Fun! Had cocktails & a bite to eat while enjoying a wonderful band
William B Raker Jr.
Exceptional food and service.
Delmas Dotson
This is a MARVELOUS Place..Other than the hostess being very RUDE we had an AWESOME meal with a GREAT server Daniel.. Daniel was super nice and very down to earth and very helpful with our meal and directing us to get WONDERFUL pics..The HOSTESS i would give a 1 where the rest of the staff were AWESOME 👌..
Ana Rodriguez
Excellent service and the food was so delicious I got the salmon with mush potatoes and green beans everything was cool and food was brought to the table on time. I also got a margarita and it was great and very refreshing. I went for dinner and the sunset was breathtaking . Would def go back!!
Rick Rohrs
What a great time: friendly and fast service, reasonable prices, and great music. Great diverse crowd from 5-10.
Jeff S
I’ve place on the water
Michael Rogers
Lovely atmosphere and service!
Ann Fitz
My husband took me to Fagers Island for my BD dinner. The atmosphere, view, staff and food were amazing!! Definitely my favorite place in Ocean City, Md! Bought sweatshirts in the gift shop and love them as well! Thank you to all who enjoy working there! We will be back and highly recommend! ❤️
Nia Learning
As long-time visitors to Ocean City, Maryland – over 35 years and counting – my wife and I have experienced a wide spectrum of accommodations, from classic boardwalk hotels to luxurious downtown stays like the Cambria. However, for the past several years, there is only one place that truly feels like "home" in Ocean City, and that's Fager's Island.
In our mid-50s and 60s, we've found something truly unique and unparalleled here. While the stunning bayfront sunsets, expertly timed to the "1812 Overture," are always a highlight, it's the unwavering warmth and personal touch that sets Fager's Island apart.
The fact that staff members like Adriana and Peyton greet us by name upon arrival speaks volumes. This level of personalized service isn't just professional; it's genuinely heartwarming and creates an immediate sense of belonging and familiarity that we haven't found anywhere else. It's clear that your team values repeat guests and cultivates an environment where genuine connections are forged.
Beyond the exceptional service, we continue to be drawn to Fager's Island for:
The Unbeatable Ambiance: Whether we're enjoying a casual meal on the deck, soaking in the lively atmosphere of the bar, or indulging in the fine dining experience, the vibe is consistently perfect for a relaxing and enjoyable getaway.
Consistently Excellent Food and Drink: From the "lite fare" to the more elaborate dinner selections, we've always found the cuisine to be of the highest quality, complemented by a superb beverage selection.
The Overall Experience: It's more than just a hotel or a restaurant; it's a complete destination where every detail seems thoughtfully curated for guest enjoyment.
Fager's Island has become an integral part of our Ocean City tradition, and we look forward to many more years of creating cherished memories with you. Thank you for making our stays so consistently exceptional and for truly understanding what it means to create a unique and welcoming experience.
Larry and Cathy
Jay Von Runnen
Food: Oysters Rockefeller - too much spinach, not much flavor otherwise. Cream of crab soup - salty, not much crab. Lobster tail arrived cold. Drawn butter watered down and cold. Crab cake very good, filet good. Service: very good but - forgot repeated requests for a straw for water. Brought rosemary potatoes instead of specifically requested baked potato. Summary: been there several times. Spent a lot of money. Tipped 20+ %. Disappointed, we will not go back.
Great food and service for Valentine’s Day weekend!
Judy
Excellent! Our waiter was knowledgeable of the menu, gave us great suggestions and was so kind! The food was the best we've ever had! The atmosphere was wonderful and the view was definitely the best in Ocean City Maryland!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Harry Burns
Sunset is beautiful
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
CWOK
We went there on a busy night, but they were able to seat us at a high top by the bar quickly. Our server was friendly and although she was very busy, she took good care of us. The Chilean sea bass in plum sauce was excellent and the lemon lush dessert is so good it would be worth going there just to eat that. I have been there before and I recommend sticking to the seafood rather than the steak, which was just average and was kind of tough. I hate to say anything negative about the place because the seafood I've had there has always been top notch, so definitely don't skip this place if you're looking for upscale dining, but I wanted to leave an honest review. Thank you Fager's Island for a really enjoyable dinner.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lemon Lust, Fish, Seafood
Tony B
We've only been for Shell Shocked. It's definitely oversold; it's packed. Good luck finding a place to sit. Otherwise the food is great. Plenty of oysters and great beer. Parking is no problem. Great staff. Good bands.
