Your draught beer lines need to be cleaned and are not safe for public consumption. Multiple occasions this winter (2023-24) I have ordered a domestic light beer off the tap and the taste is decidedly sour and the beer is cloudy. Your bartenders are very attentive and friendly but they should know better than to be serving this beer. In fact Marilyn confessed when I sent the beer back that she has had multiple complaints about it. Please, I like going there - have a pro change out the lines.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
John Foley
Their Google listing says they do delivery, but they don't, they contract out to third party services.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 1
Magnus Dunning
FANTASTIC PIZZA EVERY
Food: 5
Finnegan “Finn” Tempestus
Portland Pie killing it with the pizza per usual and they don't skimp on the cheese; look at these breadsticks hold my fries this was good. The Nor' Easter is must try for anyone who likes the combination of blue cheese and Buffalo wings....like, you have to.Vegetarian options: Vegetarian pies are greatParking: Big parking lotKid-friendliness: Kid options, great big restaurant with friendly atmosphere.Wheelchair accessibility: Yes, careful during the winter hours I saw ice on the sidewalk to the restaurant.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken, Buffalo
Mitch Kennedy
First time there since it was still Ricetta. I've had their pizza before, and loved it, but never "eat-in"... my wife and I were astounded!! I've been in Maine for over 35 years, but grew up in the South Jersey/Philly area, and cheesesteaks are sacred down there, and I had to try there steak/queso sandwich... first of all, they get bonus points for not trying to call it a Philly cheesesteak...bogus at first sight! This came out the gate with the soft yeasty bread and slightly tough crust, tender steak, and the queso was a lot like what the real Italian folks used as a combination of their own mozzarella and provolone... plus those little red peppers with a little bite to them are amazing. My wife's pizza was superb, as was the mushroom stuffed with spinach and blue cheese! The tab was more than reasonable, and Marilyn, our waitress was strictly top-notch!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John
Got patato/bacon pie with beer dough, and caesar's salade. Pleasantly surprised, very fresh and tasty, overall excellent food! Thank you
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
BEN
You would have a hard time to have a "bad" meal here. Great food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Alex Morse
Good pizza. Great family spot.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Olivia Kupper
Very delicious but very overpriced. Two medium pizzas (I’m talking Dominos sized mediums) were $50…. But very delicious. Definitely a special treat!
Rachael Coleman
We had a family party for eight. We had a space that felt intimate. The starters were appealing to the children as well as adults. We chose two large designer pizzas, and the children created their own large pizza. We highly recommend. Great waitress!
Our waitress Hailey was beyond adorable and sooo nice! Thank you ?
David Maguire
Salad and pizza were both very good. The service wast fast and friendly. The beer was cold. Can't ask for more than that!!We came back in a few nights later for the ice cream cookie pie and kids' chicken fingers. I personally would skip them both. The chicken fingers looked like they were microwaved baked, and the cookie pie is half baked and heated to serve. 20 mins later, the ice cream is still not melted on it. So,.. not hot. Stick to the pizza here, which I am still talking about.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Eden Lima
ordered from this place when I was passing through maine. the food took forever to get here and when it arrived it was cold. i found what appeared to be some type of fur or short hair in my food and was sick for the next two days after eating here. i tried getting a refund but was put on hold for almost a half an hour so i gave up. wouldn’t recommend this place to anyone
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jamie Morton (Jaylyn)
The food was delicious! ? Their Buffalo pizza is so good! It was a little expensive, but it was so good! I do recommend this place if you want good pizza or good food! Everyone was super polite & friendly. Thanks, Portland Pie!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken
Gracie Alexander
They did not give me what I ordered- a regular pepperoni pizza with ricotta added. And they put it on the thin crust pizza which I did not ask for, so it’s cardboard with some sauce and cheese and pepperoni. Not the portland pie that I expected like every other location. One pizza and an overpriced app (caprese sliders- not worth it) and my order was $40. Almost $30 for the wrong thing and they won’t answer the phone now. Never order the caprese sliders either. One didn’t even have mozzarella on it. I know the Falmouth spot is new(ish) but I’m very disappointed with this location considering how much I normally love Portland Pie and have never had issues with any other of their restaurants. This review is specific to the Falmouth restaurant.
