The Cap'ns Slice

8 Pitts St, Berlin
(667) 288-1039

Customers' Favorites

Photos

+13 photos
+12 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Finally got a chance to try this place after hearing countless amazing reviews from friends and family … by far the best pizza on the shore 🔥 11/10 highly recommend coming here
Best part about here is that they grate fresh Parmesan on straight out the tabletop oven slice. Usually can get a whole pie but it was Halloween so slices only. The names of slices are funny bc it definitely dates the generations. Like I didn’t know who Lou was but his toppings were the way to go lol

Parking: Street parking right in front of shop and free parking lot across the little street
So, solid 3 stars. Best texture I've had since leaving New York. Dough is imported from New York so that makes sense. Flavor on the other hand, is sorely lacking. The dough tastes like it either never had salt or is over proofed. I got the James t Kirk. I'm not sure they added any spices to the sauce, may just be tomatoes. Certainly all the ingredients are top notch, Don't get me wrong, it tastes good, but it's certainly not NYC level pizza. it lacks depth...

More Reviews