Muffin House Cafe

325 N Main St, Natick
(508) 417-1445

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Banana Nut Chocolate Chip Muffins
Blueberry Muffin
Milky Way
Pastries
Cupcakes

Menu

BAGELS
6 BAGELS - SELECT
Choose your 6 favorite bagels.
6 BAGELS - ASSORTED
We will pick a nice assortment for you or tell us what you want under Special Instructions
ASIAGO BAGEL
EVERYTHING BAGEL
PLAIN BAGEL
SESAME BAGEL
HONEY WHEAT BAGEL
CINNAMON RAISIN BAGEL
EGG BAGEL
FRENCH TOAST BAGEL
ONION BAGEL
MARBLE RYE BAGEL
JALAPENO CHEDDAR BAGEL
12 BAGELS - ASSORTED
We will pick a nice assortment for you or tell us what you want under Special Instructions
12 BAGELS - SELECT
Choose your 12 favorite bagels.
BAGEL with
Click Here to choose your bagel and how you would like your bagel sandwich prepared.

MUFFINS
COFFEE CAKE
Chocoloate CHIP
DOUBLE CHOC CHIP
FUNFETTI
BANANA CHOC CHIP
BLUEBERRY BANANA NUT
BLUEBERRY
CRANBERRY ORANGE
LEMON POPPY
CORN
CAPPUCINO
12 MUFFINS - ASSORTED
A hand-picked selection of 12 of our delicious muffins !
BANANA NUT
APPLE Cinammon
CRANBERRY APPLE WALNUT
12 MUFFINS
You pick your favorite 12 muffins !
6 MUFFINS - ASSORTED
A hand-picked selection of 6 of our delicious muffins !
BUTTER CRUNCH LEMON
6 MUFFINS - SELECT
You pick your favorite 6 muffins !

PASTRIES
CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE
WHOOPIE PIE
Raspberry Stick
LEMON FRUIT SQUARE
RASPBERRY FRUIT SQUARE
M&M COOKIE
OREO BROWNIE
ECLAIR
GINGERBREAD FROSTED
HALF MOONS
PLAIN BROWNIE
Chocolate Brownie
Cheese Danish
Figure 8
Cinnamon Stick
CHOCOLATE CUPCAKE
CHOCOLATE CHIP WHOOPIE
Hostess CUPCAKE
Hostess Cupcake - the classic chocolate cupcake filled with white cream and topped with Chocolate ! Yum
White CUPCAKE
White Cupcake with White Frosting

CAKE BY THE SLICE
CAKE SLICE Carrot
CAKE SLICE Buttercream
CAKE SLICE Chocolate

Coffee By The Pound
Pound of Coffee
1/2 Pound of Coffee

Delivery Hot Coffees and Drinks
LARGE COFFEE
Our delicious house coffee ... select your sweetener and milk and optionally your coffee style including decaf. *All coffee flavors roasted in the bean
MEDIUM COFFEE
Our delicious house coffee ... select your sweetener and milk and optionally your coffee style including decaf. *All coffee flavors roasted in the bean
SMALL COFFEE
HOT COFFEE
LATTE
CAPPUCINO
Cappuccino made with Espresso, Steamed Milk and an airy thick layer of foamed milk
AMERICANO
CARAMEL MACCHIATO
ESPRESSO
FLAVORED LATTE
HOT CHAI TEA
Vanilla or Spiced
HOT COCOA

Delivery Iced Coffes and Drinks
SMOOTHIE
ICED COFFEE
FROZEN COFFEE
ICED CARAMEL MACHIATTO
ICED CHAI TEA
ICED MOCHA
ICED TEA
FLAVORED ICED LATTE

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+43 photos
Photo credit: nextdoor
+42 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I ordered a cake from Muffin House Cafe for my thirtieth birthday and it was the best decision!

Everyone loved the cake! I ordered a red velvet cake with cream cheese frosting. The cake was so moist. One of the best cakes we’ve ordered. The design was exactly what I was looking for. Their inquiry system is quick and efficient. Great communication and reasonable pricing. I would highly recommend! Will order again. 😊
December 2025
There's nothing I can say that can describe how good it is!! The best I've ever had! Run to get it, and the service is so good, they are also donating all leftovers! If you want to enjoy something super amazing and support small business. That's your spot❤️❤️❤️
July 2025
We ordered a fantastic 10" custom triple layer cake from Muffin House Cafe. The cake was delicious and easy to order! Natick staff were super friendly. We will definitely order cakes from you again!
January 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Mingaliens Trattoria - 319 N Main St
Pizza, Gluten-Free
Joy Luck - 319 N Main St
Asian, Chinese
Einstein Bros. Bagels - 44 Main St
Bagels

Muffin House Cafe

325 N Main St, Natick, MA 01760
(508) 417-1445