We've dined here a number of times since they've opened. The food is usually very good. The menu has been redone sine our last trip. Service was ok but could have been more attentive. We asked for extra bread to soak up the broth in the mussels, which is excellent. Getting charged $3 for 4 small pieces of. Crostini seemed excessive. Overall, it's 4 stars.
Doug
It's always a great experience. The food is excellent and the staff friendly and attentive.
J. R.
Loved our time at 876. It was our second visit. Loved the food and drinks. Our server was so very friendly.
Matt
Our visit to 876 in Baldwin on Valentine's Day: This was the second time we came to 876 and were extremely disappointed; I've been 4 times total .Their food is quality, but, the service and food planning was absolutely terrible. Reservations were for 7:00 and upon being seated, were told there was no pizza dough. Okay. We ordered a glass of wine and a water. That took 15 min to come. We ordered the meatball appetizer, which was good (but, took 1/2 hr to arrive; 45 min in). My date ordered the Ropa Vieja and were told they were out of Brisket. So, she ordered the Tagliatelle alla Bolognese and was told this was not available either. So she ordered the Tagliatelle in mushroom sauce. Perfect!! My date decided she wanted the drink special and I ordered another glass of wine. 20 min later, I walked up to the bar and ordered them direct, which we got immediately. An hour after ordering our food, the waitress came back and said they were out of the pasta for the Tagliatelle. She reordered a salad; so much for going out to eat a quality meal only to get a salad you can get anywhere. Mind you, we were there at 7:00 pm and they were out of, literally, 1/3 of their menu. Looking around the restaurant, none of the tables were happy and were there for a LONG time. We got our food at about 9:20. Our waitress was horrible!! When presented the bill, our waitress made extra sure that we knew we were not charged for the Mushroom Tagliatelle, like it was being gifted. She never came by to see if we needed anything, no apology, nothing. 2 other waitresses did notice we were not being serviced. I ordered the Spinach Lasagna Rotolo which was very good, albeit, small. Literally rolled one noodle, cut in half, covered in sauce and cheese. Again, the food here is awesome. The service and food planning is horrible. 2-1/2 hrs for a pasta dish, salad, appetizer,and 4 drinks; 2 I had to get myself. I doubt we'll return. This has happened 2 out of 4 visits.
Jamie
The kitchen was REALLY backed up and it took almost 1 1/2 hours to get our food. The restaurant seemed short staffed and overall chaotic.
Sally
Always a lovely visit to 876! We are frequent customers each time we visit our MI lake house, at least eight times a year with family and friends. Delicious classic recipes that satisfy every palate. Great decor, vibe. Staff is always professional, friendly and have a great work ethic. So glad you took a chance on Baldwin❤️
William Flaska
Great place! Food was on point and it all had great flavors. Nice menu selections also
kathy dennison
Tonight was my first time trying out this fabulous restaurant.
Ladies - The drinks are amazing. Pasta was homemade. The dessert tastes like heaven. But do not walk out of this restaurant without taking a little trip to the ladies room!!! You can thank me later. 🏆💜😎
Allison Obermier
Drinks and food were unique and very well executed. The mussels were amazing!
Karen
They didn't have chicken so they went and bought some to make my meal. The gluten free pasta is AMAZING!!!!
We've been here numerous times and have brought friends from all over and have always had a great experience. The atmosphere is layed back, the food and drinks are great, and the employees from the hostess, waitresses, bartenders, and kitchen staff are exceptional. No matter what you have going in the Baldwin area whether your passing through, visiting for the weekend or a local resident I highly recommend checking this place out...Order the smoked Old Fashioned you won't be sorry.
Penny
My friends who had the walleye were delighted. The harvest pizza was delicious, though l would have liked a little more of the toppings...the beets and squash. Our server, Ari, was amazing! She was fun and very helpful. She gets 7 stars! We will be back.
Charles Johnson
Jessica was great!! Amazing apps, we had the Italian meatballs and muscles. Beautiful atmosphere ♥️ spent our 13th anniversary dinner there, Perfect place in Baldwin. We will definitely come back with family and friends.
Nick Meekhof
Amazing food, hidden gem in Baldwin!
Ben Cuprys
A hidden gem in Baldwin. Amazing food, great service, and cool decor. Went when we encountered long lines at our normal places. Wish we had gone sooner. Will be back!
