Restaurants near Bay Port

“Bay Port bliss! Delicious food, yummy cocktails, and the kind of fun, happy vibe you never want to leave. Mel --- the fabulous queen of this place - makes you feel instantly at home. Already dreaming of our next friends trip herel”

“Great place friendly people and delicious food we will be back this summer Thank you !!”

“Loved the food. Fresh, consistent, delish. Cocktails are spot on! Connor, your the Best!”

“We love Mast's! My wife and I are "usuals" and we typically stop in at least once, if not twice, a week for a mid-day pick me up. Great location and service! Crystal and her crew are top notch!”

“Just as you remember as a kid - perfect diner!!”

“Can't beat the Great Bar Burgers and bar food.. I need to eat there alot more often

Vegetarian options: I know nothing about this

Dietary restrictions: I know nothing

Kid-friendliness: Didn't pay attention to that.. I was to busy eating my Burger

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes they have wheelchair accessibility”

“My family and I visited Caseville this week and enjoyed Brew Moon Coffee House each day! After seeing the cafe come up on Google, we had to give them a try and seriously it was the best! The first day we went in, the young baristas were friendly, gave great recommendations with outstanding service! We enjoyed the rose garden and walking through the shop area and gallery. We knew we had to come back so my husband would bike the remaining two mornings to bring back coffee to our campsite. I would highly recommend you visit if you’re in Caseville!”

“OMG amazing hand tossed pizza, made just the way I love! Hot fresh and on time! Had pepperoni and sausage and a quarter of it had green olives ♥️”

“Really good BBQ and Cheesecake :-) Thank you”

“Came here for dinner last night and it was such a great experience. We ordered the three cheese artichoke dip, shrimp scampi pasta, and BBQ Brisket sandwich. My husband got a beer… one of the IPAs, I’m unsure of the name! It was all delicious! Highly recommend the dip with the fresh baguette! 👌👍 If you’re going for dinner, I suggest getting there early as it got very packed even a little before 6pm on a Friday night! There was live music playing and the musician was good to boot! Huge shout to Lauren for her accommodations (we had a baby and stroller in a small and busy space) as she quickly shifted tables and other things around for us to be comfortable. She even had the musician give us an anniversary shout on the mic. It made us feel very special. It looks like there is a lot of outdoor seating and I’m sure it would be a different but equally wonderful experience in the warmer months also. If we’re ever in the thumb again (love their brewery name, too haha) we will have to make this a stop! Thank you, Thumb Brewery staff, for everything!”

“Shakers is the best! Worth the drive for totally delicious ice cream! There is sooooo much to choose from! The service is awesome, too! The helpful, happy, friendly staff make you feel at home! Shakers has great indoor and outdoor seating! It’s very clean and even has fun decor! ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️”

“My first pizza from Main St.! I ordered a Margharita pizza because I want to taste the crust, sauce, and cheese on my first try. Crust was good, very little sauce so no comment on that, lots of very good mozzarella cheese. It was more like a cheesebread. Hardly any fresh tomatoes and vitually no fresh basil. But I'll give him a break since it's winter in Caseville and no fresh produce to speak of! I'll try again with a different type of pizza. Also want to try the ribs! I support local eateries!!”

“Wonderful and tasty grilled chicken pita 🫓 I would definitely recommend!”

“This family owned, family operated business is WONDERFUL. The coffee is delicious. The people are friendly. The atmosphere is inviting. Wish we lived closer, would visit again and again.”

“Caseville Dairy Queen is my favorite! Always delicious treats and terrific staff! The best blizzard mixers around!”

“I stopped in today for a coney. Carson was my server and he was the best. No offense to any servers over the years, they're all nice, he was hands down THE BEST. All young folks could take a lesson from him. He was polite, had a smile the whole time, and was very knowledgeable . He deserves to be the employee of the summer. WAY TO GO CARSON... you're going to go far in life.”

