The owner who works in the kitchen/baking area looks out at the customers. When I come she glares at like I am interfering with her day even though we never have spoken or had contact. Her front clerk is very nice and helpful.I have hit the point I don't like going there because she makes feel like I am an intruder. If I want there goods I will go to their place in Bloomfield.My thoughts are based on the times I have said hello to her angry stare and never have had a response back. I won't go there where she.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Sabine Dizdarevic
We did a 3-tier wedding cake with them. The best tasting cake I have tried from an Italian bakery! They do the authentic old school Italian pipping by hand. The cake was super moist and not dry at all!!! Very hard to find wedding cakes or cakes in general that are very fluffy and moist and just has a lot of flavor! Their white chocolate raspberry filling is the best and their chocolate cake with almond filling is amazing as well!!! Highly recommend them for wedding cakes and sweets in general. They are super honest and straightforward and will work with you to make what you really want and even more! They were even able to put any flowers on the cake that we wanted and our topper! Thank you to Jessica & Emiddio's family for making my dream wedding cake, come to life!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Steve W
Awesome pastry !!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Cannoli
Rosalind Pantano
Everything i purchased was delicious and fresh! Service with a smile! I recommend trying this place if you haven't. My daughter in law loved her chocolate mousse birthday cake, Thank you Pasticceria Italia.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies
Jon L.
Hours are posted as being open till 6:00 pm. Got there at 5:50 tonight and they had already shut the lights off and turned off their sign. Not very professional.
Julie Nicoletti
Stopped in for the first time today. Bought two Lobster Tails, a slice of Oreo Cake and one Sfogliatella. Both the Lobster Tails were bad - stale pastry and the cream had gone sour. Had to spit it out immediately. Would not recommend
Christopher Tobia
Unfortunately, (IMO) this bakery has gone downhill. For the third time I received cannolis that were only filled at the tips. The filling was missing in the middle (and at $3.25 a cannoli - it’s insulting and a real ripoff).Additionally, their tiramisu cake is a joke ( but find out for yourself).I’m sorry to say (IMO) they’re not a true Italian Bakery - they only pose as one.
Dorothy Nicoletti
It's one thing to sell a day old loaf of bread or donut, but a pastry with a cream filling that's gone bad? I'm disgusted. The lobster tail looked a little sad but I gave them the benefit of my doubt. The minute I tasted it, had to spit it out. It was sour, spoiled.Shame on you!
Steve Barrett
Just delightful. Great coffee, amazing selection of cakes and pastries with lovely service.
Christopher T
Unfortunately, for the third time the bakery has only filled the tips of the cannolis ( the middle was empty). It’s incredibly insulting and a ripoff to me when my family members and I have informed the owner ( and some of her employees in the past) that this is grossly unsatisfactory! IMO - it truly appears that they don’t care.
I recently ordered a small cake for a party. This cake was amazing! Not only did it look beautiful and appealing, but it also tasted sooo good! A friend even commented that it may be the best cake he had ever eaten! Thank you so much for providing quality baked goods that we can enjoy and be confident to serve!
Anne Poon
This a very nice, clean and cheerful looking bakery. The lobster tail that I had is a delicious cream filled pastry with a flaky outer layer. Tasty and ultra filling! My husband enjoyed the fresh moist chocolate tiramisu. He said it was sooo good! He loves the flaky apple turnover too. My son enjoyed the plain non chocolate tiramisu. So fresh and good . My daughter raved about the pistachio ricotta sliced cake. It was a soft,creamy and absolutely delightful piece of cake. It is her new favorite. The young lady serving us was very nice. Great cakes and good service too.
Lorraine G.
Great neighborhood pastry shop to find Italian specialty cakes. Sfogliatella made every day. Today's visit was a special treat for zeppoles. Pastry shops specialize with these as March 19th approaches. Zeppoles are often referred to as Saint Joseph's Day pastries. Eat in available as well.
John Obrien
Counter person was very helpful and polite. Cake was delicious.
