We absolutely love coming here. The staff is really kind every time we go, especially Shea who is so kind to us. The ice cream is also so delicious.
Nick S
Truly's is a small ice cream shop in the heart of Wellesley, open into later hours of the night. We came about an hour before closing, and there was many people still there ordering ice cream, and this was on a cold day as well so we knew that this should be good.
They offer a selection of seasonal flavors, in froyo, hard scoop, or soft serve varieties. We got a milkshake and the blueberry pie flavors. The blueberry flavor was good, a lil sweet but not overly sweet. The milkshake was of the thicker variety, but not overly thick. The price was good for the portion, and we were satisfied, though we did need lactaid pills so maybe watch out if you're lactose intolerant.
Johanna Steensma
I love Truly’s! I have never ordered anything larger than a small because their portions are so generous. My favorite is the raspberry sorbet.
Michael Antonelli
Really good value and portion sizes
joseph klein
The ice cream is delicious! It’s a nice spot with a lot of sitting outside and inside. Great family spot. I recommend 👍
Bebe Shih
The ice cream is delicious and the price is reasonable. The location is perfect when you are in the area for other activities.
Noted that other reviews have mentioned/complained about their service and attitude, it’s some of their staff, not all. So suggestion is that wait/observe and let the right person take your order.
Jonathan Bruce
Great ice cream flavors. Servers are very cheerful and upbeat. A nice experience with every visit.
Abner Bonilla
Delicious Ice Cream + Great service. On street parking only. The place is compact but clean. The employees are always nice. Got in the line and it went quick. They take credit/debit. It is accessible and they do have a bathroom if you are looking for one. Lota of flavors to choose from and the prices are super reasonable. They have a community bulletin board so check that out. It’s really good ice cream.
Vikas G
It used to be amazing - we grew up with Trulys. Ice cream is still the best but the service and quality control has is not up to par anymore. Last few times we have bought pints (including today), they have been 3/4 full and and not at all packed down. It is really not a full pint - just 3 scoops or so. This is unfortunate and no more Trulys of old.
Another delightful outing to Truly's. It's my go to ice cream shop, but it's especially wonderful when I am able to take out of town guests. I recently came in with my family and our guests (7 of us to be exact), and of course, the line is out of the shop and down the street. Don't be afraid reading this, it moves FAST. The young woman helping us took great care to make sure she got our order right, answered questions our guests had, and was efficient. Time and time again, this shop always impresses us. The employees and owners are very kind and make their customers feel appreciated. Thanks Truly's!
Grace Rodrigue
Great local spot for ice cream. As a former employee, I can say it’s a great place to work, especially as a high school job. I love going there to visit my younger sister, Simone! She’s awesome. Great scooper. Athena is also a top favorite scooper. Delicious ice cream, frappes, and cakes! Wide variety of flavors and toppings. Live laugh love Trulys! 🍦😍🥄
Sandra Lee
TERRIBLE NEW OWNERS - RACIST
As a Wellesley native, I grew up on Truly's. It was a staple in my childhood – warm, welcoming, and always buzzing with neighborhood charm. Gary, the previous owner, brought a kind of magic to the place that made it feel like home. So when I recently visited from NYC and took my mom out for a nostalgic trip to Truly's, I was genuinely excited. Sadly, the experience was nothing short of upsetting.
We ordered a kiddie twist and a raspberry mini, and while they accidentally gave us the wrong size for the raspberry, I didn’t mind – honest mistakes happen. But what really rubbed me the wrong way was the treatment my mom received from the new owner, a member of the Marcus family (pictured below - the man in the hat - found online), who rang us up.
After my mom paid and we turned to walk away, he pointedly motioned at the tip screen – as if to shame her for not tipping. Let’s be clear: this is a counter-service ice cream shop, not a sit-down restaurant. Tipping isn’t required, especially when the service is curt and impersonal. His reaction? He made a rude face, muttered something to the cashier next to him, and scoffed – loud enough for us to hear.
I’ve worked in customer service. I understand the grind. But this was flat-out disrespectful – especially towards a loyal local returning to a once-beloved neighborhood spot. As a person of color in a predominantly white town, I couldn’t help but wonder if the treatment we received was about more than just tips.
It’s devastating to see how far Truly's has fallen from its community-centered roots. What was once a friendly, joyful place now feels cold, transactional, and frankly, unwelcoming. This is not the Truly's I grew up loving.
