Services was outstanding. However was very disappointed with the Cod Dinner. Cod did not have the usual beer batter coatingvand flaky fish texture. This Cod was was tasteless with a like coating. Looked like boxed fish sticks. Fish was tough and actually had to use a knife to cut it. Friends were happy with Coconut Shrimp dinner.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
David Wright
Will not return!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Katie M
We have a summer house in Caseville and have been here for about 20 years. We’re not tourists, and every time we come here they treat you rude, and it’s a very uncomfortable atmosphere. We have tried it many times hoping it would get better, and it never has unfortunately. They should be happy to have the tourism because believe me that’s what keeps them afloat. Labor Day weekend we came in on Sunday at 2:00pm because we wanted to check out their new “deck upstairs” (which they posted about on Facebook) and order some apps and have some drinks. We walked in we’re not greeted and followed the deck sign, the door was closed so my husband asked a waitress “hi, is the deck upstairs open?” and she rudely said “um, I don’t think so” and walked away to the kitchen. I was flabbergasted. They were not busy, she could have said let me check, or say unfortunately no we don’t have the staff or whatever the reason was. We just stood and looked at each other in awe that was how they treat their customers. We left and went over the thumb brewery which is always exceptional with food, drinks, live entertainment and service. Beachys as well, they are just different vibes. With the amount of negative reviews I read tonight about Blue Water when coming on to post this I’m not surprised. They better figure it out and get better staff because paying customers have A LOT more options which are way better than this place to spend their money at.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Alex Grignani
It is a sit yourself restaurant/bar there was 6 of us we sat down within minutes of sitting someone greeted us took our order and filled up our drinks 30 mins go past no one has came and checked on us and other tables started filling up with similar party sizes, Now we are in a hour with no one to be seen other tables got served before us 4-5 tables , we did not order much 6 of us but only 4 meals. When waitress came by we finally was able to ask for a check for our drinks, her response was “ I just got buzzed I think your food is next” short story it wasn’t , we asked for our check again and she said “yours is the next ticket” tell me why 4-5 other tables got served before us and paid and left. We ended up leaving after paying what we had. The waitress seemed a little irritated when we asked about this. Even a little hi all sorry your food is taking longer than expected can I get you some more water could have went a long way
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Andrew Fribley
Local dive. Live music was great inside. Outside cover band were weekend warriors...I hope. Loud and awful. Rude ignorant bartenders.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
Curt B.
Typical Michigan Tavern type eating place.
Nothing special on the menu had a good selection of burgers. We had the nachos for appetizer which were pretty good.
Looks like they have had a fried perch sandwich which I might try next time. Otherwise just a ho-hum place to fill your belly, with a bar adjacent.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
carlin caszatt
Good food and service even on a crazy weekend of cheeseburger festival.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Jami Ovares
Worst service I've ever had, after 25 minutes of my drink order I had to go to the bar and reorder. I already ordered my appetizer and had to reorder that at the bar. The menu online is not the same as in the resteraunt, very limited. The owner approached us at our table saying I think we've missed you, our waitress left on family emergency, everyone around us was being served and when the owner tried to square up our tab, he charged us double for our drinks, we had to let him know he was wrong, we got our own drinks. The food we ordered, coconut shrimp came with no lemon or sauce, after 15 minutes we got a lemon wedge. Mind you the place was not overcrowded to where we should have been forgotten. We paid full price for Gordon frozen food, heat em up appetizers. The staff was young and very unknowledgeable, we decoded to go somewhere else for dinner
Becky the bartender was super unprofessional & made me & my family extremely uncomfortable. Would recommend a positive atmosphere
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 1
Mario D
Old time restaurant from the 1900s the interior hasn’t changed much and has a rustic feel the staff are nice and friendly and the food is quite good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Heather Terry
Great food and staff
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amy Kaminski
Sunday Brisket Special is NOT TO BE MISSED! I have it on good authority (my husband...and he handles our smoking detail!) is still raving the next day with how good the Brisket Special was. I tried the BBQ Beans and I have to admit, they were pretty good on their own. I had the pizza which I've had several times and really enjoyed. We love heading to Dufty's BWI whenever we're in Caseville and we've never been disappointed!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
QL QL
$17 for a small burger and $3 for a Coke. Nothing to write home about. Kind of ironic for a place that's supposedly famous for cheeseburgers. I guess when you're in a popular summer boating town, even mediocrity comes with a premium.
