Mad Martha's Homemade Ice Cream

The vegan coffee Oreo was pretty good. Not the best vegan ice cream I’ve ever had but it was tasty, especially after hiking all day

Beyond terrible! I emailed brook with Nathan cc Seventeen actual times. I can get this ice cream pie in Edgartown where we are staying? No, Brook answered, only at Oak Bluff-ok I say. I would like to pick up on Tuesday-No, brook answered. He needs me to pick up on Wednesday bc it’s their busy time. Ok, I say. Can we get some decorations on this birthday cake? No, says Brook, you need to decorate yourself. Ok, I say. I emailed them today to say I would be in as promised. No response, so sure it’s ok -so, we load in an 80 yo, 3 kids under 10, 3 adults and head out to collect cake. NO cake. That’s right, no cake. When I asked to speak to one of then, Nathan doesn’t apologize, but man-Splains to me that there has been “ a miscommunication “. That’s all, end of story. Well, first he said Brook forgot to get with the cake maker. Then he said there was a duplicate order and they just sold my cake to someone else. Both clearly fabrications. Offered nothing, just repeated there was a miscommunication- So, not an islander, but will never do business at Mad Martha’s again. And yep, sharing my story with my island people. Entire family both inconvenienced in a big way and also disappointed!! Oh-we pivoted and picked up similar cake on the way home from Dairy Queen!!! It was perfect!! And, I told them, too!

Was ok. Nothing special. Very expensive.

Perfect way to top off lunch, I loved this cute spot. Shark attack is the way to go!

The one scoop for $8 was not worth it. It was average and they didn’t even have the flavor-of-the-week (it was thursday when I visited). we each had a different flavor, vanilla w/M&M, coconut, strawberry, and salted caramel. The strawberry had the most flavor, while the vanillam&m was creamy and fresh. coconut lacked flavor and salted caramel also bland. freshness won us over as the ice cream was fresh and creamy just lacked a good flavor burst. the sugar cones were good and crunchy.

Lots of flavors to choose from at this very old creamery.

Love this place

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best ice cream in Oak Bluffs. Lots of flavors. Big single scoops. Sundae is only $1.50 more than a single, a deal by Vineyard standards.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Hot Fudge

My favorite childhood ice cream has now become my kids' favorite childhood ice cream! ❤️ We highly recommend the Reese's Cream, Oreo Cream, Chocolate, and the Chilmark Coffee.... all at once if you dare lol! Summer staff are all so sweet and friendly as well 😊

Great ice cream! Glad we stopped in!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: With Hot Fudge, Ice Cream Soda, Chocolate Ice Cream

Great place to enjoy some ice cream!
Coffee and chocolate or pistachios..yummy!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

This is average ice cream at an extremely high price. Definitely did not live up to the hype.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Excellent ice cream in a no frills setting

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 5

awesome food and service

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Ice Cream

One of the best ice cream I have ever had 10/10 would recommend

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4