We absolutely love coming here. The staff is really kind every time we go, especially Shea who is so kind to us. The ice cream is also so delicious.
Truly's is a small ice cream shop in the heart of Wellesley, open into later hours of the night. We came about an hour before closing, and there was many people still there ordering ice cream, and this was on a cold day as well so we knew that this should be good.
They offer a selection of seasonal flavors, in froyo, hard scoop, or soft serve varieties. We got a milkshake and the blueberry pie flavors. The blueberry flavor was good, a lil sweet but not overly sweet. The milkshake was of the thicker variety, but not overly thick. The price was good for the portion, and we were satisfied, though we did need lactaid pills so maybe watch out if you're lactose intolerant.
I love Truly’s! I have never ordered anything larger than a small because their portions are so generous. My favorite is the raspberry sorbet.
Really good value and portion sizes
The ice cream is delicious! It’s a nice spot with a lot of sitting outside and inside. Great family spot. I recommend 👍
The ice cream is delicious and the price is reasonable. The location is perfect when you are in the area for other activities.
Noted that other reviews have mentioned/complained about their service and attitude, it’s some of their staff, not all. So suggestion is that wait/observe and let the right person take your order.
Great ice cream flavors. Servers are very cheerful and upbeat. A nice experience with every visit.
Delicious Ice Cream + Great service. On street parking only. The place is compact but clean. The employees are always nice. Got in the line and it went quick. They take credit/debit. It is accessible and they do have a bathroom if you are looking for one. Lota of flavors to choose from and the prices are super reasonable. They have a community bulletin board so check that out. It’s really good ice cream.
It used to be amazing - we grew up with Trulys. Ice cream is still the best but the service and quality control has is not up to par anymore. Last few times we have bought pints (including today), they have been 3/4 full and and not at all packed down. It is really not a full pint - just 3 scoops or so. This is unfortunate and no more Trulys of old.
Exceptional
Restaurantji Recommends
It was amazing!! So good
Another delightful outing to Truly's. It's my go to ice cream shop, but it's especially wonderful when I am able to take out of town guests. I recently came in with my family and our guests (7 of us to be exact), and of course, the line is out of the shop and down the street. Don't be afraid reading this, it moves FAST. The young woman helping us took great care to make sure she got our order right, answered questions our guests had, and was efficient. Time and time again, this shop always impresses us. The employees and owners are very kind and make their customers feel appreciated. Thanks Truly's!
Great local spot for ice cream. As a former employee, I can say it’s a great place to work, especially as a high school job. I love going there to visit my younger sister, Simone! She’s awesome. Great scooper. Athena is also a top favorite scooper. Delicious ice cream, frappes, and cakes! Wide variety of flavors and toppings. Live laugh love Trulys! 🍦😍🥄
TERRIBLE NEW OWNERS - RACIST
As a Wellesley native, I grew up on Truly's. It was a staple in my childhood – warm, welcoming, and always buzzing with neighborhood charm. Gary, the previous owner, brought a kind of magic to the place that made it feel like home. So when I recently visited from NYC and took my mom out for a nostalgic trip to Truly's, I was genuinely excited. Sadly, the experience was nothing short of upsetting.
We ordered a kiddie twist and a raspberry mini, and while they accidentally gave us the wrong size for the raspberry, I didn’t mind – honest mistakes happen. But what really rubbed me the wrong way was the treatment my mom received from the new owner, a member of the Marcus family (pictured below - the man in the hat - found online), who rang us up.
After my mom paid and we turned to walk away, he pointedly motioned at the tip screen – as if to shame her for not tipping. Let’s be clear: this is a counter-service ice cream shop, not a sit-down restaurant. Tipping isn’t required, especially when the service is curt and impersonal. His reaction? He made a rude face, muttered something to the cashier next to him, and scoffed – loud enough for us to hear.
I’ve worked in customer service. I understand the grind. But this was flat-out disrespectful – especially towards a loyal local returning to a once-beloved neighborhood spot. As a person of color in a predominantly white town, I couldn’t help but wonder if the treatment we received was about more than just tips.
It’s devastating to see how far Truly's has fallen from its community-centered roots. What was once a friendly, joyful place now feels cold, transactional, and frankly, unwelcoming. This is not the Truly's I grew up loving.
Great choices for ice creams. Truly delicious.
Loading...