Not only is this cake beautiful AND delicious, the Cake Faerie was so easy and kind to work with and didn’t charge crazy prices for add ons. We chatted on the phone about what I was thinking and she put my few random visions for a simple cake for a small retirement party into this beautiful creation. Definitely the best cake maker around, and she helped us get our dream delicious cake at a price we could actually fit in our budget. Just overall great experience
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Birthday Cake
Sarah Lilly
Absolutely phenomenal. I am blown away at how friendly, creative, and talented Michelle is!! My best friend turned 29 and I wanted a fun cake with a character from our favorite show on it. Michelle did not bat an eye and was immediately down to help me make this cake come true! She was so communicative with everything I wanted and it turned out so great. The cake was freaking delicious!!!!!!!!We got a 6 inch round cake, and it fed 10 people with a few slices left over.I will absolutely be coming back for any cake needs! So so so great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Cupcake
Sarah L.
Absolutely phenomenal. I am blown away at how friendly, creative, and talented Michelle is!! My best friend turned 29 and I wanted a fun cake with a character from our favorite show on it. Michelle did not bat an eye and was immediately down to help me make this cake come true! She was so communicative with everything I wanted and it turned out so great. The cake was freaking delicious!!!!!!!! We got a 6 inch round cake, and it fed 10 people with a few slices left over. I will absolutely be coming back for any cake needs! So so so great
Michelle Stickler
We are so happy we chose The Cake Faerie for our wedding cake. Many of our guests commented on how good the cake was, which is not often heard at weddings. The cake truly was delicious and beautiful, for a much better price than nearby fancy bakeries. Michelle was very nice and easy to work with, and was accommodating to a last minute change in our order. Would highly recommend her for your wedding cake!
Ahmad S.
Great design. Quality cake. Excellent service. Reasonable price. Best in the area for sure
Francis Stout
The cupcakes were delicious! They perfectly executed and it turned out to be very elegant. And the cupcake was so flavorful — like we knew it would be! We received compliments all night from our guests about how much they enjoyed them!
Jacob Layer
Wow! Knocked it out of the park!My wife is a cake connoisseur and she loved it. We got a chocolate cake with peanut butter buttercream for her birthday.Customer Service: Michelle was wonderful and worked with me to design a cake that would be something fun and special. She was fast with email communication and answered all of my questions.Decoration: beautiful, neat as a pin, and creative! The added Reese's Cups pulled the whole thing together and made the cake a treat to look at.Cake: moist, tender, and flavorful. The crumb held together and cut cleanly. Most of all, it is absolutely delicious!Buttercream: the buttercream frosting was well-flavored, rich, but light. Pretty sure it was my wife's favorite part.Packaging: securely placed in a box with cellophane keeping the air off it. Her instructions for transportation and handling were clear and helpful. The box itself was plain white.Price: a bit more than your grocery store, but infinitely better. The buttercream alone justifies the special trip, but the custom nature of the cake makes for very very competitive pricing.If you have a special occasion that requires a cake, I would highly recommend Michelle.
Matt F.
Just a heads up, the cake fairy is real and if you don't believe in her, you're not real. She did an amazing job and with our baby shower cake and I would recommend her to anyone.
Chris Smith
Second time ordering a cake. Delicious is an understatement. The cakes are perfected. You can't go wrong ordering here. Amazing service and satisfaction guaranteed.
Carina Cox
Michelle designed a beautiful Frozen-themed unicorn cake for my daughter's birthday! From initial inquiry to pickup, Michelle was responsive and enjoyable to work with as we came up with ideas for the final design. Most importantly, the cake is delicious - perfectly moist and not overly sweet with the buttercream icing. We chose a chocolate cake with cream cheese filling though Michelle can share all the different flavor combinations. We highly recommend the Cake Faerie!
I found Michelle’s business when seeking out a dairy free cake for my daughters wedding. She was so easy to deal with, open to any request, and full of ideas and suggestions. The wedding cake was beautiful and so delicious! Everyone loved it and I was so happy, I have asked her to make my sons grooms cake next.
Carina
Michelle designed a beautiful Frozen-themed unicorn cake for my daughter's birthday! From initial inquiry to pickup, Michelle was responsive and enjoyable to work with as we came up with ideas for the final design. Most importantly, the cake is delicious - perfectly moist and not overly sweet with the buttercream icing. We chose a chocolate cake with cream cheese filling though Michelle can share all the different flavor combinations. We highly recommend the Cake Faerie!
Alicia H.
She was a pleasure to work with, reasonably priced, and answered every question I had. The cake was delicious and not dry at all! I will be using her again!
Brandy Hood
Ordered a birthday cake, 12 cupcakes and macaroons. Everything turned out beautifully and tasted very delicious. My daughter loved it and so did everyone else at the party, wanting to try all the different flavors of macaroons because they were so yummy. I would definitely purchase again, Everything went nice and smooth was ready on time and was reasonably priced. Definitely worth every penny.