“Places to eat are few and far between in a small town. Subway is great place because it is fresh and fast. The Ladies behind the counter are fast and friendly, and the food is really good. A great place to pick up a fast meal. Located in the Clark gas station.”

“pizza and garlic sticks were delicious!!!!!!”

“Some of the best pizza around!!!”

“The pizza was good but my son was a little disappointed in his first trip that the Pizza Portal wasn't working. The attendant at the counter quickly retrieved our pizza and we were out the door in under 60 seconds. Another gentleman waiting for his order even opened the door for us. Over all, the pizzas were good and so was our experience”

“Young man was all by himself for non hour. He worked his tail off trying to keep up with walk ins and online orders. Making sandwiches and running the register is practically impossible, but he was getting it done. Would of been faster if management we're to staff the store better during peak times. Young man deserved double pay for trying to keep up!!”

“We moved here about a month ago, and have eaten there a few times. The Food and Service are Outstanding! What a great little gem we found.”

“I recently had the pleasure of staying at Blue Water Inn, and I couldn't be more impressed with the experience! The location is unbeatable, offering stunning views of the water and easy access to nearby attractions. The rooms were clean, comfortable, and well-appointed, with all the amenities needed for a relaxing stay.

What really stood out was the friendly and attentive staff. From check-in to check-out, they went above and beyond to ensure we had everything we needed and made us feel right at home. The atmosphere was cozy and welcoming, perfect for a getaway.

If you're looking for a place to unwind by the water with great service and a warm ambiance, I highly recommend Blue Water Inn. We can't wait to return!”

“It was super swamped tonight with two huge parties of 20 people and every table and bar stool filled and the TWO girls working the bar and floor were hopping! Despite being busy they attended to everyone with smiles on their faces and kept up! Food was hot and great too. The cook came out and checked on things as well! Job well done! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️”

“How could the same restaurant deliver two completely different experiences? We visited in June and everything was on point. Wings were big and juicy, breading full coated and was crispy, provided with extra sauces, mozzarella sticks seemed handmade and we were given both marinara and nacho cheese to dip, which I thought was awesome. Very satisfied with that visit, talked the place up a bunch. When we went back in July, totally different experience - told the server as I was ordering how impressed I was the first time, picked 4 sauces for a double order of wings and was excited to try them, made a point to mention about loving the nacho cheese with the mozzarella sticks, and tried boneless wings this time. Could not have been more disappointed. Wings were small, breading was sparce, a number of wings felt rubbery or like they were mostly bone. Mozzarella sticks seemed frozen and I think I could find better boneless wings at the grocery store. For the sauces for the wings, instead of the 4 I ordered, I only got two oversized cups and I'm pretty sure they were both mango habanero, which not everyone liked. With the mozzarella sticks, we got no sauces at all, despite discussing with the server/bartender how much I liked those touches. Even the to go containers were different and not as nice, and the paper inside was cheap and all ripped. It looked like whoever made the first order quit and they hired the worst possible replacement. My dad covered the meal for us, and he objected to the place at first because he had heard some not great reviews, but I assured him that it was good, and then had to apologize for picking this place. It was all over $100 and for that much, I would expect the quality of food I got the first time, and not the kind of stuff I'd even be disappointed with from a fast food drive-thru. Sucks too, cuz I love the vibe in there and enjoyed sitting and waiting for my food, but after the disastrous gamble of the second visit, I do not feel like rolling the dice on another one.”

“They were out of zucchini sticks but suggested the mushrooms which were amazingly!! A phenomenal appetizer, really glad we got it. The pizza was very good obviously made with quality cheese and ingredients. The boneless wings were very tasty, we appreciated the sauce being on the side.

If you are in the mood for real pizza, go to this genuine restaurant with real pizza ovens. The woman who took the order and gave it to me was very nice.

In response to earlier posters, the prices are what you should expect for good pizza and appetizers.”

“It was our first time here….and both my wife and I thought their cheeseburger was EXCELLENT!! The staff was also very friendly and helpful, and the service was quick. We will definitely be back!”

“friendly crew great service”