Hand-tossed, homemade, pizza made from scratch. This local hometown pizzeria has it all going on.From a young man taking the big step to run and operate a business, working 7 days a week just to make sure he's a successful businessman shows how much of his heart and time is devoted to making sure everyone has that "Wow, what a difference?" experience when they take their 1st bite. I'm very proud of you buddy. I know Thurmont, MD is lucky to have that delicious pizza so close to home. I wish you all the best with years of success.Your hard work does not go unnoticed.~Shaun
Walter Seiberling
We go here to pick up pizza for dinner after a long day at Liberty ski mountain. One of the best pizzas!Food: 5/5
Scott Cannon
This review is a little long, but I want to share my experience. On Sunday 1/15/23 we took my daughters soccer team to Liberty Winter resort to go Tubing. After it was done everyone was hungry. We chose Fratelli's because it was on the way home and the reviews. No question we made the right choice. We came at the start of lunch time and informed the staff that we had 24 people all together. They welcomed us in. We had 8 pizzas and 4 large orders of fries. Everything came out perfect. True New York style pizza along with perfectly cooked fries. I never got the name of our server but she was on top of everything. We all really enjoyed lunch. Our girls were treated like gold. Thank you Fratteli's.
Lisa M.
Fratelli's is such a great place to go for a meal. We drove about 30 minutes out of the way just to get a salad and a cheeseburger sub. Om nom. I love the dessert selection too. Everything we've had has been wonderful. I also really like their house salad dressing - wish I could get the recipe!!!! Hint, hint. ?Food: 5/5
Felix Whitfield
Ordered a cheese steak with extra onions, green peppers and mushrooms. The cheese steaks are still awesome. I returned the next day to order two more. The staff was very friendly and compensating. I will definitely stop here again.....I just hope it's not too long.Food: 5/5
Shannon Bilger
Very good pizza. A nice chew to the crust and authentic New York style sauce. All that at a reasonable priceFood: 5/5
Eric Garcia
Great meat lovers pizza….truck parking in back free for overnight
DJ/Don Heinz
Attentive staff. HUGE menu for a pizza joint!!We had Chicken Parmigiano and Eggplant Parmigiano. Serving size was HUMONGOUS! 2 meals per plate!Extremely reasonable prices.Food: 5/5
Terry K.
The service was below par. The food took too long and wasn't what we ordered. The pizza was too greasy and missing toppings. The steak and cheese had no cheese and the mozzarella sticks were cold.
Jay C.
Was in the area and needed to feed the family. This place definitely delivered on filling our bellies. The pizza was great but they also had fried pickles and delicious burgers. My son and wife wanted their 8 inch pizzas but from the photo you can tell they were much bigger. The staff was friendly and this was absolutely a local favorite for carry out orders. You won't go wrong ordering or eating in here. I'll be sure to stop there again the next time I'm in the area.
Great food, wish we lived closer! Worth the trip! I got a pizza steak sub.
Virtual Hiker
Don’t let the exterior fool ya. Pepperoni pizza was good, and the white pizza was okay. The staff is great, polite, quick, and friendly.. I’d eat here again.
Patricia Winters
2 stars for the pizza and good soda. The worst place to dine in. We ate half of a slice and left instead. The cook was so obnoxious, talking so loudly about drinking and how the lady only got a 5$ tip from another customer. Place is very unprofessional. The waitress didn’t bother listening to to our order from our drinks to the food. Messed it up and we still had to pay. We didn’t complain just left. Good pizza an soda is all
Melissa Henry
We are currently staying in the Catoctin Mountain and didn't want to cook our last night here. Service was fast and workers are very friendly. We ordered the Fratelli's pizza special it was so good.
David Luja-King
Fratelli's NY Pizza is great. We didn't get pizza because we are watching our weight, but what we got was outstanding.The mozzarella caprese was huge! A 12" takeout tray full. Five times what you get at most places. The french bread that with it would have been better with garlic butter, but still was delicious bread.The soups were savory and the salads were loaded. My steak salad was completely covered, must have been a pound or more of juicy and flavorful meat.10 of 10 would recommend this as a must stop destination.
