I got the large pizza and wings deal! I got blue cheese and mild on my wings and they were amazing!! My pizza had mushrooms and pepperoni. Really good pizza! Everything was so good! I also got their fried dough balls with icing and those are so delicious! Super friendly staff!! Just wish they weren't so busy all the time for delivery but I understand! Five stars in my book!
justin
Do not recommend Pizza taste like cardboard
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jacob Weese
Literal garbage. Ordered a pizza and boneless wings. Wings were burnt on the outside but still raw on the inside. Called back and told them and they said they would replace them. Got the replacements an hour later and they were the same way. Called back again and they said they couldn't replace them this time since they already had once. Man on phone was very rude and didn't seem to care at all. Asked for a manager and they said they don't have one? Will never order here again. Also check your equipment! Obviously something wrong with the wings other than being cooked wrong
Food: 1
Service: 1
Tracy Winebrenner
We got two pizzas delivered up to the pool over the weekend. My husband who is very picky said the crust was perfect, and it was probably the best pizza he’s had in a long while. I grew up on coney pizza, he unfortunately didn’t. Hats off to you all he’s very hard to please. He said we will be back for sure ?
Lori Folk
We moved to Barton MD 3 years ago and later found out, sadly, Coney Pizza is the only food place that will deliver to our area. You would think because of the extra business they get just for this reason they would strive to make their food and service top-notch! When we first moved to the area the food was always fresh, hot, and correct, and portion size was good but this has changed. I try not to order at all anymore but after working all day and both my husband and I not wanting to make dinner we end up giving them another try. Our mistake I guess. The last time we ordered I got a salad, when it came the dressing was all over it and I don't like to put my leftover salad in the fridge with dressing on it because it kills the lettuce so couldn't save the rest when I was full. Waste of money. I always order the stampede baked potato with no steak and extra cheese. I don't prefer to eat meat... With ordering no meat they are usually pretty generous with the other toppings, grilled onions, and mushrooms, this time there are probably 3 of each, mushrooms and grilled onions. We ordered nachos with seasoned beef, cheddar cheese, and sour cream. The chips were so stale they don't even break, they just bend, and they even taste stale. I called and asked to speak with a manager, they said there wasn't one on shift so they took my number and said one would call me back. I guess I don't get to eat tonight because they will want to see the food or even want it back... Waste of money again. I didn't even get into the rude, disrespectful customer service. There is one guy that delivers to us that is always very nice and respectful but that's about it.
Update: We have not heard from anyone! No one has called to ask what the problem was or to see if they could resolve the issue, nothing! Absolutely ridiculous! Horrible customer service and customer care! No regard for people spending their hard-earned money to eat and not getting what they paid for/ordered or even being able to eat the food they ordered!
Food: 1
Service: 1
Carissa
I love this place and always have. The owner is a wonderful local man whom everyone seems to like. The food is usually always good and its decently priced.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
Tristen Hodo
My pizza was old and my onion rings were burnt. I'm disappointed.
Food: 3
Sebastian _
Food is always amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joseph Beckner
They want to change 1.75 for to make sure the wings are wet. Tired of restaurants charging for extras when they’re not extras. So they can keep their food. Went
Service: 1
Brittany Coates
So I call, ask for onion rings, chicken tenders, a whole steak an cheese sub, an bacon cheeseburger. My food get here. A whole hour n 30 mins.Sub was wrong. It was a BLT I call to get our sub that we ordered in the 1st place. They say they want there BLT sub back FOR the steakcheese sub I ordered 1st.a whole hour they get here with the steakcheese sub was told we did not have the other sub. An sub was given to us anyways. We get a call from the shop being cussed at saying we had to pay for the BLT we did not order. All in all that's bad customer service an was not no one else mess but there's.
Decided to try something new. Unfortunately will not be spending money again here. Compared to other places the value for what you get is much better. Very sparse toppings on the pizza. “1/2 pound” of boneless wings were $9 and you can see from the photos what we got….. ranch spilled in the pickles because it was in the container and the lid morphed and spilled all over. Wings were a mix of small and large, I would think to compensate for ones that are very small you would get another to account for the difference. Ordered on wing night, wanted 6 of a few different flavors and was told had to do 10 of each. Not very friendly on the phone or in person. Another customer there when I came to pick up and was also complaining about her order. Seems to be a trend. I’m all for supporting local businesses, but based on the other person there and other reviews, I don’t think I’m alone with my dissatisfaction. Drove 30 mins from Keyser so wasn’t going back to complain.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Ancient Guardians Farm
Great food. Definitely suggest calling ahead. Only suggestion I could make is updating the menu or updating the board with specials.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Traditional Stromboli
christopher turner
My wife ordered pizza2 hours later still no deliveryCalled and was told we can’t cancel order.Never go back
Carissa Preston
Great fresh dough cheesticks and pizza. Quick convienant service and good prices.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Asyouwish T
Delicious pizza and breadsticks. Very large menu. Over 200 items.
