My wife and I did a weekend here and it was absolutely perfect. One of the top 3 meals I've ever had in my life. The cottages were cozy and comfortable and staff everywhere were great. Hope to come again.
Jeffery Longaker
Aragosta at Goose Cove is tremendous. Vacationed there for 3 days. The setting, views, food, and service are exemplary.
John Broughton
Arrived for a Sunday Ala carte dinner on the deck 20 minutes early and got our name on the list. Initial seating was a tad chaotic, but your patience will be rewarded with an excellent meal. Was surprisingly one of the cheaper meals we had In Maine as well, very happy we decided to try to get a table.
Felix O'Brien
Aragosta’s location on Deer Isle is world-class, and the food was better than expected — thoughtful and ambitious, if a little inconsistent across courses. The sommelier and junior staff brought real energy and warmth to the evening, which we appreciated. Our main server, however, felt a little joyless and jaded — perhaps understandable at the end of a long summer and with us being a slightly late and lively table — but it did take the shine off what should have been a special occasion, especially given the price point. Still, I’d return for the setting and food, and hope for a more engaging service next time.
ella johanson
One of a kind location, a tasting menu extremely reflective of what Maine has to offer, as a local, you couldn’t ask for a better dining experience. Devin has a tested an oasis for treasuring coastal Maine cuisine and device to match. Cannot wait to come back!
Henry Bodkin
Review of the Sunday night dining experience: the view and atmosphere was 10/10, gorgeous and lovely vibes. The service was mediocre: we waited an hour and 40 minutes after the host told us an hour (and we arrived within 5 minutes of opening). He was seating people who had come in after us and finally seated us after my wife spoke up. The food was a B.
Island Girl
Just. INCREDIBLE!!
Kelly Greenlee
We went there on Sunday for the no reservations on the deck , it was absolutely awesome. The wait was a 1.5 hours but they had oysters and a bar on the beach ! And even made a fire as the sun dropped. The older man that was the host was so very kind and did a great job. The staff and the food was well worth the wait! This is a must go !!! ❤️
Michael Reilly
While we did not stay at Aragosta, we had a meal there that was one of the best - if not the best - meal I have ever had. I've eaten at a lot of very nice restaurants around the world, including numerous Michelin 3-star restaurants. The experience at Aragosta was better, and not as expensive as many high-end restaurants. We sat in one of the greenhouses and it was such an amazing experience. It helped that it was a beautiful summer evening and felt there was no better way to take in the beauty of coastal Maine. The food was delectable... each and every course was so thoughtfully and creativity prepared, with focus on local and seasonal flavors. Our servers were amazing... knowledgeable and friendly. We were there for 3 hours... and I usually can't tolerate a meal that goes on for more than 2 hrs. But time zipped by and the cadence of all the courses was perfect... not too hasty, but no long pauses either. The other thing we really appreciated is that we did not drink any alcohol for personal reasons. This can sometimes be received by restaurants with a snooty response, but the staff at Aragosta made us feel welcome nonetheless. Everyone in our party of 7 agreed with that the experience was amazing. My wife and I can't wait to go back again... and stay in one of the cabins!
Tyler
After several years of attempting to reserve a table, I finally managed it for an anniversary dinner.
The summer tasting menu was diverse and totally unique In presentation and flavor. All dishes were expertly prepared with ingredients as locally sourced as one could imagine, from the bay and coastal forests just beyond, to the gardens hardly paces from the establishment.
Staff and service was also exceptional (Thanks Riley et al.)
All in all it was an expensive, but utterly worthwhile experience I would recommend to anyone seeking a remarkable culinary adventure off the beaten path. .. One I feel truly captures and accentuates the otherwise quiet and underappreciated delights of Maine.
Many thanks to all the staff and Chef Finigan for a wonderful evening!
Great experience start to finish! Couldn’t ask for a more beautiful setting!
R.R. Workman
An experience my wife and I will never forget. Great meal in an even more perfect location. The staff were great and it was a chill atmosphere. Will return in the future, shoutout Chef Devin and her team
Stacey Furtado
It could not have been a better dining experience. Chloe recommended amazing wine, Riley was a phenomenal server, and the whole staff was welcoming, accommodating, and eager to show us everything their kitchen and bar had to offer. We absolutely cannot wait to come back with friends.
We had our six month old with us and while we had to take shifts stepping out to give her time to be the baby she is, the team made her feel welcome, joked around with us, and helped time our courses so we could enjoy our meal. We are so grateful and the night truly felt special.
Michael Burk
This is hands down one of the most magical places we've stayed AND ate at. Everything was perfect without it feeling unapproachable.
Brittany Carragher
My husband and I chose to elope at Aragosta after falling in love with it during a deep-dive Instagram search. We knew it was something special but, our expectations were exceeded!
From our very first conversation, Heather, Aragosta’s incredible events manager, made us feel seen, heard, and completely taken care of. Her warmth, attention to detail, and genuine love for what she does made the entire planning process joyful and stress-free. I loved working with her so much that I actually miss her now!
The venue itself is truly one-of-a-kind. Nestled in a beautiful setting with cozy cabins on site, it allowed our guests to relax and fully enjoy the weekend without having to drive. The atmosphere felt intimate, natural, and effortlessly beautiful.
The food was unreal. The guests and I felt spoiled all weekend! Our menu was tailored around what was in season and built around what my husband and I love. Every dish felt intentional and delicious, like a love letter through food.
What really set Aragosta apart, though, was the people. The owner was welcoming and kind, the entire staff was delightful, and the bar team? They did the worm on the dance floor. It doesn’t get better than that!
Our wedding wasn’t cookie cutter, it was so unique! It even rained and we embraced it, and it became part of the magic. If you’re dreaming of a venue that’s beautiful, personal, and full of heart, Aragosta is it! Highly recommend! We can't wait to come back next year to celebrate our one year of marriage!
