The pizza selection by the slice was limited (cheese or Hawaiian slices) so we ordered the Hawaiian pizza slices visible on the tray. But they didn't give us them. Instead they gave us pizza with pineapple - but no meat on the slices there.
I tried to get a salad but they didn't know how long it would take to make one, so we skipped it.
Completely indifferent service.
I suggest the B&B crab place down the road (alas they are closed on Mondays) or the pizza place in Delaware.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Drew Long
Food was great and friendly service and fast
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steph Tarno
been here a few times now as i travel between dc and nj a lot. less than $5 for two slices of hot, good pizza is a great deal and the customer service has always been friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
mike scott
Ate here 2 days in a row subs not good pizza amazing, well sub was good after I put my own olive oil and balsamic vinegar i also added hot chili with garlic sauce.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Darina Battaglia
Great stop
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Hawley
Good pizza
Lorraine Brown
I was so excited to move to Maryland and find out Nick and Joe's were still in business. N &J was the spot to hit if you went to the Castle Mall. I have decided to redo my previous review because I never read the reviews before and it looks as if someone is out to sabotage N&J REVIEWS. That is not fair because this is somebodys family who has worked hard for over 50 years. The one thing I will agree with is the girl who answers the phone ,sure does not like her job, she is rude and doesn't like for you to ask questions about anything. I've only ordered delivery because of a car accident so I can't speak on the establishment atmosphere itself. I know back in the day we loved going in because they would speak Italian and we would bring our friend who spoke Italian and the things they would say that they didn't know we could here were crazy stories we loved to eavesdropin. They also loved beautiful woman who they would also speak about but in a great way. I can tell by reading the reviews and comments that have been on here lately are being made from someone that has a grudge against them and are having people that I'm sure never been there to put bad reviews up. I would ask people to go there themselves and form your own opinion. I've had things not up to par but nothing to do with the taste and quality of the food. I would not being going there for 50 yeara if the food tasted the way the reviews said. I hope in the future people leave an honest review because even if you don't have your own business karma will get you another way . Good luck in the future Nick and Joes ... maybe just critique a few things and maybe have the phone person who is the first representative of your business go to a customer service training course on line because her attitude could already set somebody's 2mind to having a bad experience so then they look at every point of service with not so rose colored glassesI wish your nothing but the best and I just ordered your 2 medium pizza specials one with jalapenos... face 5 star for atmosphere because I'm not going to give bad stars for something idk about .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Art Miraflor
Great people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Well Done Pepperoni Pizza
Junaid Gulzar
UNWELCOMING! Poor Ownership!! Food is sub par, poor customer service, Delivery slow, no accommodations or substitutions, inflated prices. More a sandwich shop than pizzeria. Disappointing.
Pictured below is an honest review in which the owner of “Nick & Joes” responds unkindly.
Preferably better off buying Domino's unfortunately for more bang for your buck & flavor or any other prefered establishment.
...Ordered stuffed crust as well and didn't receive looking for a partial refund on that matter. (Was overcharged regardless order should've been roughly $28)
My wife and I stopped there for lunch today. We ordered the lunch special 1 bbq chicken cheese steak and 1 Buffalo with fries and 2 small sodas, 25.00. The steaks had next to no meat in them absolutely terrible. I would not reccomend this place to anyone!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Johnny’s Channel
My family and I stopped by Nick and Joe’s Pizza during a trip to New York, and unfortunately, our experience was terrible. The woman at the front counter was either having a bad day or just completely lacked customer service skills. Her attitude and energy made it clear that she had no interest in being there, which set a really negative tone for our visit.
The pizza itself was just okay, nothing special, but the real issue was the overall experience. From the moment we walked in, we felt unwelcome, as if we were inconveniencing them just by placing an order. The looks we got and the unprofessional attitude made us extremely uncomfortable.
