Mad Martha's Homemade Ice Cream

Beyond terrible! I emailed brook with Nathan cc Seventeen actual times. I can get this ice cream pie in Edgartown where we are staying? No, Brook answered, only at Oak Bluff-ok I say. I would like to pick up on Tuesday-No, brook answered. He needs me to pick up on Wednesday bc it’s their busy time. Ok, I say. Can we get some decorations on this birthday cake? No, says Brook, you need to decorate yourself. Ok, I say. I emailed them today to say I would be in as promised. No response, so sure it’s ok -so, we load in an 80 yo, 3 kids under 10, 3 adults and head out to collect cake. NO cake. That’s right, no cake. When I asked to speak to one of then, Nathan doesn’t apologize, but man-Splains to me that there has been “ a miscommunication “. That’s all, end of story. Well, first he said Brook forgot to get with the cake maker. Then he said there was a duplicate order and they just sold my cake to someone else. Both clearly fabrications. Offered nothing, just repeated there was a miscommunication- So, not an islander, but will never do business at Mad Martha’s again. And yep, sharing my story with my island people. Entire family both inconvenienced in a big way and also disappointed!! Oh-we pivoted and picked up similar cake on the way home from Dairy Queen!!! It was perfect!! And, I told them, too!

Was ok. Nothing special. Very expensive.

Perfect way to top off lunch, I loved this cute spot. Shark attack is the way to go!

The one scoop for $8 was not worth it. It was average and they didn’t even have the flavor-of-the-week (it was thursday when I visited). we each had a different flavor, vanilla w/M&M, coconut, strawberry, and salted caramel. The strawberry had the most flavor, while the vanillam&m was creamy and fresh. coconut lacked flavor and salted caramel also bland. freshness won us over as the ice cream was fresh and creamy just lacked a good flavor burst. the sugar cones were good and crunchy.

Lots of flavors to choose from at this very old creamery.

Love this place

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best ice cream in Oak Bluffs. Lots of flavors. Big single scoops. Sundae is only $1.50 more than a single, a deal by Vineyard standards.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Hot Fudge

My favorite childhood ice cream has now become my kids' favorite childhood ice cream! ❤️ We highly recommend the Reese's Cream, Oreo Cream, Chocolate, and the Chilmark Coffee.... all at once if you dare lol! Summer staff are all so sweet and friendly as well 😊

Great ice cream! Glad we stopped in!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: With Hot Fudge, Ice Cream Soda, Chocolate Ice Cream

Great place to enjoy some ice cream!
Coffee and chocolate or pistachios..yummy!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

This is average ice cream at an extremely high price. Definitely did not live up to the hype.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Excellent ice cream in a no frills setting

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 5

awesome food and service

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Ice Cream

One of the best ice cream I have ever had 10/10 would recommend

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

They had a very delicious and diverse selection of dairy-free options for ice cream! We tried all of them and thoroughly enjoyed each one. The flavor of the week, which featured raspberry, was my favorite.

Dietary restrictions: Dairy-free options available and yummy!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Black Raspberry