We've dined here a number of times since they've opened. The food is usually very good. The menu has been redone sine our last trip. Service was ok but could have been more attentive. We asked for extra bread to soak up the broth in the mussels, which is excellent. Getting charged $3 for 4 small pieces of. Crostini seemed excessive. Overall, it's 4 stars.
It's always a great experience. The food is excellent and the staff friendly and attentive.
Loved our time at 876. It was our second visit. Loved the food and drinks. Our server was so very friendly.
Our visit to 876 in Baldwin on Valentine's Day: This was the second time we came to 876 and were extremely disappointed; I've been 4 times total .Their food is quality, but, the service and food planning was absolutely terrible. Reservations were for 7:00 and upon being seated, were told there was no pizza dough. Okay. We ordered a glass of wine and a water. That took 15 min to come. We ordered the meatball appetizer, which was good (but, took 1/2 hr to arrive; 45 min in). My date ordered the Ropa Vieja and were told they were out of Brisket. So, she ordered the Tagliatelle alla Bolognese and was told this was not available either. So she ordered the Tagliatelle in mushroom sauce. Perfect!! My date decided she wanted the drink special and I ordered another glass of wine. 20 min later, I walked up to the bar and ordered them direct, which we got immediately. An hour after ordering our food, the waitress came back and said they were out of the pasta for the Tagliatelle. She reordered a salad; so much for going out to eat a quality meal only to get a salad you can get anywhere. Mind you, we were there at 7:00 pm and they were out of, literally, 1/3 of their menu. Looking around the restaurant, none of the tables were happy and were there for a LONG time. We got our food at about 9:20. Our waitress was horrible!! When presented the bill, our waitress made extra sure that we knew we were not charged for the Mushroom Tagliatelle, like it was being gifted. She never came by to see if we needed anything, no apology, nothing. 2 other waitresses did notice we were not being serviced. I ordered the Spinach Lasagna Rotolo which was very good, albeit, small. Literally rolled one noodle, cut in half, covered in sauce and cheese. Again, the food here is awesome. The service and food planning is horrible. 2-1/2 hrs for a pasta dish, salad, appetizer,and 4 drinks; 2 I had to get myself. I doubt we'll return. This has happened 2 out of 4 visits.
The kitchen was REALLY backed up and it took almost 1 1/2 hours to get our food. The restaurant seemed short staffed and overall chaotic.
Always a lovely visit to 876! We are frequent customers each time we visit our MI lake house, at least eight times a year with family and friends. Delicious classic recipes that satisfy every palate. Great decor, vibe. Staff is always professional, friendly and have a great work ethic. So glad you took a chance on Baldwin❤️
Great place! Food was on point and it all had great flavors. Nice menu selections also
Tonight was my first time trying out this fabulous restaurant.
Ladies - The drinks are amazing. Pasta was homemade. The dessert tastes like heaven. But do not walk out of this restaurant without taking a little trip to the ladies room!!! You can thank me later. 🏆💜😎
Drinks and food were unique and very well executed. The mussels were amazing!
They didn't have chicken so they went and bought some to make my meal. The gluten free pasta is AMAZING!!!!
Restaurantji Recommends
We've been here numerous times and have brought friends from all over and have always had a great experience. The atmosphere is layed back, the food and drinks are great, and the employees from the hostess, waitresses, bartenders, and kitchen staff are exceptional. No matter what you have going in the Baldwin area whether your passing through, visiting for the weekend or a local resident I highly recommend checking this place out...Order the smoked Old Fashioned you won't be sorry.
My friends who had the walleye were delighted. The harvest pizza was delicious, though l would have liked a little more of the toppings...the beets and squash. Our server, Ari, was amazing! She was fun and very helpful. She gets 7 stars! We will be back.
Jessica was great!! Amazing apps, we had the Italian meatballs and muscles. Beautiful atmosphere ♥️ spent our 13th anniversary dinner there, Perfect place in Baldwin. We will definitely come back with family and friends.
Amazing food, hidden gem in Baldwin!
A hidden gem in Baldwin. Amazing food, great service, and cool decor. Went when we encountered long lines at our normal places. Wish we had gone sooner. Will be back!
Loading...