Lovely neighborhood restaurant! Great specials and high quality made to order entrees. Huge menu! Super great customer service and deliveries! Huge portions.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Maryann MacNeil
One of the best pizza’s we’ve had in a long time. Very generous serving size of the side orders. Great value.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Logan
Huge fan of Alfredos pizza!
🍕 = ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Alfredos is one of the top pizza places in Melrose! They always make my pizza as requested and I’ve never had a bad experience at this location. The pizza sauce they use is so delicious. My go-to order is a large Cheese with Hamburger. Other pizza places use very greasy hamburger on their pizzas…not Alfredos!
They have plenty of seating inside and they keep the inside very clean. Highly recommend Alfredos in Melrose for any of your pizza needs!!
Review: June 2025
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike Longenbaker
The folks here at Alfredo's are the hardest working restaurateurs in Melrose! And they are really good at what they do! Food is fantastic. Huge portions at reasonable prices. Friendly people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Carolyn Brown
Food is always tasty! We love the chicken abruzzo.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Janice Bates
Great experience going here for the first time since they opened. Online ordering experience was easy and detailed. They also have promos that will auto populate while you're adding to your cart. We got a free cheese pizza because our cart went over a certain price, and it was a pleasant surprise. Great way to get people to try more of your food. Food is delicious and the additional bread was a nice touch. We have a lot of leftovers and ordered 2 pasta dishes for 2 people. Inside is clean and staff was friendly. Will definitely be back!
Giancarla Volpe
They have the BEST meatball subs I've ever had! And I don't usually like marinara sauce from anywhere but home!
Food: 5
Chris Scep
New take out location for me, the food hit all the spots..to the people complaining about how the owner or staff talk to you, know that it’s a New England sub shop, not Disney World hahaha
Food: 5
Peter Brownlee
The guy who takes orders over the phone has no skills to take order and every single item you order he rushes to get off the phone so I won't order nothing from them again.The food is average BTW.
Probably some of the best pizza I’ve ever had!! We live 30 minutes away and would make the drive because it’s so amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Juju Mdl
Comfortable and clean place. Excellent food. Delicious chicken fingers and vegetables pizza. I will Definitely go again to Alfred's Pizza in Melrose. Thank you 😊
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Philip Decareau
Ham and cheese calzone was terrible ate1/4 of it and threw it away, waste 27.50 for SMALL! Should have stayed closed
Food: 1
Service: 1
Lauren Fatovic, LICSW
Alfredo’s has been closed since I moved to Melrose and I’ve now gotten a chance to visit twice (my usual Melrose spot is Lisa’s on West Wyoming). Quality: Much better than Lisa’s hands down! Service: Awful. Each time I arrived for my pick up orders I was greeted rudely, once by who I think is the owner, and the other time by some young man, possibly the owner’s son. My second visit was tonight around 6:30. Obviously a busy time at a pizza place. My order’s not ready when I arrived at the designated time, no problem, to be expected. I wait a little over 10 minutes. A man who was there when I got there had just gone up to the counter to ask for an update on his order, he’s told 5-10 minutes. A moment later I approach the counter and ask the same question, the young man checks and it’s still not ready. I ask for an estimate, he says "it’s hard to say, it’s in the oven," and then says “I don’t work in the kitchen.” And yet mere moments ago you gave another customer an estimate. I wait another 5 minutes and my order is ready. Off I go and I won’t be coming back. Again, I do think their quality is better but such BAD vibes there. You go into Lisa’s and they ALWAYS greet you warmly and are not bothered if you ask for an estimate. Another good spot in town, Theo’s, I would say has the same quality as Alfredo’s, and again, much, much more pleasant staff. The world is chaotic enough as it is right now, it’s just not worth it to me to support a business that can’t even master the basics (and to boot, it's so unpleasant to wait 15 minutes in there because the TV is on so.loud.). Another reviewer noted a rude, overreaction by a staff member when placing a phone order. Rudeness is a trend here.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Owen Savage
Great Food, The staff was very friendly to me and my friends.
