Teresa's Italian Eatery

149 S Main St, Middleton
(978) 646-1111

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Cindy

We had a really great girls night. The food was amazing and our waiter Aiden made it so much more fun than usual. That kid needs a raise!! He went above and beyond for us!

Colin

Food portions are really good for the prices. The meatballs, veal saltimbocca, and chicken broccoli and ziti were all very good. The service was excellent; our server was pleasant and very attentive. Very solid place to go eat.

Scott Suleski

Food is excellent and staff is amazing

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sandra

We had reservations for Thanksgiving at 4:30 pm. When our waitress came to our table (we sat for 5-10 minutes) to take our food requests - she told us that there was no more turkey. What?? The waitress then went on to tell us that in the past they have always had leftover turkey on Thanksgiving, and that the waiters/waitresses had been able to take some turkey home at the end of the day. The waitress was totally surprised that they had run out of turkey. So, big question as to why that happened. Another couple that came in to the restaurant at the same time we did, got up and left after being told that the turkey dinner was off the menu Another thing - we ordered the salmon dinner from the menu which came with green beans, on the menu, but when the waitress brought the dish to the table, the side dish was broccoli, not green beans. I am allergic to broccoli, and so they had to replace the broccoli with another side dish. The waitress did not ask if I had any allergies when we ordered our dinner,-which she should have! So, not good that they ran out of turkey on Thanksgiving Day (should have planned better), and not great service by our waitress.

Hannah

The long curly dark haired hostess was very rude and judgmental. We stood at the stand while staff stared at us before seating us. The food came out quickly and was hot and good but was very disappointed with the staff.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 1

Maria Concepcion

The house wine is good. Don’t order the chicken parm with penne. Came out lukewarm warm and looked pre-made. Sent it back to have it put in the oven. Came out with more sauce and still luke warm. I don’t recommend it!! I asked to speak to the manager, there was none on duty. If I have a complaint, I would have to call when the manager is here. They didn’t even take it off the check. I won’t be back!!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 2

Bill

My pattern and i were on a local road trip to take ini the beauty of the "North Shore'' of MA and Southern NH and decided on Teresa's in Middleton, a convenient location for our journey home from our location in Rye NH. We were there on time for our Open Table reservation and we had a nice window seat. Our server was excellent and served us with a smile and called to each of our dining choices, "It's SOOO good'' which made me smile. and it was SOOO Good. WE had stopped on the way somewhere for some homemade scones and decided upon the Eggplant Rollatini and a Salmon dish which could easily feed two with the Arborio rice with the creamy texture and teh salmon sitting on top. A true picture (actually both the Eggplant Rolllatini and the salmon were picture plates! Both were excellent!!

Barbara White

The food was so good and our server was very efficient and pleasant 😋

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Margaret

We took my mother-in-law to lunch at Teresa's and had a wonderful time. The food is excellent, the pasta homemade, and the portions very generous. Best of all, the staff was not only efficient and superbly trained but also extremely hospitable. It felt like we were being welcomed into their family home for a meal.

Jana

My sister highly recommended Teresa's. This was my first time eating at Teresa's. The restaurant has a very nice ambience and an extensive menu. The portions are enormous and delicious. I had the frutti di mare with homemade fusilli, another person had the shrimp scampi with penne, another had a smash burger and the last person, a vegan, had sautéed spinach, broccoli and french fries. All food was superbly prepared pasta al dente and vegetables just perfect! The service and cocktails were both excellent too. We will definitely return.

Maddie Wrenn

Teresa’s is one of my all time favorite restaurants! Food is always amazing and the staff is even better! They are so welcoming there! Definitely reccommend trying!!! 10/10!!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Xhoraldo Gjinaj

Me and my family love it here ! For the past 3 years of finding out about this place everytime i come i never have a bad experience, staff is always friendly and welcoming, especially our favorite waitress Jill. She’s truly the best, and always happy to see us when we walk in, it’s perfect for dinning in and also if you want to grab a drink by the bar. Highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Victoria Hoerauf

Used to love coming to Teresa’s, but the service and ambiance has definitely gone downhill. Visited on Sunday with my father, we were immediately told that the kitchen was closing at 8:00. No problem at all, we ordered, food came out quick and was delicious. About five minutes into eating we decided to ask for bread and were told that “there was none left”. Once again, no problem at all! That is, until a family came in at around 8:25, well after the time the kitchen had closed. They all ordered dishes, and were served not one but two rounds of bread. Not sure why there are such inconsistencies- will not be back.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 2

Jean Dowd

The food was great, the service was very pleasant and quick. Had chicken marmalade and it was delicious

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Vito Martello

Waitress was awful 😔

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 1

Loading...