Fun! Had cocktails & a bite to eat while enjoying a wonderful band
Exceptional food and service.
This is a MARVELOUS Place..Other than the hostess being very RUDE we had an AWESOME meal with a GREAT server Daniel.. Daniel was super nice and very down to earth and very helpful with our meal and directing us to get WONDERFUL pics..The HOSTESS i would give a 1 where the rest of the staff were AWESOME 👌..
Excellent service and the food was so delicious I got the salmon with mush potatoes and green beans everything was cool and food was brought to the table on time. I also got a margarita and it was great and very refreshing. I went for dinner and the sunset was breathtaking . Would def go back!!
What a great time: friendly and fast service, reasonable prices, and great music. Great diverse crowd from 5-10.
I’ve place on the water
Lovely atmosphere and service!
My husband took me to Fagers Island for my BD dinner. The atmosphere, view, staff and food were amazing!! Definitely my favorite place in Ocean City, Md! Bought sweatshirts in the gift shop and love them as well! Thank you to all who enjoy working there! We will be back and highly recommend! ❤️
As long-time visitors to Ocean City, Maryland – over 35 years and counting – my wife and I have experienced a wide spectrum of accommodations, from classic boardwalk hotels to luxurious downtown stays like the Cambria. However, for the past several years, there is only one place that truly feels like "home" in Ocean City, and that's Fager's Island. In our mid-50s and 60s, we've found something truly unique and unparalleled here. While the stunning bayfront sunsets, expertly timed to the "1812 Overture," are always a highlight, it's the unwavering warmth and personal touch that sets Fager's Island apart. The fact that staff members like Adriana and Peyton greet us by name upon arrival speaks volumes. This level of personalized service isn't just professional; it's genuinely heartwarming and creates an immediate sense of belonging and familiarity that we haven't found anywhere else. It's clear that your team values repeat guests and cultivates an environment where genuine connections are forged. Beyond the exceptional service, we continue to be drawn to Fager's Island for: The Unbeatable Ambiance: Whether we're enjoying a casual meal on the deck, soaking in the lively atmosphere of the bar, or indulging in the fine dining experience, the vibe is consistently perfect for a relaxing and enjoyable getaway. Consistently Excellent Food and Drink: From the "lite fare" to the more elaborate dinner selections, we've always found the cuisine to be of the highest quality, complemented by a superb beverage selection. The Overall Experience: It's more than just a hotel or a restaurant; it's a complete destination where every detail seems thoughtfully curated for guest enjoyment. Fager's Island has become an integral part of our Ocean City tradition, and we look forward to many more years of creating cherished memories with you. Thank you for making our stays so consistently exceptional and for truly understanding what it means to create a unique and welcoming experience. Larry and Cathy
Food: Oysters Rockefeller - too much spinach, not much flavor otherwise. Cream of crab soup - salty, not much crab. Lobster tail arrived cold. Drawn butter watered down and cold. Crab cake very good, filet good. Service: very good but - forgot repeated requests for a straw for water. Brought rosemary potatoes instead of specifically requested baked potato. Summary: been there several times. Spent a lot of money. Tipped 20+ %. Disappointed, we will not go back.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great food and service for Valentine’s Day weekend!
Excellent! Our waiter was knowledgeable of the menu, gave us great suggestions and was so kind! The food was the best we've ever had! The atmosphere was wonderful and the view was definitely the best in Ocean City Maryland!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sunset is beautiful
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We went there on a busy night, but they were able to seat us at a high top by the bar quickly. Our server was friendly and although she was very busy, she took good care of us. The Chilean sea bass in plum sauce was excellent and the lemon lush dessert is so good it would be worth going there just to eat that. I have been there before and I recommend sticking to the seafood rather than the steak, which was just average and was kind of tough. I hate to say anything negative about the place because the seafood I've had there has always been top notch, so definitely don't skip this place if you're looking for upscale dining, but I wanted to leave an honest review. Thank you Fager's Island for a really enjoyable dinner.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lemon Lust, Fish, Seafood
We've only been for Shell Shocked. It's definitely oversold; it's packed. Good luck finding a place to sit. Otherwise the food is great. Plenty of oysters and great beer. Parking is no problem. Great staff. Good bands.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...