Rodney’s at 436 Main

436 Main St, Presque Isle
(207) 550-2700

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jonathan Curtis

Was there last night for dinner service and food top notch . Ribeye was cooked to perfection. Great job to everyone working last night .

Kaitlyn Sennott

Nicole was an amazing waitor! So happy to have good food. Nice fireplace.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

jeffrey deforest

One glaring problem is Collin the floor manager’s bad attitude.He was drinking at the bar with customers still in the restaurant .He is quick to anger just because customers change there mind or don’t like something. This restaurant will never go anywhere with Collin on the floor .His the customer is not first attitude is what comes thru. Live across the street were we have a small business and a loft and have not been eager to go there do to what we heard overall.Two employees live in our building ,there great people .Put them in charge or Wes who was great the first time we went in .Food was ok .We have heard mixed reviews from people in town about Rodney’s and the management/food being rather inconsistent and just ok .Now we know why.Tighten up .This place could be a diamond with change and more pride .Start with Collin being retitled or out .He is more qualified to be a night club door man..These customers will never step foot in the place with Collin running the floor . We know lots of people being in the wholesale precious metal business for 5 plus years in.P.I .25 plus overall. Premium prices deserve premium service and premium food .We will not send any one to Rodney’s with captain Collin.Peace and God Bless hope to see a change to IGNITE Rodney’s .

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 1

JADECYN BORGES

Almost always top-notch food and service here. Love it. This is one of my go to places.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Caesar Salad

Tristan Yost

The service and food was top notch!

Danielle M

Pros:
Easy to find
Clean, spacious, and bright
You can go in in street clothes (I was worried about my appearance)
Friendly staff
Unique specials
Fun and different cocktail options
Bright space
Able to watch the world go by from the beautiful windows
Free street parking
Qualify hunks of lobster in roll

Cons:
May need to parallel park
Wish they had kept the lobster roll where it was sliders so you could try both hot and cold. I went with the hot (as my server said it was much more popular) but it tasted like nothing at all and I was disappointed

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Lobster Roll

Rich Petrelli

We decided to stop in here to try the food, it’s our first time to this area of Maine.

Parking was on the street and at 4pm Saturday, we had no problem parking at all.

We were greeted by a friendly young man at the door who led us to our table.

The waitress we had was super nice, informative and went the extra mile to answer some of our questions.

We started with the lobster bisque. The consistency and taste were perfect, the amount of lobster in the soup was great, my only issue was the size of the pieces of lobster, which were not bite sized and left me trying to cut them with my spoon.

The Caesar salad was just “ok”. It tasted like bottled dressing to me and had too much sugar in it.

For dinner we both had the Chicken Caprese. Presentation was perfect. This is the first time I have had it with a thick breadcrumb coating, almost as thick as the coating you get on Jalapeño poppers. I scraped it all off onto the plate and also noticed that the coating on the bottom of the chicken was burnt. I did not like the coating at all. The chicken was better without it.

The thin asparagus was no better. It was very stringy and almost an hour after dinner I was still picking strings of asparagus out of my teeth. They should’ve done one of two things:

1. Picked more tender pieces of thin asparagus or…

2. Choose thick asparagus and peel it, then steam it.

My wife had the Brussels sprouts and they were good.

We skipped desert.

I don’t think we will return but I would not order the chicken caprese again for sure.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Abel daCorte

So far everything we've tried has been 4⭐ or better food wise, the most elevated dining experience we've found in Aroostook county to date and we've been here like 3 years...if anyone reading this knows of another restaurant with higher quality food lemme know!!! Excuse the food photos they aren't really post worthy and from two separate meals but better than nothing

Vegetarian options: The sprout/beet salad is a great veggie option

Parking: There's 15 or so spots on either side of the street and a whole parking lot in the rear.

Wheelchair accessibility: Single level from entrance, mild ramp to host podium

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fish Tacos

Chris Nelson

Excellent food. The lobster bisque is to die for. The steak and shrimp were very good as well.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Renee Grant

Great atmosphere and decor. The food was delicious and service was great. I had the Caprese Chicken with brussel sprouts and asparagus. Loved all of it. I highly recommend Rodney’s.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Caprese Stuffed Chicken

Richard DeMerchant Jr

Talk about finding an amazing spot for dinner..... this is certainly it. A coworker and I tried this spot out and goodness was the food great. I had a delightful steak that was so tender, juicy and favor bound that it was as if I was in a dream. The waitress was absolutely amazing, very kind and willing to chat us up a bit which is something that you just don't see these days anymore.

If you're in the area, I highly recommend stopping in!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

JanC

The buffet was a nice treat for Mom and Grandma. The food selections were perfect for the ladies and for us men, too. As always, we had excellent service from your staff. The only glitch was the chicken was a trifle dry. It tasted good, though. Thank you for the tasty meal and a pleasant atmosphere.

Tim Gonda

Extremely classy atmosphere, tasty food, and drinks. Definitely a must for date night or special occasions.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fish Tacos

Shawn Gregory

A great experience - wonderful atmosphere, friendly, helpful service and delicious food and drink. The fish tacos were so good as was the Relaxer drink. If you're in the P.I. area, stop in! You won't be disappointed!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jody Johnson

Classy spot! Would be perfect for a special occasion. The food was wonderful & the service on point. I had salmon, which was perfectly prepared and my husband had a steak, which he enjoyed. We also tried poutine for an appetizer, a first for both of us and it was delicious. We love Caribou and will be back!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...