Catered an event I attended tonight! Food and desserts were hot and fresh. They were running a little late but it was the first time they've catered this event and the location is kind of hidden so I understand. The last caterer at this event sucked so Goodfellow breathed life back into this event. I'm sorry to see so many negative reviews, our experience was nothing short of a good one. No raw food here. I recommend Goodfellows catering.
Malori May
Since I have known them, their food is great. But since September of 2024 when we hired them for our wedding, it has been a disaster. With him forgetting about our taste testing TWICE, not even trying what we had on our menu, nothing was written down on our invoice(not even downpayment it was written on a sticky note), late for our wedding 1.5 hours, didn’t bring half of our desserts we paid for,, and didn’t have written down I paid him another payment of over $500. Super unorganized, and not trust worthy
Richard Fortune
I don't like giving bad reviews at all, but for cost that we paid and having only 2 young people serve our wedding and they where in van on there phones ! No pick up of plates ect. And food bland as it comes won't recommend js unfortunately. Who puts pork in cream of mushroom soup js.
Lexi 2017
I was very unhappy on my wedding day due to them being late the food was either over cooked or under cooked and the food was bland. He also didn’t have my dinner rolls that were supposed to be included with my order and he didn’t even bring my desserts the two desserts that I was looking forward to eating. Will say he did bring chicken that was not even on my order but he shouldn’t have because that was under cooked and didn’t even taste good. When my family and friends asked why he was late to bringing my food he kept changing the story. Over all this was my worse experience with any food caterer I will not be using them again. Would have rather just had pizza from a pizza place.
mrbulb15
Would really be nice to let people know you're not doing Polish food Wednesday. 1.5 hour round trip drive wasted. Web site and social media both say it is supposed to be happening.
Lynn S
The Polish plate is SO GOOD!
Benjamin Santistevan
Overpriced undercooked. Set up shop outside of an ice cream shop. Should have known better they had 0 traffic. Charged for everything, no veteran discount. Been hugging toilet since the first bite of raw meat I bit into. Charge for silverware, up charge for card purchase. Not friendly. Have not seen them sanitize or wash hands in hours… flies all over the food and served cold. Catering caddies had no flames under them…. Figure out the rest. No refunds…
Robin Oscoy
Great experience with Goodfellas for my daughter graduation party. The food was delivered timely, the people who delivered were friendly and accommodating, the food was outstanding. The last two days I’ve had people calling me wanting to know who catered. I’ve never seen so many people go for seconds. Thank you for the great experience. We will most definitely be using you in the future
Alison Kennedy
We got their food at the Swirly Top and were amazed! Great food you can tell is homemade!
Jordan Choinski
Goodfellas Catering & BBQ catered my dad's birthday party last weekend. the food was wonderful. Everyone was talking about it! the ribs and chicken fall right off the bone and the mostacoli is delicious. I would recommend them for any party or occasion!
Authentic Polish food! I swear you stole my Grandma's city chicken recipe. Everything was delicious and brought me back to my childhood. Well done!!
Mimmie Kimmie
Authentic Polish food! I swear you stole my Grandma's city chicken recipe. Everything was delicious and brought me back to my childhood. Well done!!
Brenda Persyn
Goodfellas catered the Celebration of Life for my husband on Harsens Island. They were fantastic to work with. The food was excellent and the workers that came were so professional and polite. I couldn't have asked for anything more.
Mark Miller
Some of the best tasting Polish food I ever had!
L Krause
Got food for 100 guests. Very well packaged, good instructions written on each container. Great value, saved us a lot of time.
Catered an event I attended tonight! Food and desserts were hot and fresh. They were running a little late but it was the first time they've catered this event and the location is kind of hidden so I understand. The last caterer at this event sucked so Goodfellow breathed life back into this event. I'm sorry to see so many negative reviews, our experience was nothing short of a good one. No raw food here. I recommend Goodfellows catering.
Since I have known them, their food is great. But since September of 2024 when we hired them for our wedding, it has been a disaster. With him forgetting about our taste testing TWICE, not even trying what we had on our menu, nothing was written down on our invoice(not even downpayment it was written on a sticky note), late for our wedding 1.5 hours, didn’t bring half of our desserts we paid for,, and didn’t have written down I paid him another payment of over $500. Super unorganized, and not trust worthy
I don't like giving bad reviews at all, but for cost that we paid and having only 2 young people serve our wedding and they where in van on there phones ! No pick up of plates ect. And food bland as it comes won't recommend js unfortunately. Who puts pork in cream of mushroom soup js.
I was very unhappy on my wedding day due to them being late the food was either over cooked or under cooked and the food was bland. He also didn’t have my dinner rolls that were supposed to be included with my order and he didn’t even bring my desserts the two desserts that I was looking forward to eating. Will say he did bring chicken that was not even on my order but he shouldn’t have because that was under cooked and didn’t even taste good. When my family and friends asked why he was late to bringing my food he kept changing the story.
Over all this was my worse experience with any food caterer I will not be using them again.
Would have rather just had pizza from a pizza place.
Would really be nice to let people know you're not doing Polish food Wednesday. 1.5 hour round trip drive wasted. Web site and social media both say it is supposed to be happening.
The Polish plate is SO GOOD!
Overpriced undercooked. Set up shop outside of an ice cream shop. Should have known better they had 0 traffic. Charged for everything, no veteran discount. Been hugging toilet since the first bite of raw meat I bit into. Charge for silverware, up charge for card purchase. Not friendly. Have not seen them sanitize or wash hands in hours… flies all over the food and served cold. Catering caddies had no flames under them…. Figure out the rest. No refunds…
Great experience with Goodfellas for my daughter graduation party. The food was delivered timely, the people who delivered were friendly and accommodating, the food was outstanding. The last two days I’ve had people calling me wanting to know who catered. I’ve never seen so many people go for seconds. Thank you for the great experience. We will most definitely be using you in the future
We got their food at the Swirly Top and were amazed! Great food you can tell is homemade!
Goodfellas Catering & BBQ catered my dad's birthday party last weekend. the food was wonderful. Everyone was talking about it! the ribs and chicken fall right off the bone and the mostacoli is delicious. I would recommend them for any party or occasion!
Restaurantji Recommends
Authentic Polish food! I swear you stole my Grandma's city chicken recipe. Everything was delicious and brought me back to my childhood. Well done!!
Authentic Polish food! I swear you stole my Grandma's city chicken recipe. Everything was delicious and brought me back to my childhood. Well done!!
Goodfellas catered the Celebration of Life for my husband on Harsens Island. They were fantastic to work with. The food was excellent and the workers that came were so professional and polite. I couldn't have asked for anything more.
Some of the best tasting Polish food I ever had!
Got food for 100 guests. Very well packaged, good instructions written on each container. Great value, saved us a lot of time.
Loading...