I highly recommend that the owner address this issue either through proper customer service training or by hiring someone who actually wants to be there. Whoever Nick and Joe are (or were), I guarantee they wouldn’t be happy about how their name is being represented! I wouldn’t be surprised if many customers have chosen not to return because of a similar experience. Definitely disappointing.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Pastora Janice Batista
This is my very honest review on this place. Reviews are created to not mess a business up, but to help them improve and I hope that this review is taken seriously. I just stopped at in while traveling from North Carolina to New York City, and unfortunately, my experience was quite disappointing. My family and I were on our way to my mother's funeral, and I was hoping to find a welcoming place to enjoy a meal together and take a break from the road.
Upon entering, I was eager to order a pepperoni pizza, garlic knots, and a buffalo chicken calzone, wings…. And everything…I was planning to spend around $100 -$200 on a nice meal for my husband and our three adult kids. However, the lady at the counter looked at me with confusion when I asked for the buffalo chicken calzone, as if my order was something out of the ordinary. It was disheartening, especially given the fact that we're living in 2025 and buffalo chicken anything especially calzones are quite common. Her attitude was dismissive and unwelcoming, making me feel uncomfortable at a time when I needed kindness the most. We decided to not get anything huge or sit down to eat…. I just took a pepperoni pie and garlic knots and that’s it… spent $22 Who knows how many other people have entered this place with intentions to buy more food and her behavior discourage people from giving them their business or returning…….. 🙏🏼
In the restaurant industry, customer service is paramount. The first impression is everything, and the energy that this woman projected was far from hospitable. It's essential to treat every customer with respect and warmth, as you never know what they might be going through. Unfortunately, this experience felt very cold and uninviting.
While the food itself was okay—decent pizza and garlic knots—the overall experience was marred by the poor customer service. I genuinely believe that if the owner were to address this issue, possibly by reevaluating the staff at the front, it could lead to a much more positive atmosphere for customers. If the woman at the counter is the owner's wife, she may feel untouchable, but that shouldn't be the case in a customer-driven business. They should put somebody young with a fresh face somebody more friendly.
In conclusion, I would strongly recommend that management consider providing better training for her in customer relations to enhance the dining experience for future customers. A little kindness goes a long way, especially in the service industry.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Ibn Yemen2019
They have very good food I like this one because it’s next to the smoke shop ❤️
The pizza selection by the slice was limited (cheese or Hawaiian slices) so we ordered the Hawaiian pizza slices visible on the tray. But they didn't give us them. Instead they gave us pizza with pineapple - but no meat on the slices there.
I tried to get a salad but they didn't know how long it would take to make one, so we skipped it.
Completely indifferent service.
I suggest the B&B crab place down the road (alas they are closed on Mondays) or the pizza place in Delaware.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Food was great and friendly service and fast
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
been here a few times now as i travel between dc and nj a lot. less than $5 for two slices of hot, good pizza is a great deal and the customer service has always been friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ate here 2 days in a row subs not good pizza amazing, well sub was good after I put my own olive oil and balsamic vinegar i also added hot chili with garlic sauce.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great stop
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good pizza
I was so excited to move to Maryland and find out Nick and Joe's were still in business. N &J was the spot to hit if you went to the Castle Mall.
I have decided to redo my previous review because I never read the reviews before and it looks as if someone is out to sabotage N&J REVIEWS. That is not fair because this is somebodys family who has worked hard for over 50 years. The one thing I will agree with is the girl who answers the phone ,sure does not like her job, she is rude and doesn't like for you to ask questions about anything. I've only ordered delivery because of a car accident so I can't speak on the establishment atmosphere itself. I know back in the day we loved going in because they would speak Italian and we would bring our friend who spoke Italian and the things they would say that they didn't know we could here were crazy stories we loved to eavesdropin. They also loved beautiful woman who they would also speak about but in a great way.
