Carefree Cakery

71 Cowls Rd, North Amherst
(413) 230-3141

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Shane Kieran

Delicious baked goods. Alllllllllll kinds of freshly baked Deliciousness up in here. Don't miss out. You heard???

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Shao Lin

I absolutely love this place. Great customer service, gluten free and vegan offerings, and the cake and cupcakes got RAVE reviews from those who attended our party. Highly recommend!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Melissa C

We got 4 cakes plus 48 cupcakes for a birthday party and they were AMAZING! From ordering to delivery, everything went so smoothly. Everything was delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

No One

Easily the best cupcakes I've ever had in my entire life. Every single thing about their cupcakes are perfect, from the light fluffy cake to the flavor & frosting. It's also the perfect ratio of cake to frosting. There is no dessert better

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lory Hough

Alysia and her team at Carefree Cakery made a delicious birthday cake for my son's 20th birthday last week. It was vegan and gluten free, half lemon/half strawberry -- and 100% delicious. We had a mixed group, including one vegan, two gluten-free eaters, and four without allergies/preferences and EVERYONE loved the cake. It was moist and didn’t have that grainy or dense texture that gluten-free and vegan cakes often have. (I’ve been vegan for 25 years — I’ve had my share of dense, grainy desserts!) This might be the best testimonial about the cake: I had a very hard time only eating one piece that night and ended up having a slice the next morning for breakfast. :-)

Food: 5

Service: 5

Noelle Shamlian

I ordered a custom vintage heart cake for my birthday recently and it was a wonderful experience from start to finish! The Carefree Cakery team was easy to order from, enthusiastic, and talented! I gave them some inspiration pictures of what I wanted and my friends and family were blown away with how beautiful the cake was. It was also delicious and flavorful- highly recommend the lemon cake and raspberry buttercream together!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Verity N-t

Hands down, Carefree Cakery make the best cupcakes I’ve ever tasted! We have also ordered a couple of birthday cakes for our kiddos, and they too are spectacular. Not too heavy on frosting, and the cake is light and delicious. Our friends always comment on how delicious the cupcakes/cakes are. This week, we ordered a Wicked theme cake for our daughter’s 10th birthday party and it was so beautiful, I thought my kiddo was going to cry with joy when we picked it up!! We love you guys and we love your cakes ❤️🎂🧁❤️

PinayPride22

EDITED REVIEW: Alysha and her team have once again demonstrated exceptional skill and artistry. Their ability to translate imaginative cake designs into reality is truly impressive. Recently, I commissioned a graduation cake and cupcake order for my stepson, and I was thoroughly delighted with the result. Our guests praised the cake and cupcakes, noting that they were moist, soft, and flavorful, with precisely the right level of sweetness. In the near future, I intend to place another cake order for my daughter, who will be celebrating her second birthday. I have absolute confidence in their expertise and professionalism. Beyond their evident talent and creativity, the staff consistently display a warm and friendly demeanor while maintaining impeccable professionalism.

Hands down the BEST tasting cake and cupcakes I’ve ever had. Our guests for my daughter’s 1st birthday party devoured the cake & cupcakes.
Alisha was super helpful too and very professional. The cupcake toppers I ordered online were way too big, so I called her and explained the situation. She offered to order the toppers for me; some of them arrived broken but she managed to create leaves which looked so perfect at no additional cost.
I am about to order another cake for my friend’s birthday.
I highly recommend them

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake

Rochelle Forto Feldman

Alisha and her team have once again demonstrated exceptional skill and artistry. Their ability to translate imaginative cake designs into reality is truly impressive. Recently, I commissioned a graduation cake and cupcake order for my stepson, and I was thoroughly delighted with the result. Our guests praised the cake and cupcakes, noting that they were moist, soft, and flavorful, with precisely the right level of sweetness. In the near future, I intend to place another cake order for my daughter, who will be celebrating her second birthday. I have absolute confidence in their expertise and professionalism. Beyond their evident talent and creativity, the staff consistently display a warm and friendly demeanor while maintaining impeccable professionalism.

Mya Glace

They helped make the best cupcakes ever! And helped make my sweet 16th vision come alive! Thank you carefreecakery!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lisa Thompson

I ordered a gluten free cake for a cast party & 30th birthday celebration. From the ordering process to the delivery, Carefree Cakery was a dream to work with. Staff was super helpful and friendly. After a minor mishap traveling with the finished product, the team went above and beyond to repair the cake AND deliver it. Talk about going the extra mile! The cake was stunning and delicious, and everyone was delighted with the result. Thank you Carefree Cakery! You’re the best!!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nancy Hayes

If you are looking for Cupcakes as a dessert for your family gathering, or in my case, our Granddaughter's college graduation party THIS is the place to go!!!!! I wanted enough flavors for everyone to enjoy. 'Carefree Cakery' knocked it out of the park! The Cupcakes were moist and flavorful, and the buttercream frosting!!!!! OH. MY.GOODNESS

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Slater Victoroff

These folks are great! Amazing cakes with lovely decoration and good attention to detail. Their vegan cakes are also amazing! So many delicious flavors.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

JJ Lo

Ok but wait. Their CARROT CAKE CUPCAKE IS TO DIE FOR! I ate it too fast and audibly said wow in between bites. Also the sweetest customer service, so many amazing flavors to choose from and vegan/gf options . Absolutely love this spot.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jon Black

Can't say enough about the quality of the cake we bought. Great texture and flavor. Definitely the best red velvet cakes I've eaten - including homemade. And one of the best cakes period!

Loading...