My wife and I recently visited for dinner I was born on the east coast in NJ so any time I can get some pizza close to what I got back home I jump on it. We walked in and we were greeted by the owner himself Kevin right away him and I started talking about New York and how much we miss it and the Pizza his kindness is unmatched and you can tell he cares deeply about his business. We were treated with an appetizer on the house a slice of home is what it needs to be called because once I took the first bite I was in New York at that moment Kevin joined us for a slice and told us all the things he does different from anyone else. This man is genuine and he makes killer pizza đ I 100% recommend this restaurant the wait staff is sensational and Kevin treats everyone like family he is an amazing person and the pizza is phenomenal.
Katie Clark-Wilberding
Thanks Kevin for the fellowship and a wonderful lunch!!! Appreciated the time we spent with you today .... James and I will definitely be back of course lol ... Amazing food
Nic Meyer
Stopped in on Saturday evening before the Harry Potter event. Everything was fast, everything was perfect and everyone inside was pleasant. The pizza is top notch. Itâs the real deal. I will always stop into Brooklyn Boyz when Iâm hungry for something authentic.
Taylor Wagner
Had a huge order placed for my wedding but was unable to get through to the catering person, Jen. 17 days out from my wedding, I was still unable to adjust or pay for my order. I spoke with the owner to politely explain why I was canceling my order and KEVIN (THE OWNER) HUNG UP ON ME. Incredibly happy I decided to reorder from G's and they were able to accommodate my order for 80 people 17 days out.
Clayton Collins
The best pizza and calzones in Bay City! Period, everyone else is not worth the time .
We had never been here before. After asking on Facebook where to get a great pizza, this place got the most recommendations. We started with a small pizza because we didnât know if weâd like it. We ended up ordering a second pizza! We will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brooklyn Pizza
M. Hamade
The food is absolutely great. The calamari is cooked perfectly and not chewy at all, the pizza dough is not dry or oily, just perfect, and the sauce is full of flavour and tastes fresh and not out of a can. The quality of the food is great. It isn't a commercial fast food kind of restaurant. The service is amazing.
Cool little pizza place. I called and ordered 3 pizzas. All xl. Was told 25 minutes. It took 45 minutes. We had scheduled lunch with a client in our office and they called and cancelled. So last minute we ordered. Staff goes back to work at 1. You were the closest to the office. Then I got back. The staff had literally seven minutes to eat, and I have to be honest there was nothing special about your pizza. It was a pizza Iâve had 1 million times. It wasnât great you described it, but it wasnât bad either. It was just another pizza. You donât do your Pizza in a brick oven like they do in New York, especially Brooklyn. So the reality is youâre not really a New York style pizza And you have just a mediocre crust. Not Knocking your success because most Americans donât actually know what true New York style pizza taste like. First and foremost itâs not made on a. Directly on the bottom of the brick in the oven. Or if youâre really lucky a super high heat coal oven. You guys are just an average pizza pizza place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 2
Kaveman boi
Got a large pizza and garlic knots. Been a couple times, because it is a little expensive, but overall definitely worth it
Favorite restaurant in Bay City, hands down. Came to town for the fireworks festival, so of course we had to grab a pizza and some garlic knots too. New to us, they now offer text messaging service to let you know when your order is ready. Used to come to Brooklyn Boyz way way back as a teen (20ish years), and things have only improved since! Obviously, it's a new location, so it's much more spacious and even better than before. They have a full bar and offer outdoor patio seating. Overall, I'd say it's the perfect atmosphere, whether you're looking for a casual dining experience or fancy occasion. Comfortable, great music, ambiance, and a good mix of all of the above! They still offer pizza by the slice, too, which is unheard of elsewhere. Cost is very reasonable and there's something for everyone on the menu.
The Garlic Knots were fantastic, it's worth coming here just for them. They were very crispy with plenty of flavor. The pizza was a tad small, so we recommend getting a size up, but the ingredients all tasted fresh and worked well together. We will definitely stop by again if we are in town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots with Marinara Dipping Sauce
Brad Meyer
Must try the garlic knots, food and staff were wonderful!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
William Paige
Best Pizza ? Anywhere. Still the Best Pizza ? Around. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stephanie M
Best pizza anywhere! Definitely a hidden gem if you're not familiar with the area. The chicken pesto pizza is amazing and the garlic knots are so good! The atmosphere inside is very nice but we usually ordered takeout. They're very friendly you can just tell that they have higher standards including the service, quality of the ingredients, presentation, just everything. I wish we had a Brooklyn Boyz in Texas but I can't wait to visit again next time we're in town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots with Marinara Dipping Sauce, Alfredo, Pesto
Tommy Andrew
Great service and real cool place! Perfect stop for a Pizza and cold beer! Update: we stopped back in for another night out, the pizza was unbelievable!! A Margareta pizza with tomatoes and mushrooms, wow was it good!