I got the large pizza and wings deal! I got blue cheese and mild on my wings and they were amazing!! My pizza had mushrooms and pepperoni. Really good pizza! Everything was so good! I also got their fried dough balls with icing and those are so delicious! Super friendly staff!! Just wish they weren't so busy all the time for delivery but I understand! Five stars in my book!
Do not recommend Pizza taste like cardboard
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Literal garbage. Ordered a pizza and boneless wings. Wings were burnt on the outside but still raw on the inside. Called back and told them and they said they would replace them. Got the replacements an hour later and they were the same way. Called back again and they said they couldn't replace them this time since they already had once. Man on phone was very rude and didn't seem to care at all. Asked for a manager and they said they don't have one? Will never order here again. Also check your equipment! Obviously something wrong with the wings other than being cooked wrong
Food: 1
Service: 1
We got two pizzas delivered up to the pool over the weekend. My husband who is very picky said the crust was perfect, and it was probably the best pizza he’s had in a long while. I grew up on coney pizza, he unfortunately didn’t. Hats off to you all he’s very hard to please. He said we will be back for sure ?
We moved to Barton MD 3 years ago and later found out, sadly, Coney Pizza is the only food place that will deliver to our area. You would think because of the extra business they get just for this reason they would strive to make their food and service top-notch! When we first moved to the area the food was always fresh, hot, and correct, and portion size was good but this has changed. I try not to order at all anymore but after working all day and both my husband and I not wanting to make dinner we end up giving them another try. Our mistake I guess. The last time we ordered I got a salad, when it came the dressing was all over it and I don't like to put my leftover salad in the fridge with dressing on it because it kills the lettuce so couldn't save the rest when I was full. Waste of money. I always order the stampede baked potato with no steak and extra cheese. I don't prefer to eat meat... With ordering no meat they are usually pretty generous with the other toppings, grilled onions, and mushrooms, this time there are probably 3 of each, mushrooms and grilled onions. We ordered nachos with seasoned beef, cheddar cheese, and sour cream. The chips were so stale they don't even break, they just bend, and they even taste stale. I called and asked to speak with a manager, they said there wasn't one on shift so they took my number and said one would call me back. I guess I don't get to eat tonight because they will want to see the food or even want it back... Waste of money again. I didn't even get into the rude, disrespectful customer service. There is one guy that delivers to us that is always very nice and respectful but that's about it.
Update:
We have not heard from anyone! No one has called to ask what the problem was or to see if they could resolve the issue, nothing! Absolutely ridiculous! Horrible customer service and customer care! No regard for people spending their hard-earned money to eat and not getting what they paid for/ordered or even being able to eat the food they ordered!
Food: 1
Service: 1
I love this place and always have. The owner is a wonderful local man whom everyone seems to like. The food is usually always good and its decently priced.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
My pizza was old and my onion rings were burnt. I'm disappointed.
Food: 3
Food is always amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They want to change 1.75 for to make sure the wings are wet. Tired of restaurants charging for extras when they’re not extras. So they can keep their food. Went
Service: 1
So I call, ask for onion rings, chicken tenders, a whole steak an cheese sub, an bacon cheeseburger. My food get here. A whole hour n 30 mins.Sub was wrong. It was a BLT I call to get our sub that we ordered in the 1st place. They say they want there BLT sub back FOR the steakcheese sub I ordered 1st.a whole hour they get here with the steakcheese sub was told we did not have the other sub. An sub was given to us anyways. We get a call from the shop being cussed at saying we had to pay for the BLT we did not order. All in all that's bad customer service an was not no one else mess but there's.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Decided to try something new. Unfortunately will not be spending money again here. Compared to other places the value for what you get is much better. Very sparse toppings on the pizza. “1/2 pound” of boneless wings were $9 and you can see from the photos what we got….. ranch spilled in the pickles because it was in the container and the lid morphed and spilled all over. Wings were a mix of small and large, I would think to compensate for ones that are very small you would get another to account for the difference. Ordered on wing night, wanted 6 of a few different flavors and was told had to do 10 of each. Not very friendly on the phone or in person. Another customer there when I came to pick up and was also complaining about her order. Seems to be a trend. I’m all for supporting local businesses, but based on the other person there and other reviews, I don’t think I’m alone with my dissatisfaction. Drove 30 mins from Keyser so wasn’t going back to complain.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Great food. Definitely suggest calling ahead. Only suggestion I could make is updating the menu or updating the board with specials.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Traditional Stromboli
My wife ordered pizza2 hours later still no deliveryCalled and was told we can’t cancel order.Never go back
Great fresh dough cheesticks and pizza. Quick convienant service and good prices.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Delicious pizza and breadsticks. Very large menu. Over 200 items.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Loading...