Sarah Obrien
I used the Cake Faerie for my wedding cake this past weekend so I just wanted to share how great her work is. The cake was absolutely beautiful and perfectly executed the look her and I had discussed with gorgeous multicolored fondant fall leaves. It was also so delicious including the fondant leaves (I’ve never been a fondant fan so this was a big surprise) and of course her luscious buttercream! We had a red velvet layer and an almond amoretto layer, both were hugely popular with our guests. We got so many compliments! I highly recommend using The Cake Faerie and plan to get my special occasion cakes from her from now on :)
Not only is this cake beautiful AND delicious, the Cake Faerie was so easy and kind to work with and didn’t charge crazy prices for add ons. We chatted on the phone about what I was thinking and she put my few random visions for a simple cake for a small retirement party into this beautiful creation. Definitely the best cake maker around, and she helped us get our dream delicious cake at a price we could actually fit in our budget. Just overall great experience
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Birthday Cake
Absolutely phenomenal. I am blown away at how friendly, creative, and talented Michelle is!! My best friend turned 29 and I wanted a fun cake with a character from our favorite show on it. Michelle did not bat an eye and was immediately down to help me make this cake come true! She was so communicative with everything I wanted and it turned out so great. The cake was freaking delicious!!!!!!!!We got a 6 inch round cake, and it fed 10 people with a few slices left over.I will absolutely be coming back for any cake needs! So so so great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Cupcake
Absolutely phenomenal. I am blown away at how friendly, creative, and talented Michelle is!! My best friend turned 29 and I wanted a fun cake with a character from our favorite show on it. Michelle did not bat an eye and was immediately down to help me make this cake come true! She was so communicative with everything I wanted and it turned out so great. The cake was freaking delicious!!!!!!!! We got a 6 inch round cake, and it fed 10 people with a few slices left over. I will absolutely be coming back for any cake needs! So so so great
We are so happy we chose The Cake Faerie for our wedding cake. Many of our guests commented on how good the cake was, which is not often heard at weddings. The cake truly was delicious and beautiful, for a much better price than nearby fancy bakeries. Michelle was very nice and easy to work with, and was accommodating to a last minute change in our order. Would highly recommend her for your wedding cake!
Great design. Quality cake. Excellent service. Reasonable price. Best in the area for sure
The cupcakes were delicious! They perfectly executed and it turned out to be very elegant. And the cupcake was so flavorful — like we knew it would be! We received compliments all night from our guests about how much they enjoyed them!
Wow! Knocked it out of the park!My wife is a cake connoisseur and she loved it. We got a chocolate cake with peanut butter buttercream for her birthday.Customer Service: Michelle was wonderful and worked with me to design a cake that would be something fun and special. She was fast with email communication and answered all of my questions.Decoration: beautiful, neat as a pin, and creative! The added Reese's Cups pulled the whole thing together and made the cake a treat to look at.Cake: moist, tender, and flavorful. The crumb held together and cut cleanly. Most of all, it is absolutely delicious!Buttercream: the buttercream frosting was well-flavored, rich, but light. Pretty sure it was my wife's favorite part.Packaging: securely placed in a box with cellophane keeping the air off it. Her instructions for transportation and handling were clear and helpful. The box itself was plain white.Price: a bit more than your grocery store, but infinitely better. The buttercream alone justifies the special trip, but the custom nature of the cake makes for very very competitive pricing.If you have a special occasion that requires a cake, I would highly recommend Michelle.
Just a heads up, the cake fairy is real and if you don't believe in her, you're not real. She did an amazing job and with our baby shower cake and I would recommend her to anyone.
Second time ordering a cake. Delicious is an understatement. The cakes are perfected. You can't go wrong ordering here. Amazing service and satisfaction guaranteed.
Michelle designed a beautiful Frozen-themed unicorn cake for my daughter's birthday! From initial inquiry to pickup, Michelle was responsive and enjoyable to work with as we came up with ideas for the final design. Most importantly, the cake is delicious - perfectly moist and not overly sweet with the buttercream icing. We chose a chocolate cake with cream cheese filling though Michelle can share all the different flavor combinations. We highly recommend the Cake Faerie!
Restaurantji Recommends
I found Michelle’s business when seeking out a dairy free cake for my daughters wedding. She was so easy to deal with, open to any request, and full of ideas and suggestions. The wedding cake was beautiful and so delicious! Everyone loved it and I was so happy, I have asked her to make my sons grooms cake next.
Michelle designed a beautiful Frozen-themed unicorn cake for my daughter's birthday! From initial inquiry to pickup, Michelle was responsive and enjoyable to work with as we came up with ideas for the final design. Most importantly, the cake is delicious - perfectly moist and not overly sweet with the buttercream icing. We chose a chocolate cake with cream cheese filling though Michelle can share all the different flavor combinations. We highly recommend the Cake Faerie!
She was a pleasure to work with, reasonably priced, and answered every question I had. The cake was delicious and not dry at all! I will be using her again!
Ordered a birthday cake, 12 cupcakes and macaroons. Everything turned out beautifully and tasted very delicious. My daughter loved it and so did everyone else at the party, wanting to try all the different flavors of macaroons because they were so yummy. I would definitely purchase again, Everything went nice and smooth was ready on time and was reasonably priced. Definitely worth every penny.
I used the Cake Faerie for my wedding cake this past weekend so I just wanted to share how great her work is. The cake was absolutely beautiful and perfectly executed the look her and I had discussed with gorgeous multicolored fondant fall leaves. It was also so delicious including the fondant leaves (I’ve never been a fondant fan so this was a big surprise) and of course her luscious buttercream! We had a red velvet layer and an almond amoretto layer, both were hugely popular with our guests. We got so many compliments! I highly recommend using The Cake Faerie and plan to get my special occasion cakes from her from now on :)