Great eggplant Parm and chicken cutlet subs
Lovely neighborhood restaurant! Great specials and high quality made to order entrees. Huge menu! Super great customer service and deliveries! Huge portions.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
One of the best pizza’s we’ve had in a long time. Very generous serving size of the side orders. Great value.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Huge fan of Alfredos pizza!
🍕 = ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Alfredos is one of the top pizza places in Melrose! They always make my pizza as requested and I’ve never had a bad experience at this location. The pizza sauce they use is so delicious. My go-to order is a large Cheese with Hamburger. Other pizza places use very greasy hamburger on their pizzas…not Alfredos!
They have plenty of seating inside and they keep the inside very clean. Highly recommend Alfredos in Melrose for any of your pizza needs!!
Review: June 2025
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The folks here at Alfredo's are the hardest working restaurateurs in Melrose! And they are really good at what they do! Food is fantastic. Huge portions at reasonable prices. Friendly people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food is always tasty! We love the chicken abruzzo.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great experience going here for the first time since they opened. Online ordering experience was easy and detailed. They also have promos that will auto populate while you're adding to your cart. We got a free cheese pizza because our cart went over a certain price, and it was a pleasant surprise. Great way to get people to try more of your food. Food is delicious and the additional bread was a nice touch. We have a lot of leftovers and ordered 2 pasta dishes for 2 people. Inside is clean and staff was friendly. Will definitely be back!
They have the BEST meatball subs I've ever had! And I don't usually like marinara sauce from anywhere but home!
Food: 5
New take out location for me, the food hit all the spots..to the people complaining about how the owner or staff talk to you, know that it’s a New England sub shop, not Disney World hahaha
Food: 5
The guy who takes orders over the phone has no skills to take order and every single item you order he rushes to get off the phone so I won't order nothing from them again.The food is average BTW.
Restaurantji Recommends
Probably some of the best pizza I’ve ever had!! We live 30 minutes away and would make the drive because it’s so amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Comfortable and clean place. Excellent food. Delicious chicken fingers and vegetables pizza. I will Definitely go again to Alfred's Pizza in Melrose. Thank you 😊
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ham and cheese calzone was terrible ate1/4 of it and threw it away, waste 27.50 for SMALL! Should have stayed closed
Food: 1
Service: 1
Alfredo’s has been closed since I moved to Melrose and I’ve now gotten a chance to visit twice (my usual Melrose spot is Lisa’s on West Wyoming).
Quality: Much better than Lisa’s hands down!
Service: Awful. Each time I arrived for my pick up orders I was greeted rudely, once by who I think is the owner, and the other time by some young man, possibly the owner’s son. My second visit was tonight around 6:30. Obviously a busy time at a pizza place. My order’s not ready when I arrived at the designated time, no problem, to be expected. I wait a little over 10 minutes. A man who was there when I got there had just gone up to the counter to ask for an update on his order, he’s told 5-10 minutes. A moment later I approach the counter and ask the same question, the young man checks and it’s still not ready. I ask for an estimate, he says "it’s hard to say, it’s in the oven," and then says “I don’t work in the kitchen.” And yet mere moments ago you gave another customer an estimate. I wait another 5 minutes and my order is ready. Off I go and I won’t be coming back. Again, I do think their quality is better but such BAD vibes there. You go into Lisa’s and they ALWAYS greet you warmly and are not bothered if you ask for an estimate. Another good spot in town, Theo’s, I would say has the same quality as Alfredo’s, and again, much, much more pleasant staff. The world is chaotic enough as it is right now, it’s just not worth it to me to support a business that can’t even master the basics (and to boot, it's so unpleasant to wait 15 minutes in there because the TV is on so.loud.). Another reviewer noted a rude, overreaction by a staff member when placing a phone order. Rudeness is a trend here.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Great Food, The staff was very friendly to me and my friends.
Loading...