This is a solid little place. Our food was good, the sever very attentive, and just a cozy place. We both enjoyed our lunch here
Catherine Gill
We had an excellent late lunch at Uncle Matty's Eatery with our family. The food was great, with good portion sizes at a very fair price. I personally enjoyed the atmosphere, even as other diners came in for dinner we never felt crowded or or rushed. The service was good and attentive. I enjoyed the knowledge of the staff and the depth of the beer/alcohol selection was impressive. We will definitely be back again when we are in the neighborhood.
William Johnson
food was amazing. loved the service
Ruv Ghost
Food is awesome, go there quite often. Service is sometimes slow on busy days but is mostly like awesome, staff r really friendly too. The atmosphere is pretty great, its a little not on theme sometimes but the food is so good that u don't even notice it.
Roni
Great restaurant! Definitely going to be our new go-to spot!
Chris Kovolenko
Best crab soup around. Always spot on! Thanks Matty’s!
Terri Wilson
Love Matty's!! I've been coming here for years. The food is real and tasty and homemade. The portions are generous and the prices stay low despite the rising costs around us. The servers are bar none the best, most personable out there. Tonight, some asshat at the bar played videos on his phone WAY too loud and I still had great food and a great time! Matty's has always been great to me and I'm a loyal fan.
Linda Dreer
Awesome place to eat with an original menu and craft beers. Great service and generous portions.
Josh Sizemore
The employees were all very friendly and attentive. I'd put their burger up against any other restaurant in Carroll County. No complaints to speak of.
Joshua Ziegler
Food was absolutely delicious and along with it service was excellent. DJ knew every intricate detail about the foods he was serving and made a great beer choice for me to try. Wife and I were looking for a new place to try and landed here. Thankfully we did. Everything was great. We will definitely be coming back!
My husband, son and I came in today for lunch. I came in with simple, standard expectations but they were far exceeded. The atmosphere is cozy, warm and inviting, the service was prompt and friendly, and the food was fantastic! All 3 of us thoroughly enjoyed our meals. We will definitely return again to try some more menu deliciousness. Uncle Matty's is a diamond in New Windsor and I highly recommend!
Donna Carbone
Donna Carbone I finally found my homemade pasta and meatballs! I will definitely be back again and again! The marinara sauce was like my own! That I simmered all day! And the meatballs were heaven! Great service, just down home!! Should be 10 stars ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jackie Kline
I cant believe we’ve never been here. EVERYTHING was excellent! Cream of crab soup, scallops, chicken dinners 🤤 our new favorite place!
Becky Harding
Friends and I came here after walking around a nearby historical site. So glad we did! Super friendly & informative front person who equipped, "I'm just the outer face - Uncle Matty stays in the kitchen." Excellent sandwiches & panini; we all shared bites. Comfortable booth & great service. Street parking could be scarce on other than just after lunchtime on a Friday.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Donna P
We are very fortunate to have this gem in New Windsor. The service is always welcoming and attentive . The curated beer selection never disappoints and we loved our selections this evening. Our food was delicious and no one left hungry. Definitely a hometown favorite.
This is a solid little place. Our food was good, the sever very attentive, and just a cozy place. We both enjoyed our lunch here
We had an excellent late lunch at Uncle Matty's Eatery with our family. The food was great, with good portion sizes at a very fair price. I personally enjoyed the atmosphere, even as other diners came in for dinner we never felt crowded or or rushed. The service was good and attentive. I enjoyed the knowledge of the staff and the depth of the beer/alcohol selection was impressive. We will definitely be back again when we are in the neighborhood.
food was amazing. loved the service
Food is awesome, go there quite often. Service is sometimes slow on busy days but is mostly like awesome, staff r really friendly too. The atmosphere is pretty great, its a little not on theme sometimes but the food is so good that u don't even notice it.
Great restaurant! Definitely going to be our new go-to spot!
Best crab soup around. Always spot on! Thanks Matty’s!
Love Matty's!! I've been coming here for years. The food is real and tasty and homemade. The portions are generous and the prices stay low despite the rising costs around us. The servers are bar none the best, most personable out there. Tonight, some asshat at the bar played videos on his phone WAY too loud and I still had great food and a great time! Matty's has always been great to me and I'm a loyal fan.
Awesome place to eat with an original menu and craft beers. Great service and generous portions.
The employees were all very friendly and attentive. I'd put their burger up against any other restaurant in Carroll County. No complaints to speak of.
Food was absolutely delicious and along with it service was excellent. DJ knew every intricate detail about the foods he was serving and made a great beer choice for me to try. Wife and I were looking for a new place to try and landed here. Thankfully we did. Everything was great. We will definitely be coming back!
Restaurantji Recommends
My husband, son and I came in today for lunch. I came in with simple, standard expectations but they were far exceeded. The atmosphere is cozy, warm and inviting, the service was prompt and friendly, and the food was fantastic! All 3 of us thoroughly enjoyed our meals. We will definitely return again to try some more menu deliciousness. Uncle Matty's is a diamond in New Windsor and I highly recommend!
Donna Carbone
I finally found my homemade pasta and meatballs! I will definitely be back again and again! The marinara sauce was like my own! That I simmered all day! And the meatballs were heaven! Great service, just down home!! Should be 10 stars ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I cant believe we’ve never been here. EVERYTHING was excellent! Cream of crab soup, scallops, chicken dinners 🤤 our new favorite place!
Friends and I came here after walking around a nearby historical site. So glad we did!
Super friendly & informative front person who equipped, "I'm just the outer face - Uncle Matty stays in the kitchen."
Excellent sandwiches & panini; we all shared bites. Comfortable booth & great service.
Street parking could be scarce on other than just after lunchtime on a Friday.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We are very fortunate to have this gem in New Windsor. The service is always welcoming and attentive . The curated beer selection never disappoints and we loved our selections this evening. Our food was delicious and no one left hungry. Definitely a hometown favorite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...