Smith Island Baking Company

I ordered the old bay buttercream cake for a party. It was a huge hit. While I wasn’t sure about how it would taste it was delicious! Thank you

Food: 5

I highly recommend a visit to this unique piece of Americana. I called ahead and requested a “shipping ready” cake so I could bring it on my road trip and surprise my friends 1,000 miles away, 2-days later. The folks there are super friendly and I really enjoyed meeting them. The cake made it perfectly and blew my friends away!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Smith Island Bakery Chocolate Cake

Ordered a vanilla birthday cake from Goldbelly. BEST CAKE EVER!!!!! Buttercream is absolutely perfect. I couldn’t have made it better. Layers were perfection too. Cake was packaged wonderfully. I couldn’t be happier. You can tell the cakes are handmade too. This review is coming from a family of “from scratch” bakers. A+, highly recommend you order a cake from this company for your special occasion!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I purchased a red velvet cake to get delivered to my sister in law and her husband during some rough times for them. delivery happened on time and as expected, but had a little glitch on the website where it showed my order cancelled. I sort of freaked out and called the number on the site. Brian answered almost immediately and even though shipped 400 cakes that day(!!!!) took time to talk me through what happened and wanted to make 100% sure I was happy and taken care of, he even texted me tracking info and wished us a happy thanksgiving... thats the type of customer service you don't always see these days. I wish I lived close by so I could visit in person(I'm in FL), but their delivery and customer service is outstanding. I will absolutely be ordering more from them in the future. oh and my family LOVED the cake, the best they said they have ever had.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Red Velvet Cake

Highly recommended

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: lg Cakes, Smith Island Bakery Chocolate Cake

I ordered a cake for my daughters birthday. It was beautiful and delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Purchased a slice of Smith Island Cake at an Ocean City Market. Asked clerk if it had a freshness date on it which it didn't.
Cake tasted absolutely horrible old and nasty freezer burnt or whatever maybe picking up other freezer odors not sure but really bad!! Waste of money
As a company you really should be wayy more concerned about your Cake and how long it sits somewhere frozen or not!!! I dare you to try one of these apparently old pieces from OC Market and tell me it's good!! Profit is NOT everything quality control is important and good tasting Cake is paramount when in the Cake business!!

Food: 1

Stopped in to pick-up cakes for a holiday celebration. Everything was excellent! I will definitely order again, but will probably use the delivery system offered. Unique and delicious baked goods.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Red Velvet Cake, Smith Island Bakery Chocolate Cake

I got a small GF cake. I thought it was a little pricey at first, but then I got the cake. The dry ice kept it cold and it was in perfect shape. It was the best gluten free cake I’ve ever had. In the end it was worth every penny. Highly recommend.

Dietary restrictions: Gluten free

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Smith Island Bakery Chocolate Cake

Overpriced and overrated.

Food: 2

Service: 4

Cake and ice cream arrived in Northern California just in time for my birthday! It was packaged up so well and the dry ice kept the ice cream cold for its cross country journey! Super impressed

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ordered a gluten free cake for my mother-in-law for Mother's Day. Shipped to OH. It was an absolute hit. Arrived on time, well packed and, as always, yummy!

Dietary restrictions: Ordered gluten free.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Smith Island Bakery Chocolate Cake

glad we went, but wouldn't recommend it. cool story behind it but could have read that on line. cake was not extraordinary. average taste, average appearance. Have had better cake at most restaurants.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 4

Ordered a cake to be delivered on Saturday for a Birthday party. After delivery never happened I contacted the company and received zero response. Do not trust the delivery date it will never arrive on time.

Delivery of smith island original cake was delicious! Great for an at home celebration!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Smith Island Bakery Chocolate Cake