Teresa's Italian Eatery

149 S Main St, Middleton
(978) 646-1111

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Mary

Had a great lunch with friends. Jill was awesome as our server. She remembered all our orders which were all yummy. Requested round table by window and that's exactly where we sat.

Barry

Our server was pleasant but a little slow. Ordered a glass of pinot noir and she brought pino grigio. Took her too long to get it right; the food had already been served for about 7 minutes. I was also charged for the first glass which I believe was $1.00 more than the red I ordered, which I didn't notice until I was home and emptied my pockets and looked a the receipt.There were very few people in the restaurant, so being too busy is not an excuse.

Laura

Have been here several times. Food is always superb and plenty of of it. Nothing beats Theresa's eggplant rollatini!! Very reasonable! Our waitress was fantastic Danielle P. Friendly and accommodating. We were the last ones to Leave and she never rushed us out. On the contrary. She found out it was my birthday and surprised us with a Tiramisu. Teresa's had a wonderful employee!!!!! When we come back I won't hesitate to ask for her! Thank you for another wonderful dining experience!

melissa

We were sad. We have been to this restaurant many times before, but tonight was a little disappointing. Food was room temperature to warm. Menu was downsized for Mother's Day, which we were not informed of until we sat down and saw the menu. You can tell the food was made prior and just reheated to serve. It felt like a mediocre meal at best. you would figure that for Mother's Day. They would've stepped up their game a little better but instead for a higher class Italian restaurant I feel I could've gotten a better meal at Olive Garden.

Sheryl

It's unfortunate that the food was very bland. It was not full of flavor compared to what I've had experienced in the past. We have eaten in the bar area, the restaurant and have purchased their catering, but today the food fell short of expectation. Management and staff were welcoming and accommodating. So overall a little disappointing.

Ed

Was really busy for Mom's Day. Our server was very outstanding. Apps were great. Mom's and kids meals were fantastic. could not say the same for guys' cowboy steaks. One was very fatty and second was negatively tasting due to the seasonings.

Robert

We had Easter dinner , a 24 ounce Prime rib cooked perfectly and roast lamb chops The food was delicious and the service impeccable

Wendy

We recently dined at Teresa's Italian Eatery and was truly impressed by the entire experience. From the moment that we walked in, the cozy ambiance made us feel like we had stepped into a trattoria in the heart of Italy. The staff was friendly and welcoming, which set the tone for a wonderful evening. For starters, we had the arancini which was made fresh, and perfectly presented. We also ordered the Apple Gorgonzola salad. Excellent flavors and crispy greens. For the main course, we tried the carbonara and the pollo milano. They were both absolutely delicious — the pasta was cooked to perfection, and the sauces were creamy without being overly rich. The pancetta added a delightful crunch, and the dish had the perfect balance of flavors. Paired with glasses of Italian wine, it was the perfect combination to a perfect meal. Our waitress was attentive and friendly . Overall, I highly recommend Teresas Italian Eatery to anyone craving authentic Italian cuisine. The flavors are rich, the atmosphere is warm, and the service is top-notch. We'll definitely be coming back soon.

Opentable Diner

Teresa's never disappoints, if you're looking for a restaurant that has great food and service this is the place for you!!!

Opentable Diner

The place was very nice and elegant. Server was very good, but had a lot of tables which slowed things down a bit. Food was average - had the penne vodka. Arancini was delicious though.

Kathleen

Fantastic all around. Met up with a GF for early apps and wine at about 4:30. Our servers were incredible (one in training) Enjoyed the Buratta salad, Arancini and Mussels. All were excellent and beautifully presented. Will definitely be back soon for dinner. Very impressed.

Michelle Batchelor

Management needs to do a better job! We were in tonight at the back bar on bar side of place. We chose to eat on the bar side for a reason. Unfortunately our plans were spoofed when a gentleman came on w/ host checking out the area and asked for 2 -4 tops. The host balked at first, but then gave in. Imagine when 4 kids and 4 adults came in, kids at one table and adults at the other. Young girls all had IPads and were happily, but loudly playing game while adults enjoyed themselves. This was the bar side and signs indicated age restrictions. This was unacceptable as this was clearly an adult environment. I adore kiddos, but there are limitations! We were very disappointed and actually moved into another area. I don’t foresee another visit. Unfortunate!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Eggplant Rollatini, Arancini

Nancy Perkins

My family and I have been there for the past three months. Each time the food has been superb. However, nothing beats the Seafood Risotto!!! The best ever -- UNBELIEVABLE! Nancy P.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kim Marston

One of my favorite restaurants. They have such wonderful staff and amazing food :))

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lori Capezzuto

I will share my negative comments with the owner and event staff privately from an event on Sunday, September 29. It was not good from food to service to over site. Would not recommend this place for a function (and it was small…less than 30 people!)

Loading...