Highly recommend this place. The smoked mussels are insanely good, I couldn’t stop eating them. We also tried the fresh scallops, out of this world!!! Not only is the seafood really good, everyone is genuinely nice and kind there. Will be my first stop to get seafood when we come back to Stonington next time!
C Gove
My husband is a self employed clam harvester. He had sold his clam here off and on over the past couple of years. Earlier this December, another market was buying clams at almost double the price Coldwater was buying them for, so we sold my husband's clams at the other market. Four weeks later, after Coldwater raised their buying price, my husband went to sell a small batch of clams to them. One of the workers met my husband outside after looking in the back of our truck and told him, "You were caught selling to the truck at the bridge and she (Amelia Damon) said you are no longer allowed to sell here." We now have to sell at markets away from Deer Isle Stonington because Coldwater won't buy clams from clam harvesters that sell to higher buyers. Another clam harvester hasn't even received a check yet for clams he sold there days ago when there is suppose to be a next day check policy minus weekends.
Peter Shapiro
Great scallops and oysters
alex bishop
Best place to get fresh seafood in Stonington!
Jill Rohrbach
Always the best selection of seafood and meat!!!
Ryan Morey
Love this place
Liv Vaisberg
We got the best fish and clams ever. We put everything on the fire pit, including the clams, there are no words how good and fresh it was!
Gabriel Frank
I have mixed feelings about this place.They do heve a nice variety of fish and seafood and the staff is helpful.However, we bought mussels, half of them were dead (wouldn't close when nicking on them) another bunch wouldn't open during cooking, the rest had funny taste.Bottom line if your mussels are not good, don't sell them.
Joshua August
Everything was great and the staff was helpful and funny. Good prices and locally driven. If your in the island you got to stop in for the daily catch
John L.
One of Deer Isle's hidden gems for fresh and smoked seafoods. Lobster, clams, and mussels, ya yup everyday. Beautiful live lobster!!! The more you buy the better the price. We've been here on a Isle a couple of times and Coldwater Seafood has been a source each time. On our recent trip to the Isle we saw a young couple carrying a couple of crates and bags of lobster and other "Clam Bake" items for a large family event. This is when the volume discount was "Lurned". Sadly we were shopping for two and just couldn't girth the same volume. Despite four 1.5 pounders, clams, and some smoked haddock was just peachy for us "Come-To's."
Buy fresh picked crab and lobster here. A huge variety of fresh fish including haddock and whole live lobsters. Also a large variety of fresh frozen fish. Some great local dips and cheeses, and kefir.
Paul bock
Had a wonderful experience at the Belfast Farmer's Market today. Fantastic fish, very friendly and helpful representative.
Highly recommend this place. The smoked mussels are insanely good, I couldn’t stop eating them. We also tried the fresh scallops, out of this world!!! Not only is the seafood really good, everyone is genuinely nice and kind there. Will be my first stop to get seafood when we come back to Stonington next time!
My husband is a self employed clam harvester. He had sold his clam here off and on over the past couple of years. Earlier this December, another market was buying clams at almost double the price Coldwater was buying them for, so we sold my husband's clams at the other market. Four weeks later, after Coldwater raised their buying price, my husband went to sell a small batch of clams to them. One of the workers met my husband outside after looking in the back of our truck and told him, "You were caught selling to the truck at the bridge and she (Amelia Damon) said you are no longer allowed to sell here." We now have to sell at markets away from Deer Isle Stonington because Coldwater won't buy clams from clam harvesters that sell to higher buyers. Another clam harvester hasn't even received a check yet for clams he sold there days ago when there is suppose to be a next day check policy minus weekends.
Great scallops and oysters
Best place to get fresh seafood in Stonington!
Always the best selection of seafood and meat!!!
Love this place
We got the best fish and clams ever. We put everything on the fire pit, including the clams, there are no words how good and fresh it was!
I have mixed feelings about this place.They do heve a nice variety of fish and seafood and the staff is helpful.However, we bought mussels, half of them were dead (wouldn't close when nicking on them) another bunch wouldn't open during cooking, the rest had funny taste.Bottom line if your mussels are not good, don't sell them.
Everything was great and the staff was helpful and funny. Good prices and locally driven. If your in the island you got to stop in for the daily catch
One of Deer Isle's hidden gems for fresh and smoked seafoods. Lobster, clams, and mussels, ya yup everyday. Beautiful live lobster!!! The more you buy the better the price. We've been here on a Isle a couple of times and Coldwater Seafood has been a source each time. On our recent trip to the Isle we saw a young couple carrying a couple of crates and bags of lobster and other "Clam Bake" items for a large family event. This is when the volume discount was "Lurned". Sadly we were shopping for two and just couldn't girth the same volume. Despite four 1.5 pounders, clams, and some smoked haddock was just peachy for us "Come-To's."
Restaurantji Recommends
The scallops were wonderful
Finest seafood in the state and stellar crew.
Excellent food and service...
Buy fresh picked crab and lobster here. A huge variety of fresh fish including haddock and whole live lobsters. Also a large variety of fresh frozen fish. Some great local dips and cheeses, and kefir.
Had a wonderful experience at the Belfast Farmer's Market today. Fantastic fish, very friendly and helpful representative.