Cape Cod Creamery

5 Theater Colony Rd, South Yarmouth
(508) 398-8400

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jackie Buttaro

We stopped in for ice cream one night after hearing good things - we were surprised at the lack of variety in flavors, not available cones, and the whipped cream that tasted horrible. The ice cream itself was also not great. The little caboose and ice cream smuggler were way better on flavor selection, taste, and whipped cream.

Mike Kennedy

This place has THE BEST ice cream on the Cape! Lots of great flavors named after local towns. It's always fresh and delicious. I absolutely love their brownie sundae. Fantastic place to stop after a great beach day.

Shayla S

Delicious ice cream! We got the strawberry and black raspberry on the waffle cones and they were phenomenal. It was super creamy and yummy. Atmosphere is very cute as well, perfect place to go with your family

Maryann DeLoria

Delicious ice cream! Inventive flavors!
Young workers who were easily distracted.

Phil Hess

If you are an ice cream fan, you have got to go to the Cape Cod Creamery! Our family all agreed it is the best we have had on any of our trips. A lot of flavors, great outdoor seating, friendly staff and they were very accommodating with our daughters food allergies. Make sure you stop in and give this place a try!

Karen Gray

Was great except the giant hole in the bottom of the waffle cones. Made a huge mess

Alex Velez

Amazing!! Best Tutruo turtle

Pearl Li

Very good! Creamy and fresh~ great service and nice outdoor seating in shield by trees

D R

Clean inside. Kid friendly. Ice cream was not fresh and creamy. A little disapointed there. The wait staff didnt seem super friendly

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

Justin Russell

My favorite creamery on the Cape. Period.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rhonnie Ruble

So disappointed I waited all year for the peach ice cream. I bought a pint to take home and put in the freezer. (I only live 2 1/2 miles away.) when I took it out to eat, it had ice crystals all throughout.
** I returned to Cape Cod creamery a few weeks later and bought a quart of peach ice cream to take to a friends dinner. I must say it was the same peach ice cream I remembered. I must have received a bad batch previously. My faith is restored! Love it!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

James

Great ice cream. Service was excellent. I was party of a big group and the people working were very patient and pleasant.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stephen Ahern

My new favorite ice cream shop on the Cape. Great flavors. Efficient delivery and good service by the kids. Nice out door seating area.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

X N

Lovely ice cream parlor with plenty of outdoor seating and delicious flavors. Reasonably priced and very friendly staff!

Parking: This is a very popular shop so spots may become scarce during the peak season but there is plenty of parking during typical business times.

Kid-friendliness: Large outdoor seating area with grass lawn perfect for kids and families

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Orleans Oreo

gabriele houari

Always a must when on the Cape. Some of the best ice cream on

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pistachio Ice Cream, Orleans Oreo

Loading...