My wife and I recently visited for dinner I was born on the east coast in NJ so any time I can get some pizza close to what I got back home I jump on it. We walked in and we were greeted by the owner himself Kevin right away him and I started talking about New York and how much we miss it and the Pizza his kindness is unmatched and you can tell he cares deeply about his business. We were treated with an appetizer on the house a slice of home is what it needs to be called because once I took the first bite I was in New York at that moment Kevin joined us for a slice and told us all the things he does different from anyone else. This man is genuine and he makes killer pizza đ I 100% recommend this restaurant the wait staff is sensational and Kevin treats everyone like family he is an amazing person and the pizza is phenomenal.
Thanks Kevin for the fellowship and a wonderful lunch!!! Appreciated the time we spent with you today .... James and I will definitely be back of course lol ... Amazing food
Stopped in on Saturday evening before the Harry Potter event. Everything was fast, everything was perfect and everyone inside was pleasant. The pizza is top notch. Itâs the real deal. I will always stop into Brooklyn Boyz when Iâm hungry for something authentic.
Had a huge order placed for my wedding but was unable to get through to the catering person, Jen. 17 days out from my wedding, I was still unable to adjust or pay for my order. I spoke with the owner to politely explain why I was canceling my order and KEVIN (THE OWNER) HUNG UP ON ME. Incredibly happy I decided to reorder from G's and they were able to accommodate my order for 80 people 17 days out.
The best pizza and calzones in Bay City! Period, everyone else is not worth the time .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots with Marinara Dipping Sauce, Marinara, Lasagna, Margherita Pizza, Brooklyn Pizza
We had never been here before. After asking on Facebook where to get a great pizza, this place got the most recommendations. We started with a small pizza because we didnât know if weâd like it. We ended up ordering a second pizza! We will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brooklyn Pizza
The food is absolutely great.
The calamari is cooked perfectly and not chewy at all, the pizza dough is not dry or oily, just perfect, and the sauce is full of flavour and tastes fresh and not out of a can. The quality of the food is great. It isn't a commercial fast food kind of restaurant.
The service is amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Alfredo, Greek Salad, Calamari, Marinara
Cool little pizza place. I called and ordered 3 pizzas. All xl. Was told 25 minutes. It took 45 minutes. We had scheduled lunch with a client in our office and they called and cancelled. So last minute we ordered. Staff goes back to work at 1. You were the closest to the office. Then I got back. The staff had literally seven minutes to eat, and I have to be honest there was nothing special about your pizza. It was a pizza Iâve had 1 million times. It wasnât great you described it, but it wasnât bad either. It was just another pizza. You donât do your Pizza in a brick oven like they do in New York, especially Brooklyn. So the reality is youâre not really a New York style pizza And you have just a mediocre crust. Not Knocking your success because most Americans donât actually know what true New York style pizza taste like. First and foremost itâs not made on a. Directly on the bottom of the brick in the oven. Or if youâre really lucky a super high heat coal oven. You guys are just an average pizza pizza place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 2
Got a large pizza and garlic knots. Been a couple times, because it is a little expensive, but overall definitely worth it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots with Marinara Dipping Sauce, Alfredo, Margherita Pizza
Favorite restaurant in Bay City, hands down. Came to town for the fireworks festival, so of course we had to grab a pizza and some garlic knots too. New to us, they now offer text messaging service to let you know when your order is ready. Used to come to Brooklyn Boyz way way back as a teen (20ish years), and things have only improved since! Obviously, it's a new location, so it's much more spacious and even better than before. They have a full bar and offer outdoor patio seating. Overall, I'd say it's the perfect atmosphere, whether you're looking for a casual dining experience or fancy occasion. Comfortable, great music, ambiance, and a good mix of all of the above! They still offer pizza by the slice, too, which is unheard of elsewhere. Cost is very reasonable and there's something for everyone on the menu.
Kid-friendliness: Family friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots with Marinara Dipping Sauce, Antipasta Salad, Lasagna
Restaurantji Recommends
The Garlic Knots were fantastic, it's worth coming here just for them. They were very crispy with plenty of flavor. The pizza was a tad small, so we recommend getting a size up, but the ingredients all tasted fresh and worked well together. We will definitely stop by again if we are in town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots with Marinara Dipping Sauce
Must try the garlic knots, food and staff were wonderful!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best Pizza ? Anywhere. Still the Best Pizza ? Around. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza anywhere! Definitely a hidden gem if you're not familiar with the area. The chicken pesto pizza is amazing and the garlic knots are so good! The atmosphere inside is very nice but we usually ordered takeout. They're very friendly you can just tell that they have higher standards including the service, quality of the ingredients, presentation, just everything. I wish we had a Brooklyn Boyz in Texas but I can't wait to visit again next time we're in town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots with Marinara Dipping Sauce, Alfredo, Pesto
Great service and real cool place! Perfect stop for a Pizza and cold beer! Update: we stopped back in for another night out, the pizza was unbelievable!! A Margareta pizza with tomatoes and mushrooms, wow was it good!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...