AJ's Cookie Jar

118 Baltimore St, Cumberland
(240) 362-7141

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Erin Foutz

As Christmas gifts this year, my son gave his teachers cookies and they absolutely loved them like we do!

Roy Bernardo

Got the cake batter cookie with red butter cream frosting wow wow wow. Downtown renovation absolutely beautiful hope it is sucssesful.

Paul

Ordered 144 cookies for a ceremony. Everyone absolutely loved the cookies. I could not have expected any better. AJ's cookies are the best I ever had!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Gourmet Cookies, Classic Chocolate Chunk Cookie

Glenn Fruehan

We go to AJ's regularly for her cookies. They're creative and delicious, often like artwork; simply wonderful. And on today's visit we got an unexpected surprise. Ashley is now making pumpkin pies. Away we went with one and were no more than a half hour inside our home before we cut a slice. My wife and I have tried a lot of pumpkin pies but nothing as good as this one. The filling is a perfect balance of the spices and the pumpkin. But what is a real treat is the deliciously flakey crust. Folks, make your way to AJ's and treat yourself to what will most likely be the best pumpkin pie that you've ever had.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Hayden Ort-Ulm

All of the macaroon flavors and different cookie creations I have had from AJ’s have been fantastic. When Ashley said that she was thinking about doing pies around the holidays, I knew I had to try one. Well I did, and you need to. I am a novice pie baker myself, and know a couple things about a good crust. I can not pin down what it is that makes AJ’s pumpkin pie crust so different from others I have had, but it’s amazing. It melds and flows into the pumpkin pie filling so well and it almost reminds me of a cookie….but its most certainly one of the best pumpkin pies I’ve ever had.

Kid-friendliness: Ashley is always super nice to my kids and they are always very excited to go to “the cookie place”

Recommended dishes: French Macarons

Katie Cioni

I have enjoyed all of AJ’s offerings. Today l discovered a new item which is the pumpkin pie. My family LOVES pumpkin pie but are very selective and picky with spices and crust. I served this to them and they raved and raved! I have to agree with them. The spices are subtle and not over powering. Every bite was delicious! I think my favorite thing about it (though it is hard to pick just one favorite thing) is the crust. I have never had a crust like this one. I struggle to describe it but encourage you to try it for yourself. You will be blown away by the deliciousness and flakiness of it. This item will most definitely be added to my purchases at AJ’s! If you love pumpkin pie you MUST try this for yourself!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Judy Britton

I never had macaroons before and let me tell you the ones I had at AJs were delicious and beautiful looking! The flavors were just so good! We also had a chocolate chip cookie and that was delicious as well.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lina McDonald

delicious cookies! variety of flavors, consistently devine!

claire hasslinger

I ordered several flavors of macarons for my daughters bridal shower. The honey lavender, salted caramel, creme brulee, blueberries and cream, Ispahan and pistachio flavors were outstanding. The customer service was excellent. I will be ordering again!!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: French Macarons

Larry Brock

What a wonderful place to get a friend a quality and unique snack. Really like the friendly surface and chocolate chunk cookies. ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gwen Davis

They’re always so nice and serve fresh, delicious macaroons! I’ve stopped by about 3 times and it is an excellent experience every time!

Haley Portmess

The macarons are delicious! My daughter absolutely loved the fruity pebble flavor, but the strawberry shortcake was my favorite! Crunchy and gooey all in one bite, you definitely will not regret trying it! The staff were also very sweet when I went to pick up my order ? Was testing out options for my daughter's birthday since I was going to decorate her birthday cake in rainbow macarons and now I know where I'm going for them!

Dietary restrictions: They offer gluten free options!

Kid-friendliness: Sugar and brightly colored sweets, as well as polite staff! It's all on the ground floor right in the back so you also don't have to worry about wheelchair access.

Wheelchair accessibility: It's all on the ground floor right in the back so you also don't have to worry about wheelchair access. While there is construction happening in the area, it is a tight squeeze getting to the store, but there are little alcoves along the way that make getting by easier.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Macaron

Madison Kirkpatrick

We ordered a couple different flavors of macaroons and all of them were an absolute 10/10. The birthday cake cookie was also phenomenal. One of the best dessert places i’ve ever been to! The service was also incredible! The cashiers were very friendly!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lauren Bowser

Best GF cookie I’ve ever purchased from a bakery. Most of the cookie was gone before we even made it home. You have to try their GF cake batter cookie. I promise you won’t be disappointed.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

aj comer

Delicious cookies!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...