Love this little pizza place! Have had 2 of my son’s parties here and the staff is always responsive and friendly. The pizza is great with my favorite being cheese and mushroom. The buy one pizza get one for .99 Tuesdays are always awesome!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Pilecki
This pizza place has a fantastic atmosphere—cozy, lively, and exactly what you want for a casual night out with friends or family. The decor is spot-on, lighting is warm, and there's a great energy without being too loud. Service was truly excellent: our server was friendly, attentive, and quick with refills and checks throughout the meal. They made us feel welcome from the moment we walked in. Unfortunately, the food didn't quite match the rest of the experience. The pizza crust came out very floppy—when we picked up a slice, it folded completely and the cheese slid right off. It seemed like the sauce was too watery, which made everything overly soggy and hard to eat without a fork. Flavor-wise it was just bland with the topping s being best part but the texture issues were a big letdown. One person in our party ordered a hot dog, and the bun was rock-hard—when he bit into it, it actually crumbled and fell apart. The hot dog itself was fine, but the stale bun ruined it. Overall, this spot has a lot going for it with the ambiance and top-notch service, and we'd consider coming back if the kitchen tightens up consistency on the basics. With a few tweaks to the dough/sauce ratio and fresher buns, this could easily be a go-to spot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Anees Ahmad
We're regulars at Potomac. Pizza is easily best in the area. Potomac has a kind and welcoming staff, encourages and implements customer feedback, has clean and modern ambience, and has a generous rewards program.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Nicholas Lloyd
I went in with my fiancé today to grab Lucy and we used to live around the corner from here and never had a problem. First time in forever we say “hey we are passing by let’s grab lunch” we placed our order and grabbed the bag and just left. Didn’t think to check the print out on the side of the bag. I should have thought something was weird when I asked about what bread my “turkey club” comes on and she labeled off they had all kinds of turkey things and she said Italian and that’s fine. I mentioned turkey club 2 more times in the conversation. Long story short I get home open my “turkey club” to find a sorry excuse of a turkey burger between bread. Not even a single condiment. Really I won’t be back ever again, always thought they were some over priced place but my fiancé liked them. Tried giving it to my dogs and they just ran from it. This is sad. Even tipped $15. Now I’m out of $30 between the sorry excuse of a sandwich and my tip.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
Laura Forbes
Enjoyable in all ways
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Danny Junior
This is not your normal pizza place, if you are looking for a pizza that you will want again and again this is your place. My wife and I got introduced to this place and now I don't want another places pizza. I love the meat lovers pizza it has the meats you want but non of them over power each other. The sauce that they use is just right not to much but not to little either. It take me back to the way pizzas were made in the seventies and eighties when the store cared about the product they were making and cared about the customer. The staff knows how to make you feel welcome like you are stepping in to an old family restaurant they will greet you when you walk in and talk to you like they have known you for years. This is my go to pizza place for great pizza. The only thing I wish they had I don't know if they do or not is stuffed crust pizza. So if you want great pizza at a great price Potomac Pizza is the place to go. Almost for got they don't just make pizza they also have a full menu
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Patrick Beatty
Pizza was outstanding. Daphy was super friendly and engaging. Clean venue. The live music was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Aaron Brown
Was working in the area & didn't want subway so I wal over to Potomac. The aroma from outside was amazing. Ordered the cheese steak which surprised me how good it was. The service was top notch. Came back the next day on purpose!!!
Ree E.
This is the first time I've ever been to Potomac Pizza. The service was phenomenal. We were welcomed/greeted as soon as we got in. Tables were placed together with no problem due to us having a large party. It was my nephews 2nd birthday and he was able to roam around the restaurant without any dirty stares so I love that it was kid friendly. Our appetizers came out first and with enough time to finish them, then our pizza came out right on time and hot. We kept it simple, 2 pepperoni and 1 cheese pizza. It tastes like brick oven pizza, not sure if it is or not. The cheese pull was everything. It is some thick cheese if you like that, but it does not look heavy on the cheese from first glance. There was a small bar section to the left and it was full. I think I will be back to sit there and try something else besides pizza and update my review at that time. The restaurant/carry out is cute, not too small not to big. I do not know how they managed to get a bar, carry section, and a dinning room area for families to sit in and enjoy a meal in such a way that it doesnt feel tiny and pushed together. Overall, excellent experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gary Light
Great little pizza place close to SpringHill Suites.
We hosted an event for work at Potomac Pizza (Middle River) last night and it was incredible! The manager, Alex, made the planning process so seamless and was so helpful and response. He was also present the day of the event along with 2 bartenders, Donny & Lauren, who were also just as great! I was very impressed with their service and our guests really enjoyed them too. The event was made so simple and we will absolutely be back! Thanks so much guys!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shinies Glitters
Very nice cozy place with friendly staff and cool historical photos of the areas history
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tina Offley-Boyd
The pizza was amazing. Freshly made and hot. Initially, my husband's pizza wasn't correct. The bartender/server quickly corrected the mistake and made sure we were happy. Outstanding service. This will definitely be our new go to spot. Restaurant and bathrooms very clean. With football season starting we are looking forward to hanging out there.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shirlonda Scott
Service was good. The pizza was ok but good atmosphere and comfortable. They have a happy hour. Pricing was reasonable. I enjoyed it.
