The pizza is not to saucy or cheesy, a little on the dry side
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Benjamin C.
The pizza here was cold and slow, also the service was terrible. They were rude and mean to a little kid was just trying to get an ice cream. They were yelling at him to hurry up when he took less than a minute.
Theresa Connors
Tried to place an order over the phone and the man who answered was very unhelpful and
Food: 5
Service: 1
Joshua M
Some of the better pizza I've had in Massachusetts.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Lizet Ramos
The cashier working on the day I went was so helpful!! Her recommendations were on point!! Definitely will b my go 2 get pizza when I'm in town!! ❤️?❤️?❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Toppings, Cheese Pizza
William delaiarro
There is nothing better than the pizza here. And for lunch you can but it by the slice. Cheese,pepperoni, chicken bacon ranch,BBQ chicken and a couple im missing are all available by the slice. Haven't had the sandwiches before and I got a pastrami last time I was here and it was fantastic also. Don't miss a chance to order from here. Great food and service.
Every Saturday I go cruising with my Mom and stop to get dinner from Old School Pizza ?. We also get a great salad, spaghetti ? & meatballs ?..I can't wait for Saturdays.It's like it used to be Wednesday with Anthony, but now it's Old School Pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian
Dylan Bob508
Good pizza, buffalo slices are delicious and decent prices
Old School makes pizza that could contend with the best of New York. The dough is crisp and doesn't flop and the cheese and sauce are well ratio'd and flavorful. The restaurant, while not having as many decorations as it used to, has a unique atmosphere and many retro posters and trinkets. Only complaints are that they generally take about 10 minutes longer on the cook time estimate, and for being a pizza restaurant of their caliber they close the box completely which can negatively affect texture. But overall, the best place in Wellesley and one of the best in Massachusetts.Vegetarian options: It's a pizza place; fine for vegetarians, not vegansKid-friendliness: Many people going are from the local schools, so the restaurant is used to kidsParking: Wellesley can be a pain to park in during the day, but the library close by has a large parking lot.
Sarah Y.
This place is a hidden gem in Wellesley, the most solid pizza I've had in the area. The killer is the mac and cheese bites (not pictured because I ate them so much. Paired with the marinara sauce, it's heaven in your mouth. All the pizzas are very good, I haven't had one where I thought it was bad. My favorite has to be good old pepperoni and margerita (pictured below). Large is honestly not that big - could be easily shared by two people so I would keep that in mind price wise. I've heard a lot about the pastas and sandwiches which I haven't had a chance to try yet but would love to at some point. The interior of the place is very old school and has a fun vibe to it, I enjoy eating there with friends when I want to meet up locally.
Brian F.
Lost my order twice in a row. Ordered delivery the first time and somehow it was crossed out and changed to pick-up. After two hours and several calls later, the pizza was delivered cold as ice. I'm currently sitting in the restaurant waiting for my newest order, which I made a concerted effort to pick up this time, and the pizza wasn't made....hour + has gone by and the clock keeps ticking.... The quality of this pizza isn't nearly worth it
Howard Gold
Tried it today for first time. Literally the best pizza I have ever had. Sauce, cheese, spices and crust. Really great! Will be back!
maria elvira sarmiento alvarez
I really liked the place and the food, but I think they have changed the kitchen staff. the quality of the food has gone down a lot, it doesn't feel the same. it's still a good place. I just hope they return to the quality of before.
The pizza is not to saucy or cheesy, a little on the dry side
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza here was cold and slow, also the service was terrible. They were rude and mean to a little kid was just trying to get an ice cream. They were yelling at him to hurry up when he took less than a minute.
Tried to place an order over the phone and the man who answered was very unhelpful and
Food: 5
Service: 1
Some of the better pizza I've had in Massachusetts.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
The cashier working on the day I went was so helpful!! Her recommendations were on point!! Definitely will b my go 2 get pizza when I'm in town!! ❤️?❤️?❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Toppings, Cheese Pizza
There is nothing better than the pizza here. And for lunch you can but it by the slice. Cheese,pepperoni, chicken bacon ranch,BBQ chicken and a couple im missing are all available by the slice. Haven't had the sandwiches before and I got a pastrami last time I was here and it was fantastic also. Don't miss a chance to order from here. Great food and service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Bacon Ranch and Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Margherita Pizza, Buffalo Chicken, Sicilian Pizza
I believe it is the best pizza in ask of
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Every Saturday I go cruising with my Mom and stop to get dinner from Old School Pizza ?. We also get a great salad, spaghetti ? & meatballs ?..I can't wait for Saturdays.It's like it used to be Wednesday with Anthony, but now it's Old School Pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian
Good pizza, buffalo slices are delicious and decent prices
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Bacon Ranch and Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Buffalo Chicken
Had a buffalo chicken sandwich, flavor was fine but each bite of the chicken was very tough, almost like jerky.
Restaurantji Recommends
Old School makes pizza that could contend with the best of New York. The dough is crisp and doesn't flop and the cheese and sauce are well ratio'd and flavorful. The restaurant, while not having as many decorations as it used to, has a unique atmosphere and many retro posters and trinkets. Only complaints are that they generally take about 10 minutes longer on the cook time estimate, and for being a pizza restaurant of their caliber they close the box completely which can negatively affect texture. But overall, the best place in Wellesley and one of the best in Massachusetts.Vegetarian options: It's a pizza place; fine for vegetarians, not vegansKid-friendliness: Many people going are from the local schools, so the restaurant is used to kidsParking: Wellesley can be a pain to park in during the day, but the library close by has a large parking lot.
This place is a hidden gem in Wellesley, the most solid pizza I've had in the area. The killer is the mac and cheese bites (not pictured because I ate them so much. Paired with the marinara sauce, it's heaven in your mouth. All the pizzas are very good, I haven't had one where I thought it was bad. My favorite has to be good old pepperoni and margerita (pictured below). Large is honestly not that big - could be easily shared by two people so I would keep that in mind price wise. I've heard a lot about the pastas and sandwiches which I haven't had a chance to try yet but would love to at some point. The interior of the place is very old school and has a fun vibe to it, I enjoy eating there with friends when I want to meet up locally.
Lost my order twice in a row. Ordered delivery the first time and somehow it was crossed out and changed to pick-up. After two hours and several calls later, the pizza was delivered cold as ice. I'm currently sitting in the restaurant waiting for my newest order, which I made a concerted effort to pick up this time, and the pizza wasn't made....hour + has gone by and the clock keeps ticking.... The quality of this pizza isn't nearly worth it
Tried it today for first time. Literally the best pizza I have ever had. Sauce, cheese, spices and crust. Really great! Will be back!
I really liked the place and the food, but I think they have changed the kitchen staff. the quality of the food has gone down a lot, it doesn't feel the same. it's still a good place. I just hope they return to the quality of before.