racial terms against their customers after they leave, Making fun of peoples names because they are ethnic sounding. Heard they are selling the business also. Good, get some respectful people who treat everyone nicely.
Great gourmet pizza, this is far from run of the house pizza shops, this is high end pizzas, made with the finest ingredients. Try their frappes!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mac Daddy Pizza, Sausage, Roasted, Chicken Bacon
Tim Gago
First time trying Wildfire. Phoned in an order. Was quoted 10 minutes or 45 minutes. Went with the 10 minute time slot. Hustled to get their on time and of course it took 30 minutes. ??♂️usually not an issue, but when you pull up with your boat you want to be in and out. Good thing they make a decent pizza or it would be a one and done. Went with a small meatlovers minus the meatball. Good amount of toppings, cooked well. Very good overall tasting. A little grease, but not bad. Sauce was good. Crust had a decent crunch along the edges. Pizza had a little flop but not bad. Very good undercarriage. Very good cheese and good overall taste. Very good overall pizza. They have a very unique rotating oven. No drinking on that job. Pizza gets a Google 4, 7.3 out of ten.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Jeff Myers
I’m very picky about pizzas and this amazing restaurant consistently blows me away. I would strongly suggest you go with whatever the receptionist recommends. For us it was a seasonal pie with mozzarella and ricotta geese’s, apples, cinnamon (yes!!) brown sugar and some other stuff that I can’t remember because we dug into it so fast. The best part was the amazing crust. More thick than thin thick and slightly bread-y but not too thick or bread-youth some incredible spices. And the best part: it was still amazing reheated for lunch today. Congrats to an amazing staff for making it a fun and super-tasty experience. (PS…during summer go in or order early. They get slammed and now you know why)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Dan M.
Good pizza, used to go there frequently, but never again. Recently went to pick up a take out order and noticed that in their chalk board, where they listed their beers, they had out X's through Bud Light. I thought it was odd that that they didn't just erase it, but realized they were going out of their way to make a statement of hate. They certainly have that right and I have the right not to ever patronize them again and to tell people in the area who may want to do the same. You can have your beliefs, you can choose what products you want to sell, but as a business owner, it's not wise to alienate a part of your customer base and foster hate in the community where you do business. It was a childish move.
Steven Damalas
Imaginative pizza made in a brick oven, delicious baked chicken wings, homemade warm croutons on the salad. Friendly husband and wife team. Nice informal place for a decent meal.
Good pizza and the options the offer are quite nice. The only problem I have with them sometimes is the wait it's the longest for any pizza place I have been too
Pros:* Fresh ingredients with amazing quality! I rarely ever visit a pizza place with this much care in the ingredients used.* Fun themed pizzas like fig and honey!* Slight spicy kick in some of their pizzas, which I loved. Doesn't make the pizza bland, and was a joy to taste and eat.Cons:* The dough was chewy (it's not hard). I struggled eating the crust. I placed a slice in microwave, covered it with a wet paper towel, and set the timer for 30 seconds. This resulted in a pillowy soft crust that I like.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
I really don't know how it's taking me this long to get to this dang place. And I live 15 minutes away. What a little gem. Had the prosciutto/fig pizza and it was perfect. But it didn't end there. The chicken wings are some of the better wings I've ever had. Perfectly cooked. You have a choice of sauces and I highly recommend the sautéed onions. Plus, they've got a killer beer selection, and the place has such a great, homey feel. I just loved it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
How in the hell do we live in Sandwich and are just getting to this place? Sooooo good. Had the fig/prosciutto pizza and ooh la la. But it didn't end there. The wings were some of the best I've ever had. Absolutely perfectly cooked. You have a choice of dips, but I highly recommend the sautéed onions. This is a killer spot I can't wait to go back to.
5 Stars in Friendliness & 5 Stars as a Long Islander trying pizza here for the first time!!??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My favorite pizza joint in Cape Cod. Cool vintage theme inside with lots of awesome memorabilia. Show up to the counter, place your order, pay and sit down and they deliver the pizza to your table so, simple service but man are the pizzas good. Personally I enjoy the Goddess - the banana peppers make it so good and the steakenator if you are hungry is delicious.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
I had high hopes for this place, however, it fell a bit short. The service was quick and friendly which was nice, but the food left something to be desired. The large pizza was $28- I thought, this going to be good. The crust was nice and crunchy but flavorless and the toppings were soggy. The boneless "chicken wings" were huge, the order came with four, again very wet, The meat was very tender but no crunch at all. Just soggy meat. For an extra charge they offer sauced which is essentially the tenders being drizzled with sauced right in the container, not tossed. Pretty disappointed with our first time here. The prices are a little outrageous. May try one more time and see if it was an off night.
Is this place ever opened? I’ve tried going here about a dozen times and it’s always closed. How do they make money to stay open? I have no idea. Maybe the pizza is good for the cape but I wouldn’t know bc they’re never opened. (This review is on a Sunday at 4pm and there closed)
Service: 1
Delicious pizza and subs! Just wish they could extend their hours! Definitely the place to go for great food!
Use to love this place till I found out they don’t give there workers the tips and they keep them for themselves… and I have also heard that they use racial terms against their customers after they leave, Making fun of peoples names because they are ethnic sounding. Heard they are selling the business also. Good, get some respectful people who treat everyone nicely.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great gourmet pizza, this is far from run of the house pizza shops, this is high end pizzas, made with the finest ingredients. Try their frappes!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mac Daddy Pizza, Sausage, Roasted, Chicken Bacon
First time trying Wildfire. Phoned in an order. Was quoted 10 minutes or 45 minutes. Went with the 10 minute time slot. Hustled to get their on time and of course it took 30 minutes. ??♂️usually not an issue, but when you pull up with your boat you want to be in and out. Good thing they make a decent pizza or it would be a one and done. Went with a small meatlovers minus the meatball. Good amount of toppings, cooked well. Very good overall tasting. A little grease, but not bad. Sauce was good. Crust had a decent crunch along the edges. Pizza had a little flop but not bad. Very good undercarriage. Very good cheese and good overall taste. Very good overall pizza. They have a very unique rotating oven. No drinking on that job. Pizza gets a Google 4, 7.3 out of ten.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
I’m very picky about pizzas and this amazing restaurant consistently blows me away. I would strongly suggest you go with whatever the receptionist recommends. For us it was a seasonal pie with mozzarella and ricotta geese’s, apples, cinnamon (yes!!) brown sugar and some other stuff that I can’t remember because we dug into it so fast. The best part was the amazing crust. More thick than thin thick and slightly bread-y but not too thick or bread-youth some incredible spices. And the best part: it was still amazing reheated for lunch today. Congrats to an amazing staff for making it a fun and super-tasty experience. (PS…during summer go in or order early. They get slammed and now you know why)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Good pizza, used to go there frequently, but never again. Recently went to pick up a take out order and noticed that in their chalk board, where they listed their beers, they had out X's through Bud Light. I thought it was odd that that they didn't just erase it, but realized they were going out of their way to make a statement of hate. They certainly have that right and I have the right not to ever patronize them again and to tell people in the area who may want to do the same. You can have your beliefs, you can choose what products you want to sell, but as a business owner, it's not wise to alienate a part of your customer base and foster hate in the community where you do business. It was a childish move.
Imaginative pizza made in a brick oven, delicious baked chicken wings, homemade warm croutons on the salad. Friendly husband and wife team. Nice informal place for a decent meal.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4