Love this little pizza place! Have had 2 of my son’s parties here and the staff is always responsive and friendly. The pizza is great with my favorite being cheese and mushroom. The buy one pizza get one for .99 Tuesdays are always awesome!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This pizza place has a fantastic atmosphere—cozy, lively, and exactly what you want for a casual night out with friends or family. The decor is spot-on, lighting is warm, and there's a great energy without being too loud. Service was truly excellent: our server was friendly, attentive, and quick with refills and checks throughout the meal. They made us feel welcome from the moment we walked in.
Unfortunately, the food didn't quite match the rest of the experience. The pizza crust came out very floppy—when we picked up a slice, it folded completely and the cheese slid right off. It seemed like the sauce was too watery, which made everything overly soggy and hard to eat without a fork. Flavor-wise it was just bland with the topping s being best part but the texture issues were a big letdown.
One person in our party ordered a hot dog, and the bun was rock-hard—when he bit into it, it actually crumbled and fell apart. The hot dog itself was fine, but the stale bun ruined it.
Overall, this spot has a lot going for it with the ambiance and top-notch service, and we'd consider coming back if the kitchen tightens up consistency on the basics. With a few tweaks to the dough/sauce ratio and fresher buns, this could easily be a go-to spot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
We're regulars at Potomac. Pizza is easily best in the area. Potomac has a kind and welcoming staff, encourages and implements customer feedback, has clean and modern ambience, and has a generous rewards program.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
I went in with my fiancé today to grab Lucy and we used to live around the corner from here and never had a problem. First time in forever we say “hey we are passing by let’s grab lunch” we placed our order and grabbed the bag and just left. Didn’t think to check the print out on the side of the bag. I should have thought something was weird when I asked about what bread my “turkey club” comes on and she labeled off they had all kinds of turkey things and she said Italian and that’s fine. I mentioned turkey club 2 more times in the conversation. Long story short I get home open my “turkey club” to find a sorry excuse of a turkey burger between bread. Not even a single condiment. Really I won’t be back ever again, always thought they were some over priced place but my fiancé liked them. Tried giving it to my dogs and they just ran from it. This is sad. Even tipped $15. Now I’m out of $30 between the sorry excuse of a sandwich and my tip.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
Enjoyable in all ways
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is not your normal pizza place, if you are looking for a pizza that you will want again and again this is your place. My wife and I got introduced to this place and now I don't want another places pizza. I love the meat lovers pizza it has the meats you want but non of them over power each other. The sauce that they use is just right not to much but not to little either. It take me back to the way pizzas were made in the seventies and eighties when the store cared about the product they were making and cared about the customer. The staff knows how to make you feel welcome like you are stepping in to an old family restaurant they will greet you when you walk in and talk to you like they have known you for years. This is my go to pizza place for great pizza. The only thing I wish they had I don't know if they do or not is stuffed crust pizza. So if you want great pizza at a great price Potomac Pizza is the place to go. Almost for got they don't just make pizza they also have a full menu
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza was outstanding. Daphy was super friendly and engaging. Clean venue. The live music was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Was working in the area & didn't want subway so I wal over to Potomac. The aroma from outside was amazing. Ordered the cheese steak which surprised me how good it was. The service was top notch. Came back the next day on purpose!!!
This is the first time I've ever been to Potomac Pizza. The service was phenomenal. We were welcomed/greeted as soon as we got in. Tables were placed together with no problem due to us having a large party. It was my nephews 2nd birthday and he was able to roam around the restaurant without any dirty stares so I love that it was kid friendly. Our appetizers came out first and with enough time to finish them, then our pizza came out right on time and hot. We kept it simple, 2 pepperoni and 1 cheese pizza. It tastes like brick oven pizza, not sure if it is or not. The cheese pull was everything. It is some thick cheese if you like that, but it does not look heavy on the cheese from first glance. There was a small bar section to the left and it was full. I think I will be back to sit there and try something else besides pizza and update my review at that time. The restaurant/carry out is cute, not too small not to big. I do not know how they managed to get a bar, carry section, and a dinning room area for families to sit in and enjoy a meal in such a way that it doesnt feel tiny and pushed together. Overall, excellent experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great little pizza place close to SpringHill Suites.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
We hosted an event for work at Potomac Pizza (Middle River) last night and it was incredible! The manager, Alex, made the planning process so seamless and was so helpful and response. He was also present the day of the event along with 2 bartenders, Donny & Lauren, who were also just as great! I was very impressed with their service and our guests really enjoyed them too. The event was made so simple and we will absolutely be back! Thanks so much guys!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very nice cozy place with friendly staff and cool historical photos of the areas history
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza was amazing. Freshly made and hot. Initially, my husband's pizza wasn't correct. The bartender/server quickly corrected the mistake and made sure we were happy. Outstanding service. This will definitely be our new go to spot. Restaurant and bathrooms very clean. With football season starting we are looking forward to hanging out there.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Service was good. The pizza was ok but good atmosphere and comfortable. They have a happy hour. Pricing was reasonable. I enjoyed it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Good pizza, as well as other selections of food.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Loading...