Your draught beer lines need to be cleaned and are not safe for public consumption. Multiple occasions this winter (2023-24) I have ordered a domestic light beer off the tap and the taste is decidedly sour and the beer is cloudy. Your bartenders are very attentive and friendly but they should know better than to be serving this beer. In fact Marilyn confessed when I sent the beer back that she has had multiple complaints about it. Please, I like going there - have a pro change out the lines.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Their Google listing says they do delivery, but they don't, they contract out to third party services.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 1
FANTASTIC PIZZA EVERY
Food: 5
Portland Pie killing it with the pizza per usual and they don't skimp on the cheese; look at these breadsticks hold my fries this was good. The Nor' Easter is must try for anyone who likes the combination of blue cheese and Buffalo wings....like, you have to.Vegetarian options: Vegetarian pies are greatParking: Big parking lotKid-friendliness: Kid options, great big restaurant with friendly atmosphere.Wheelchair accessibility: Yes, careful during the winter hours I saw ice on the sidewalk to the restaurant.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken, Buffalo
First time there since it was still Ricetta. I've had their pizza before, and loved it, but never "eat-in"... my wife and I were astounded!! I've been in Maine for over 35 years, but grew up in the South Jersey/Philly area, and cheesesteaks are sacred down there, and I had to try there steak/queso sandwich... first of all, they get bonus points for not trying to call it a Philly cheesesteak...bogus at first sight! This came out the gate with the soft yeasty bread and slightly tough crust, tender steak, and the queso was a lot like what the real Italian folks used as a combination of their own mozzarella and provolone... plus those little red peppers with a little bite to them are amazing. My wife's pizza was superb, as was the mushroom stuffed with spinach and blue cheese! The tab was more than reasonable, and Marilyn, our waitress was strictly top-notch!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Got patato/bacon pie with beer dough, and caesar's salade. Pleasantly surprised, very fresh and tasty, overall excellent food! Thank you
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
You would have a hard time to have a "bad" meal here. Great food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Good pizza. Great family spot.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Very delicious but very overpriced. Two medium pizzas (I’m talking Dominos sized mediums) were $50…. But very delicious. Definitely a special treat!
We had a family party for eight. We had a space that felt intimate. The starters were appealing to the children as well as adults. We chose two large designer pizzas, and the children created their own large pizza. We highly recommend. Great waitress!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Our waitress Hailey was beyond adorable and sooo nice! Thank you ?
Salad and pizza were both very good. The service wast fast and friendly. The beer was cold. Can't ask for more than that!!We came back in a few nights later for the ice cream cookie pie and kids' chicken fingers. I personally would skip them both. The chicken fingers looked like they were microwaved baked, and the cookie pie is half baked and heated to serve. 20 mins later, the ice cream is still not melted on it. So,.. not hot. Stick to the pizza here, which I am still talking about.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
ordered from this place when I was passing through maine. the food took forever to get here and when it arrived it was cold. i found what appeared to be some type of fur or short hair in my food and was sick for the next two days after eating here. i tried getting a refund but was put on hold for almost a half an hour so i gave up. wouldn’t recommend this place to anyone
Food: 1
Service: 1
The food was delicious! ? Their Buffalo pizza is so good! It was a little expensive, but it was so good! I do recommend this place if you want good pizza or good food! Everyone was super polite & friendly. Thanks, Portland Pie!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken
They did not give me what I ordered- a regular pepperoni pizza with ricotta added. And they put it on the thin crust pizza which I did not ask for, so it’s cardboard with some sauce and cheese and pepperoni. Not the portland pie that I expected like every other location. One pizza and an overpriced app (caprese sliders- not worth it) and my order was $40. Almost $30 for the wrong thing and they won’t answer the phone now. Never order the caprese sliders either. One didn’t even have mozzarella on it. I know the Falmouth spot is new(ish) but I’m very disappointed with this location considering how much I normally love Portland Pie and have never had issues with any other of their restaurants. This review is specific to the Falmouth restaurant.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3