Chelsea DeRouchey
Amazing cappuccino and rainbow cookies. Great staff who were very kind, patient and helpful. I am already looking forward to my next visit.
The owner who works in the kitchen/baking area looks out at the customers. When I come she glares at like I am interfering with her day even though we never have spoken or had contact. Her front clerk is very nice and helpful.I have hit the point I don't like going there because she makes feel like I am an intruder. If I want there goods I will go to their place in Bloomfield.My thoughts are based on the times I have said hello to her angry stare and never have had a response back. I won't go there where she.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
We did a 3-tier wedding cake with them. The best tasting cake I have tried from an Italian bakery! They do the authentic old school Italian pipping by hand. The cake was super moist and not dry at all!!! Very hard to find wedding cakes or cakes in general that are very fluffy and moist and just has a lot of flavor! Their white chocolate raspberry filling is the best and their chocolate cake with almond filling is amazing as well!!! Highly recommend them for wedding cakes and sweets in general. They are super honest and straightforward and will work with you to make what you really want and even more! They were even able to put any flowers on the cake that we wanted and our topper! Thank you to Jessica & Emiddio's family for making my dream wedding cake, come to life!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Awesome pastry !!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Cannoli
Everything i purchased was delicious and fresh! Service with a smile! I recommend trying this place if you haven't. My daughter in law loved her chocolate mousse birthday cake, Thank you Pasticceria Italia.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies
Hours are posted as being open till 6:00 pm. Got there at 5:50 tonight and they had already shut the lights off and turned off their sign. Not very professional.
Stopped in for the first time today. Bought two Lobster Tails, a slice of Oreo Cake and one Sfogliatella. Both the Lobster Tails were bad - stale pastry and the cream had gone sour. Had to spit it out immediately. Would not recommend
Unfortunately, (IMO) this bakery has gone downhill. For the third time I received cannolis that were only filled at the tips. The filling was missing in the middle (and at $3.25 a cannoli - it’s insulting and a real ripoff).Additionally, their tiramisu cake is a joke ( but find out for yourself).I’m sorry to say (IMO) they’re not a true Italian Bakery - they only pose as one.
It's one thing to sell a day old loaf of bread or donut, but a pastry with a cream filling that's gone bad? I'm disgusted. The lobster tail looked a little sad but I gave them the benefit of my doubt. The minute I tasted it, had to spit it out. It was sour, spoiled.Shame on you!
Just delightful. Great coffee, amazing selection of cakes and pastries with lovely service.
Unfortunately, for the third time the bakery has only filled the tips of the cannolis ( the middle was empty). It’s incredibly insulting and a ripoff to me when my family members and I have informed the owner ( and some of her employees in the past) that this is grossly unsatisfactory! IMO - it truly appears that they don’t care.
Restaurantji Recommends
I recently ordered a small cake for a party. This cake was amazing! Not only did it look beautiful and appealing, but it also tasted sooo good! A friend even commented that it may be the best cake he had ever eaten! Thank you so much for providing quality baked goods that we can enjoy and be confident to serve!
This a very nice, clean and cheerful looking bakery. The lobster tail that I had is a delicious cream filled pastry with a flaky outer layer. Tasty and ultra filling! My husband enjoyed the fresh moist chocolate tiramisu. He said it was sooo good! He loves the flaky apple turnover too. My son enjoyed the plain non chocolate tiramisu. So fresh and good . My daughter raved about the pistachio ricotta sliced cake. It was a soft,creamy and absolutely delightful piece of cake. It is her new favorite. The young lady serving us was very nice. Great cakes and good service too.
Great neighborhood pastry shop to find Italian specialty cakes. Sfogliatella made every day. Today's visit was a special treat for zeppoles. Pastry shops specialize with these as March 19th approaches. Zeppoles are often referred to as Saint Joseph's Day pastries. Eat in available as well.
Counter person was very helpful and polite. Cake was delicious.
Amazing cappuccino and rainbow cookies. Great staff who were very kind, patient and helpful. I am already looking forward to my next visit.