My wife and I did a weekend here and it was absolutely perfect. One of the top 3 meals I've ever had in my life. The cottages were cozy and comfortable and staff everywhere were great. Hope to come again.
Aragosta at Goose Cove is tremendous. Vacationed there for 3 days. The setting, views, food, and service are exemplary.
Arrived for a Sunday Ala carte dinner on the deck 20 minutes early and got our name on the list. Initial seating was a tad chaotic, but your patience will be rewarded with an excellent meal. Was surprisingly one of the cheaper meals we had In Maine as well, very happy we decided to try to get a table.
Aragosta’s location on Deer Isle is world-class, and the food was better than expected — thoughtful and ambitious, if a little inconsistent across courses. The sommelier and junior staff brought real energy and warmth to the evening, which we appreciated. Our main server, however, felt a little joyless and jaded — perhaps understandable at the end of a long summer and with us being a slightly late and lively table — but it did take the shine off what should have been a special occasion, especially given the price point. Still, I’d return for the setting and food, and hope for a more engaging service next time.
One of a kind location, a tasting menu extremely reflective of what Maine has to offer, as a local, you couldn’t ask for a better dining experience. Devin has a tested an oasis for treasuring coastal Maine cuisine and device to match. Cannot wait to come back!
Review of the Sunday night dining experience: the view and atmosphere was 10/10, gorgeous and lovely vibes. The service was mediocre: we waited an hour and 40 minutes after the host told us an hour (and we arrived within 5 minutes of opening). He was seating people who had come in after us and finally seated us after my wife spoke up. The food was a B.
Just. INCREDIBLE!!
We went there on Sunday for the no reservations on the deck , it was absolutely awesome. The wait was a 1.5 hours but they had oysters and a bar on the beach ! And even made a fire as the sun dropped. The older man that was the host was so very kind and did a great job. The staff and the food was well worth the wait! This is a must go !!! ❤️
While we did not stay at Aragosta, we had a meal there that was one of the best - if not the best - meal I have ever had. I've eaten at a lot of very nice restaurants around the world, including numerous Michelin 3-star restaurants. The experience at Aragosta was better, and not as expensive as many high-end restaurants. We sat in one of the greenhouses and it was such an amazing experience. It helped that it was a beautiful summer evening and felt there was no better way to take in the beauty of coastal Maine. The food was delectable... each and every course was so thoughtfully and creativity prepared, with focus on local and seasonal flavors. Our servers were amazing... knowledgeable and friendly. We were there for 3 hours... and I usually can't tolerate a meal that goes on for more than 2 hrs. But time zipped by and the cadence of all the courses was perfect... not too hasty, but no long pauses either. The other thing we really appreciated is that we did not drink any alcohol for personal reasons. This can sometimes be received by restaurants with a snooty response, but the staff at Aragosta made us feel welcome nonetheless. Everyone in our party of 7 agreed with that the experience was amazing. My wife and I can't wait to go back again... and stay in one of the cabins!
After several years of attempting to reserve a table, I finally managed it for an anniversary dinner.
The summer tasting menu was diverse and totally unique In presentation and flavor. All dishes were expertly prepared with ingredients as locally sourced as one could imagine, from the bay and coastal forests just beyond, to the gardens hardly paces from the establishment.
Staff and service was also exceptional (Thanks Riley et al.)
All in all it was an expensive, but utterly worthwhile experience I would recommend to anyone seeking a remarkable culinary adventure off the beaten path.
.. One I feel truly captures and accentuates the otherwise quiet and underappreciated delights of Maine.
Many thanks to all the staff and Chef Finigan for a wonderful evening!
Restaurantji Recommends
Great experience start to finish! Couldn’t ask for a more beautiful setting!
An experience my wife and I will never forget. Great meal in an even more perfect location. The staff were great and it was a chill atmosphere. Will return in the future, shoutout Chef Devin and her team
It could not have been a better dining experience. Chloe recommended amazing wine, Riley was a phenomenal server, and the whole staff was welcoming, accommodating, and eager to show us everything their kitchen and bar had to offer. We absolutely cannot wait to come back with friends.
We had our six month old with us and while we had to take shifts stepping out to give her time to be the baby she is, the team made her feel welcome, joked around with us, and helped time our courses so we could enjoy our meal. We are so grateful and the night truly felt special.
This is hands down one of the most magical places we've stayed AND ate at. Everything was perfect without it feeling unapproachable.
My husband and I chose to elope at Aragosta after falling in love with it during a deep-dive Instagram search. We knew it was something special but, our expectations were exceeded!
From our very first conversation, Heather, Aragosta’s incredible events manager, made us feel seen, heard, and completely taken care of. Her warmth, attention to detail, and genuine love for what she does made the entire planning process joyful and stress-free. I loved working with her so much that I actually miss her now!
The venue itself is truly one-of-a-kind. Nestled in a beautiful setting with cozy cabins on site, it allowed our guests to relax and fully enjoy the weekend without having to drive. The atmosphere felt intimate, natural, and effortlessly beautiful.
The food was unreal. The guests and I felt spoiled all weekend! Our menu was tailored around what was in season and built around what my husband and I love. Every dish felt intentional and delicious, like a love letter through food.
What really set Aragosta apart, though, was the people. The owner was welcoming and kind, the entire staff was delightful, and the bar team? They did the worm on the dance floor. It doesn’t get better than that!
Our wedding wasn’t cookie cutter, it was so unique! It even rained and we embraced it, and it became part of the magic. If you’re dreaming of a venue that’s beautiful, personal, and full of heart, Aragosta is it! Highly recommend! We can't wait to come back next year to celebrate our one year of marriage!
Loading...