Joey C's Pizzeria
1835 M-139, Benton Harbor
(269) 925-1188
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
Great food Everytime we have got it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Taco Pizza, Chicken Bacon Ranch
Disgusting Owner! Ordered a large supreme pizza and a large salad. Pizza had raw pink under cooked sausage all over it. Raw undercooked crunchy big pieces of bell pepper. Soggy raw dough. Cheese half melted. Salad was half cheese. Had to drive all the way back with the disgusting raw undercooked pizza and cheese salad. Asked for a refund. Owner came up to the counter with a horrible attitude. Argued and said there's no pink In the sausage. Said the pizza was fine, like someone who's indenial. Obviously its not, everything is undercooked,including the dough. I'm a customer who's standing at the counter asking for a refund.. He then went on to say he's only refunding the pizza not the salad. He then started verbally harassing me yelling at me and called me broke. Im a woman in her 20s and I was super nice about the situation. The owner yelled at me, called me broke, and walked away from me angrily. Do not give this place your business. I spent $57 on an undercooked pizza and a large size salad and some extra sauces. Only refunded me $30. I feel taken advantage of. And disrespected. To be called broke after patronizing his business and having to come back with an inedible pizza... Im a woman and I shouldn't have been talked to like that by a grown man. He was yelling and everything, as if it's my fault the pizza is undercooked and disgusting. Really upset. You guys are horrible people to treat customers that way. I was polite, tried to even call first and nobody would answer. Horrible people. Horrible owner.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
We were passing through town on our vacation and always like to try some place local. We had a pizza and some salads. Fantastic food and the service was great.
THEE BEST PIZZA! CAN'T SAY MORE!
I didn't try this place until 2025 and I got carry out. I feel like i've been missing out! Great pepperoni pizza, breadsticks, and fantastic marinara sauce. I'll be back, thank you!
We usually get the full order of mosticolli with meat sauce and there's plenty for leftovers
Love the PIZZA 😁😁😚😎
First time customer!
I ordered the chicken ranch pizza and it was the best I’ve ever had! Pizza was hot, loaded and very fresh!
This was our second time getting pizza here. First time was when we were in MI in 2022. I now remember why we didn't go back. The crust is so thin and soggy, the sauce and toppings are way too salty. And, for the money is seriously overpriced. Large pizza with 2 extra toppings was over $30. Very disappointed and I wouldn't call this pizza....more like slop-in-a-box.
Awesome pizza!
Restaurantji Recommends
Always great food and staff. Recommend the Joey C Sub!
We continue to order from Joey C’s for our work luncheons. Everyone loves the pizza, pricing is very fair, and the staff is incredibly friendly and will do whatever they can to ensure you enjoy. One time, even with an oven down, they still prepared our very large order. 5 stars across the board, they will continue to have our business :)
Other than feeling a little pressured to tip, the food was amazing. We will be repeat customers for sure.
Pizza 🍕 was really good!
Joey C’s did not disappoint. We are from out of state and took a chance on this restaurant to provide pizza for our son’s wedding at The Blue Dress Barn. Everyone gave the pizza rave reviews! Friendly service, prompt delivery, and delicious pizza made their late night snack a huge success! Thank you!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...