I can tell by reading the reviews and comments that have been on here lately are being made from someone that has a grudge against them and are having people that I'm sure never been there to put bad reviews up. I would ask people to go there themselves and form your own opinion. I've had things not up to par but nothing to do with the taste and quality of the food. I would not being going there for 50 yeara if the food tasted the way the reviews said. I hope in the future people leave an honest review because even if you don't have your own business karma will get you another way . Good luck in the future Nick and Joes ... maybe just critique a few things and maybe have the phone person who is the first representative of your business go to a customer service training course on line because her attitude could already set somebody's 2mind to having a bad experience so then they look at every point of service with not so rose colored glassesI wish your nothing but the best and I just ordered your 2 medium pizza specials one with jalapenos... face 5 star for atmosphere because I'm not going to give bad stars for something idk about
.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Great people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Well Done Pepperoni Pizza
UNWELCOMING! Poor Ownership!! Food is sub par, poor customer service, Delivery slow, no accommodations or substitutions, inflated prices. More a sandwich shop than pizzeria. Disappointing.
Pictured below is an honest review in which the owner of “Nick & Joes” responds unkindly.
-J
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
$35 - Cheesesteak Pizza (Very Bland), Cheesecake slice, and Jalapeno Poppers
Preferably better off buying Domino's unfortunately for more bang for your buck & flavor or any other prefered establishment.
...Ordered stuffed crust as well and didn't receive looking for a partial refund on that matter. (Was overcharged regardless order should've been roughly $28)
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
My wife and I stopped there for lunch today. We ordered the lunch special 1 bbq chicken cheese steak and 1 Buffalo with fries and 2 small sodas, 25.00. The steaks had next to no meat in them absolutely terrible.
I would not reccomend this place to anyone!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
My family and I stopped by Nick and Joe’s Pizza during a trip to New York, and unfortunately, our experience was terrible. The woman at the front counter was either having a bad day or just completely lacked customer service skills. Her attitude and energy made it clear that she had no interest in being there, which set a really negative tone for our visit.
The pizza itself was just okay, nothing special, but the real issue was the overall experience. From the moment we walked in, we felt unwelcome, as if we were inconveniencing them just by placing an order. The looks we got and the unprofessional attitude made us extremely uncomfortable.
I highly recommend that the owner address this issue either through proper customer service training or by hiring someone who actually wants to be there. Whoever Nick and Joe are (or were), I guarantee they wouldn’t be happy about how their name is being represented! I wouldn’t be surprised if many customers have chosen not to return because of a similar experience. Definitely disappointing.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
This is my very honest review on this place. Reviews are created to not mess a business up, but to help them improve and I hope that this review is taken seriously. I just stopped at in while traveling from North Carolina to New York City, and unfortunately, my experience was quite disappointing. My family and I were on our way to my mother's funeral, and I was hoping to find a welcoming place to enjoy a meal together and take a break from the road.
Upon entering, I was eager to order a pepperoni pizza, garlic knots, and a buffalo chicken calzone, wings…. And everything…I was planning to spend around $100 -$200 on a nice meal for my husband and our three adult kids. However, the lady at the counter looked at me with confusion when I asked for the buffalo chicken calzone, as if my order was something out of the ordinary. It was disheartening, especially given the fact that we're living in 2025 and buffalo chicken anything especially calzones are quite common. Her attitude was dismissive and unwelcoming, making me feel uncomfortable at a time when I needed kindness the most. We decided to not get anything huge or sit down to eat…. I just took a pepperoni pie and garlic knots and that’s it… spent $22 Who knows how many other people have entered this place with intentions to buy more food and her behavior discourage people from giving them their business or returning…….. 🙏🏼
In the restaurant industry, customer service is paramount. The first impression is everything, and the energy that this woman projected was far from hospitable. It's essential to treat every customer with respect and warmth, as you never know what they might be going through. Unfortunately, this experience felt very cold and uninviting.
While the food itself was okay—decent pizza and garlic knots—the overall experience was marred by the poor customer service. I genuinely believe that if the owner were to address this issue, possibly by reevaluating the staff at the front, it could lead to a much more positive atmosphere for customers. If the woman at the counter is the owner's wife, she may feel untouchable, but that shouldn't be the case in a customer-driven business. They should put somebody young with a fresh face somebody more friendly.
In conclusion, I would strongly recommend that management consider providing better training for her in customer relations to enhance the dining experience for future customers. A little kindness goes a long way, especially in the service industry.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
They have very good food I like this one because it’s next to the smoke shop ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Everything is amazing! Love it here!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...