Reynolds Tavern and 1747 Pub

Can’t speak to the food but had drinks here a couple times-
Outdoor area was great when the weather was.
Most recently we my wife and I had a drinks in the downstairs bar, super old, makes you feel like you’ve stepped back in time a bit

Very disappointing experience at Reynolds Tavern. My chicken came out burnt, then my seafood cornbread appetizer arrived late and was mushy (the server did remove it). I tried the crab dip, but it was mostly mayonnaise with hardly any crab. When I asked for it to be taken off, the manager rudely told me, “this is not a taste testing restaurant,” and refused. Poor food quality and even worse customer service. I will not return!

Thank you for your reply, but much of what you stated is inaccurate. There were no multiple drink cancellations, and the salad that was ordered with dressing on the side came out completely drenched. My chicken entrée was burnt, the seafood cornbread appetizer arrived after my meal and was mushy, and the crab dip was mostly mayonnaise with hardly any crab.

I had no issue paying for what I ate and only asked for poor-quality items to be removed. The real problem was the manager’s rude and dismissive attitude — her comment, “this is not a taste testing restaurant,” was unprofessional and unnecessary. Guests should always be treated with respect when they express valid concerns. I stand by my review — your definition of quality clearly doesn’t align with my taste buds.

Fantastic atmosphere and very nice afternoon tea options! We will be back soon!

Our favorite place for afternoon tea!

The tea is spilled! This beautiful historic lodging experience with traditional high tea IS quintessential Annapolis charm! 🫖 💐🤍💛🖤❤️

I have been here countless times and it once was a favorite. However their service has gotten considerably worse and they no longer adhere to their own hours.

Came here with a few of my girlfriends on a Thursday night. It was decently busy but nothing too bad which we liked, and it really is just a cute hidden gem in Annapolis. It is secluded and quiet but so lively and enjoyable. The atmosphere really is good and they were having live music which was so nice. Food was good and service was good. 10/10 for atmosphere!

unfortunately have to give only 2 stars due to the pub part being closed and management unwilling to accommodate our request to even sneak a peak. We came all the way from Texas just to visit as this is the older bar in Maryland - and we visit and review the oldest bars in every state. This one will
not be making our website and blog sadly.

Cozy place. It's lovely here.

We stopped here to get drinks on a Friday night. The outdoor patio was very cute and there was a musician playing live music. Make sure you stop by and check out this tavern!

I normally frequent Reynolds for years, but they did price switching and did not honor what was online that I previewed before my dining trip. You should honor what is on your website.

I had high hopes for this place being in annapolis but for tea they didn't have as many teas to choose from as I thought. And I couldn't understand my waitress at all who disappeared so we were just left sitting. The sandwiches r very plain . Soup was ok very peppery french onion. I prefer the kate pearl tea room. Its so much prettier and the food is made by an actual chef the sandwiches are so delicious and cute with a variety. And for Royal tea you get charcuterie board soup salad and specialty glittery drink along with scone delicious sandwiches and savories and ice cream at the end with a pearl. This tavern is probably better for beer and lunch. Also the people eating lunch are in the room for tea as well. Parking you have to walk down a hill to get to. The snacks for tea were meh. Ok visit but once was enough

I absolutely love this restaurant and outside pub/restaurant!
Amazing food and amazing atmosphere.... super awesome place to go for a girl's night or afternoon tea or a date nigth♡

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

A lovely afternoon tea close to downtown Annapolis. A wide variety of teas and many yummy fresh baked goodies.

We had the BEST dinner, experience, and movie in the outdoor beer garden last night. We never knew the outdoor patio was there. We had a brief wait for a table and asked if there was a bar we could wait at - an employee offered to show us the beer garden. He could not have been nicer and more welcoming. We loved it. It’s such a pretty area with a nice breeze and atmosphere - plenty of places to sit from high tops, to tables, to the bar. It’s a pretty atmosphere under the treetops with lantern lights, secluded a bit from the street. The menu was exactly what wanted - options ranged from casual sandwiches to full dinners. The cornbread appetizer was delicious and inventive. The scallops and shrimp with risotto entree was perfectly cooked, and the crab cakes truly were all killer, no filler. The mixed drink menu was great. There were also lots of fun beer choices. Service was excellent. I only wish I caught their names. The gentleman at the bar and the younger female server with dark hair in a ponytail were super friendly, welcoming, and provided excellent service. Our server made great suggestions on menu choices. The Star Wars movie was an unexpected surprise and a lot of fun - there was no charge to enjoy the movie after dinner. The atmosphere was just so nice, relaxing, and fun. We will definitely return! I was honestly shocked when I came here to leave a review and read some who weren’t happy with the service. We truly had excellent service. The evening could not have been improved. I would not hesitate to come back here. And no, I do not work there nor do I know anyone who works there, owns it, or has any connection to it. We never even knew it was there and only stumbled across it when searching on Resy for a place to spend our quarterly Amex credit. Thank you Amex and Resy for suggesting this hidden gem!