I’ve been going to the Great Island Bakery ever since I was 7 years old. A Cape Cod tradition as old as The Pancake Man! I’ve always enjoyed walking over for croissants and cinnamon rolls and I’ll never forget the smell of freshly baked goods in the cute little bakery. Stopping by on a bike ride for a treat without my parents knowing always felt so rebellious.
Deloris Malcolm
Not much of a variety as they don't have the help plus costly
Bruce Joslin
Everything is great!
Jesse Blackman
I’ve been going here since I was little - best bakery ever. Everything is fresh, delicious, and the prices are outstanding.
Grammie321
What's Happened to this bakery? Stopped by on Sunday for some cinnamon buns and was surprised at how sparse the inventory was. Cases used to be filled with all sorts of breads and other good stuff. Have not seen Carie (the owner) there in quite some time. Was such a disappointing visit and time to find another bakery.
Mikhail Romanov
Great Island Bakery should be famous! Everything from scratch, always delicious. Made with care so output is limited - visit early and often. Simply the BEST place on the Cape for baked goods like danishes, scones, muffins, cinnamon rolls and elephant ears.
Mary Jo McManus
Awesome bakery. I am partial to the scones. Although, everything is delicious and made from scratch.
Brett Carpenter
Good baked goods, but limited options and quantities. Would benefit from more and better coffee options too
Michael Tarselli
Family-run bakery with a lot of heart near the beach in S. Yarmouth. Menu needs some updating; food would be familiar to your grandmother, but is a bit too simple & sweet for this reviewer.
Rude people asked about muffins n I'm told not for sale...so I guess they pick n choose who can buy certain items..won't ever return much nicer people at other places..unbelievable...
k k
Very good, only thing they were out of sticky buns, settled for cinnamon bun. I suffered through it.
Come baaaackkkk!!!!! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I’ve been going to the Great Island Bakery ever since I was 7 years old. A Cape Cod tradition as old as The Pancake Man! I’ve always enjoyed walking over for croissants and cinnamon rolls and I’ll never forget the smell of freshly baked goods in the cute little bakery. Stopping by on a bike ride for a treat without my parents knowing always felt so rebellious.
Not much of a variety as they don't have the help plus costly
Everything is great!
I’ve been going here since I was little - best bakery ever. Everything is fresh, delicious, and the prices are outstanding.
What's Happened to this bakery? Stopped by on Sunday for some cinnamon buns and was surprised at how sparse the inventory was. Cases used to be filled with all sorts of breads and other good stuff. Have not seen Carie (the owner) there in quite some time. Was such a disappointing visit and time to find another bakery.
Great Island Bakery should be famous! Everything from scratch, always delicious. Made with care so output is limited - visit early and often. Simply the BEST place on the Cape for baked goods like danishes, scones, muffins, cinnamon rolls and elephant ears.
Awesome bakery. I am partial to the scones. Although, everything is delicious and made from scratch.
Good baked goods, but limited options and quantities. Would benefit from more and better coffee options too
Family-run bakery with a lot of heart near the beach in S. Yarmouth. Menu needs some updating; food would be familiar to your grandmother, but is a bit too simple & sweet for this reviewer.
Restaurantji Recommends
Food was fantastic but the older woman had a pretty poor attitude
Friendly people. Delicious cinnamon rolls andGreat coffee.
Great little bakery
Rude people asked about muffins n I'm told not for sale...so I guess they pick n choose who can buy certain items..won't ever return much nicer people at other places..unbelievable...
Very good, only thing they were out of sticky buns, settled for cinnamon bun. I suffered through it.
Loading...