Services was outstanding. However was very disappointed with the Cod Dinner. Cod did not have the usual beer batter coatingvand flaky fish texture. This Cod was was tasteless with a like coating. Looked like boxed fish sticks. Fish was tough and actually had to use a knife to cut it. Friends were happy with Coconut Shrimp dinner.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Will not return!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
We have a summer house in Caseville and have been here for about 20 years. We’re not tourists, and every time we come here they treat you rude, and it’s a very uncomfortable atmosphere. We have tried it many times hoping it would get better, and it never has unfortunately. They should be happy to have the tourism because believe me that’s what keeps them afloat. Labor Day weekend we came in on Sunday at 2:00pm because we wanted to check out their new “deck upstairs” (which they posted about on Facebook) and order some apps and have some drinks. We walked in we’re not greeted and followed the deck sign, the door was closed so my husband asked a waitress “hi, is the deck upstairs open?” and she rudely said “um, I don’t think so” and walked away to the kitchen. I was flabbergasted. They were not busy, she could have said let me check, or say unfortunately no we don’t have the staff or whatever the reason was. We just stood and looked at each other in awe that was how they treat their customers. We left and went over the thumb brewery which is always exceptional with food, drinks, live entertainment and service. Beachys as well, they are just different vibes. With the amount of negative reviews I read tonight about Blue Water when coming on to post this I’m not surprised. They better figure it out and get better staff because paying customers have A LOT more options which are way better than this place to spend their money at.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
It is a sit yourself restaurant/bar there was 6 of us we sat down within minutes of sitting someone greeted us took our order and filled up our drinks 30 mins go past no one has came and checked on us and other tables started filling up with similar party sizes, Now we are in a hour with no one to be seen other tables got served before us 4-5 tables , we did not order much 6 of us but only 4 meals. When waitress came by we finally was able to ask for a check for our drinks, her response was “ I just got buzzed I think your food is next” short story it wasn’t , we asked for our check again and she said “yours is the next ticket” tell me why 4-5 other tables got served before us and paid and left. We ended up leaving after paying what we had. The waitress seemed a little irritated when we asked about this. Even a little hi all sorry your food is taking longer than expected can I get you some more water could have went a long way
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Local dive. Live music was great inside. Outside cover band were weekend warriors...I hope. Loud and awful. Rude ignorant bartenders.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
Typical Michigan Tavern type eating place.
Nothing special on the menu had a good selection of burgers. We had the nachos for appetizer which were pretty good.
Looks like they have had a fried perch sandwich which I might try next time. Otherwise just a ho-hum place to fill your belly, with a bar adjacent.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
Good food and service even on a crazy weekend of cheeseburger festival.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Worst service I've ever had, after 25 minutes of my drink order I had to go to the bar and reorder. I already ordered my appetizer and had to reorder that at the bar. The menu online is not the same as in the resteraunt, very limited. The owner approached us at our table saying I think we've missed you, our waitress left on family emergency, everyone around us was being served and when the owner tried to square up our tab, he charged us double for our drinks, we had to let him know he was wrong, we got our own drinks. The food we ordered, coconut shrimp came with no lemon or sauce, after 15 minutes we got a lemon wedge. Mind you the place was not overcrowded to where we should have been forgotten. We paid full price for Gordon frozen food, heat em up appetizers. The staff was young and very unknowledgeable, we decoded to go somewhere else for dinner
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Service sucks!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
Love this place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Becky the bartender was super unprofessional & made me & my family extremely uncomfortable. Would recommend a positive atmosphere
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 1
Old time restaurant from the 1900s the interior hasn’t changed much and has a rustic feel the staff are nice and friendly and the food is quite good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Great food and staff
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sunday Brisket Special is NOT TO BE MISSED! I have it on good authority (my husband...and he handles our smoking detail!) is still raving the next day with how good the Brisket Special was. I tried the BBQ Beans and I have to admit, they were pretty good on their own. I had the pizza which I've had several times and really enjoyed. We love heading to Dufty's BWI whenever we're in Caseville and we've never been disappointed!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
$17 for a small burger and $3 for a Coke. Nothing to write home about. Kind of ironic for a place that's supposedly famous for cheeseburgers. I guess when you're in a popular summer boating town, even mediocrity comes with a premium.
Loading...