Hand-tossed, homemade, pizza made from scratch. This local hometown pizzeria has it all going on.From a young man taking the big step to run and operate a business, working 7 days a week just to make sure he's a successful businessman shows how much of his heart and time is devoted to making sure everyone has that "Wow, what a difference?" experience when they take their 1st bite. I'm very proud of you buddy. I know Thurmont, MD is lucky to have that delicious pizza so close to home. I wish you all the best with years of success.Your hard work does not go unnoticed.~Shaun
We go here to pick up pizza for dinner after a long day at Liberty ski mountain. One of the best pizzas!Food: 5/5
This review is a little long, but I want to share my experience. On Sunday 1/15/23 we took my daughters soccer team to Liberty Winter resort to go Tubing. After it was done everyone was hungry. We chose Fratelli's because it was on the way home and the reviews. No question we made the right choice. We came at the start of lunch time and informed the staff that we had 24 people all together. They welcomed us in. We had 8 pizzas and 4 large orders of fries. Everything came out perfect. True New York style pizza along with perfectly cooked fries. I never got the name of our server but she was on top of everything. We all really enjoyed lunch. Our girls were treated like gold. Thank you Fratteli's.
Fratelli's is such a great place to go for a meal. We drove about 30 minutes out of the way just to get a salad and a cheeseburger sub. Om nom. I love the dessert selection too. Everything we've had has been wonderful. I also really like their house salad dressing - wish I could get the recipe!!!! Hint, hint. ?Food: 5/5
Ordered a cheese steak with extra onions, green peppers and mushrooms. The cheese steaks are still awesome. I returned the next day to order two more. The staff was very friendly and compensating. I will definitely stop here again.....I just hope it's not too long.Food: 5/5
Very good pizza. A nice chew to the crust and authentic New York style sauce. All that at a reasonable priceFood: 5/5
Great meat lovers pizza….truck parking in back free for overnight
Attentive staff. HUGE menu for a pizza joint!!We had Chicken Parmigiano and Eggplant Parmigiano. Serving size was HUMONGOUS! 2 meals per plate!Extremely reasonable prices.Food: 5/5
The service was below par. The food took too long and wasn't what we ordered. The pizza was too greasy and missing toppings. The steak and cheese had no cheese and the mozzarella sticks were cold.
Was in the area and needed to feed the family. This place definitely delivered on filling our bellies. The pizza was great but they also had fried pickles and delicious burgers. My son and wife wanted their 8 inch pizzas but from the photo you can tell they were much bigger. The staff was friendly and this was absolutely a local favorite for carry out orders. You won't go wrong ordering or eating in here. I'll be sure to stop there again the next time I'm in the area.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great food, wish we lived closer! Worth the trip! I got a pizza steak sub.
Don’t let the exterior fool ya. Pepperoni pizza was good, and the white pizza was okay. The staff is great, polite, quick, and friendly.. I’d eat here again.
2 stars for the pizza and good soda. The worst place to dine in. We ate half of a slice and left instead. The cook was so obnoxious, talking so loudly about drinking and how the lady only got a 5$ tip from another customer. Place is very unprofessional. The waitress didn’t bother listening to to our order from our drinks to the food. Messed it up and we still had to pay. We didn’t complain just left. Good pizza an soda is all
We are currently staying in the Catoctin Mountain and didn't want to cook our last night here. Service was fast and workers are very friendly. We ordered the Fratelli's pizza special it was so good.
Fratelli's NY Pizza is great. We didn't get pizza because we are watching our weight, but what we got was outstanding.The mozzarella caprese was huge! A 12" takeout tray full. Five times what you get at most places. The french bread that with it would have been better with garlic butter, but still was delicious bread.The soups were savory and the salads were loaded. My steak salad was completely covered, must have been a pound or more of juicy and flavorful meat.10 of 10 would recommend this as a must stop destination.