Had an amazing experience the food was delicious. We did hit a busy period and seating was tight and they had run out of chicken but otherwise was an amazing lunch!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
J D
Update: 2 stars. Far too inconsistent. Sometimes it is a 5* sometimes, like tonight it is 1* (if that). Have ordered a burger Medium Rare at least 6-8 times. Maybe half the time they get it right. The other half of the time it isn't even close, very well done, all grey, dry, not good. This trip was an all-around train wreck. Arrived to a basically empty dining room at 5:45. Only 2 tables seated ahead of us. Appetizers took 30 mins. Meals were 45 mins. Delivered some of our food and the rest didn't arrive for nearly 10 mins. Entrees with no sides for 10 mins. Ordered 2 burgers Medium Rare, both came out very well done. This happens far too often here. Try to give them the benefit of the doubt but far too inconsistent. Never were checked on to ask of everything was alright. The servers are great and work hard but somehow the service is often bad due to a bad and slow kitchen. Food has so much potential, when it is good it is great but sadly, that doesn't seem to happen often enough. They usually offer to remake burgers but that shouldn't be required 50% of the time. Tonight, with already waiting nearly an hour we didn't have the time to wait longer to get our food right.
*see pics: one burger Medium Rare as ordered and it was awesome. The other ordered as medium rare and very well done and not very good.
Original review: Great food spot. Excellent burgers (edit: when cooked properly). Honestly, pretty much everything we have tried has been great. One of the best beer menus around the area as well. Staff is awesome.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Donna Lehigh
Love Love Love your Feta Fries!!! Very tasty food and excellent service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rhonda Ball
Ate here tonight for the 1st time. I grew up in the panhandle of Florida, surrounded by some of the best seafood & gator there is. Tonight I had the best I've tasted since moving up here in 2011. We had the Gator Bites & Spicy Mahi. REAL Big chunks of Gator (no flakes & batter mess) that melted in your mouth! Aaahhhh, the Spicy Mahi! Cooked perfectly, along with the spinach & sauce. The BEST food & dining experience I've had in Maryland. Cannot recommend enough!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeff
Thank you DJ and adorable staff!!! Yall are the best! Jeff and Rhonda
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kylan Connolly
A great local spot that New Windsor crucially needs. The portions are generous and the food quality is great. I recommend anything that comes with the house made potato chips and the cream of crab soup.
Food: 5
Sollux Lazuli
Cute little restaurant with delicious food! I'm obsessed with the fried alligator!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sandy Long
Place to be in New Windsor MD
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emmy Yonkoski
Great food and drinks. Customer service is incredible. Been there 3 times now and as food was absolutely delicious 😋. We took home leftovers, as usual. The appetizers we get fill me up sometimes. Gator Nuggets and Feta Fries, OMG. Plus it's in walking distance from my house.
I’ve been there twice. The grandchildren loved it the first time and my husband loved it the second. Very nice casual atmosphere, friendly service, and pretty good food. The menu is pretty boring and makes you think the food will be too, but it is not. We all enjoyed everything we tried, the handmade potato chips are especially good. Looking forward to trying more things on the menu.
Jeff Myers
We have never had a bad experience at Mattys. DJ is an awesome waiter. Great food.
Eric M. Lipsius
Great food, Awesome bottle/can selection of beers, and friendly staff!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lisa W
My friend and I came here about a week ago! I loved the atmosphere ~ it was relaxing and I adored the stained glass windows and light fixtures. Restroom was also nice and clean.
Service and food were fantastic! I had the tuna salad with side salad and vinaigrette.
I'll be coming back and recommending this place to more friends and family😊
Thanks so much!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tim Bartek
The acoustics are bad, so it is very loud. While the food is very good the prices are high.
Had an amazing experience the food was delicious. We did hit a busy period and seating was tight and they had run out of chicken but otherwise was an amazing lunch!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Update: 2 stars. Far too inconsistent. Sometimes it is a 5* sometimes, like tonight it is 1* (if that). Have ordered a burger Medium Rare at least 6-8 times. Maybe half the time they get it right. The other half of the time it isn't even close, very well done, all grey, dry, not good. This trip was an all-around train wreck. Arrived to a basically empty dining room at 5:45. Only 2 tables seated ahead of us. Appetizers took 30 mins. Meals were 45 mins. Delivered some of our food and the rest didn't arrive for nearly 10 mins. Entrees with no sides for 10 mins. Ordered 2 burgers Medium Rare, both came out very well done. This happens far too often here. Try to give them the benefit of the doubt but far too inconsistent. Never were checked on to ask of everything was alright.
The servers are great and work hard but somehow the service is often bad due to a bad and slow kitchen. Food has so much potential, when it is good it is great but sadly, that doesn't seem to happen often enough. They usually offer to remake burgers but that shouldn't be required 50% of the time. Tonight, with already waiting nearly an hour we didn't have the time to wait longer to get our food right.
*see pics: one burger Medium Rare as ordered and it was awesome. The other ordered as medium rare and very well done and not very good.
Original review:
Great food spot. Excellent burgers (edit: when cooked properly). Honestly, pretty much everything we have tried has been great. One of the best beer menus around the area as well. Staff is awesome.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Love Love Love your Feta Fries!!!
Very tasty food and excellent service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ate here tonight for the 1st time. I grew up in the panhandle of Florida, surrounded by some of the best seafood & gator there is. Tonight I had the best I've tasted since moving up here in 2011.
We had the Gator Bites & Spicy Mahi.
REAL Big chunks of Gator (no flakes & batter mess) that melted in your mouth! Aaahhhh, the Spicy Mahi! Cooked perfectly, along with the spinach & sauce.
The BEST food & dining experience I've had in Maryland.
Cannot recommend enough!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Thank you DJ and adorable staff!!! Yall are the best! Jeff and Rhonda
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A great local spot that New Windsor crucially needs. The portions are generous and the food quality is great. I recommend anything that comes with the house made potato chips and the cream of crab soup.
Food: 5
Cute little restaurant with delicious food! I'm obsessed with the fried alligator!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Place to be in New Windsor MD
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food and drinks. Customer service is incredible. Been there 3 times now and as food was absolutely delicious 😋. We took home leftovers, as usual. The appetizers we get fill me up sometimes. Gator Nuggets and Feta Fries, OMG. Plus it's in walking distance from my house.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious food and great service!
Restaurantji Recommends
I’ve been there twice. The grandchildren loved it the first time and my husband loved it the second. Very nice casual atmosphere, friendly service, and pretty good food. The menu is pretty boring and makes you think the food will be too, but it is not. We all enjoyed everything we tried, the handmade potato chips are especially good. Looking forward to trying more things on the menu.
We have never had a bad experience at Mattys. DJ is an awesome waiter. Great food.
Great food, Awesome bottle/can selection of beers, and friendly staff!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My friend and I came here about a week ago! I loved the atmosphere ~ it was relaxing and I adored the stained glass windows and light fixtures. Restroom was also nice and clean.
Service and food were fantastic! I had the tuna salad with side salad and vinaigrette.
I'll be coming back and recommending this place to more friends and family😊
Thanks so much!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The acoustics are bad, so it is very loud. While the food is very good the prices are high.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...