BEWARE they might tip themselves if you leave the tip amount unmarked. I was overcharged almost double my order amount. I have called 3 times now and even left my number for the manager and have yet to hear about a refund on my order. This is beyond ridiculous as my order was on 9/8/2025 and I called the day after to get this issue fixed.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Ryan James
If you're looking for amazing service with a side of wow, then you need to ask for Lindsie . From the moment she walked up to our table, she brought the perfect blend of charm, confidence, and total professionalism — not to mention she’s absolutely stunning. Lindsie knows how to work a room, handle a crowd, and keep every drink filled without missing a beat. She was quick with the recommendations (all spot-on), had a killer smile that lit up the place, and managed to keep the vibe friendly, flirty, and totally on point. You can tell she loves what she does, and it shows in every detail — from remembering our names to making sure we had everything we needed before we even asked. Bottom line: Lindsie isn’t just serving — she’s slaying. 10/10 would come back just for her. 🔥
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Tom Jackson
I had a very disappointing experience at the Buffalo Wild Wings in Coldwater, Michigan. My order was prepared incorrectly not once, but three separate times before it was finally corrected. This shows a clear breakdown in communication between the wait staff and the kitchen. While mistakes can happen, the repeated errors and lack of attention to detail reflected poorly on both the service and overall management of this location. As a customer, I expect accuracy and professionalism, and unfortunately, this visit did not meet even the most basic standards.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Nick Bremser
Ruff. Did me dirty on my fried pickles. They were so not done. Food was cold. Made my girl wait 15 for a refill and when she got her drink, it wasn't even the right drink.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Rich Basher
Disappointed with food, prices, and kitchen! Overpriced wings (traditional and boneless) for a plate of tiny wings. Asked for celery with both meals and they delivered 3 pieces plus threw in some carrots! Bartender was mortified with the plate and got more. Apparently they were running out at 6:30pm. We waited almost an hour for our food - wings! Place was not busy (Sunday over holiday). Heard staff saying kitchen crew walked outside to take a break - they were over worked! Only good was our Bartender on her first night by herself. Not coming back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
efonaz
Terrible service. The staff have no idea what they are doing
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Starr Myers
Had half restaurant empty. Was told they couldn’t even seat us because they couldn’t keep up. There was also a family of four with two little kids that’s was also refused service. As well as a couple that’s was refused as well. Horrible management and service. So we went to Applebees and got seated right away with excellent seevice
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Lesa Rudloff
Waitress was friendly! As busy as it was she did an awsome job!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mel Lang
Lindsie was amazing ! We are traveling back home and she had such an approachable smile. She took great care of us always checking in. She is a person who will build long lasting relationships here. Hands down she is an asset to this team. We live almost 5 hours away and she made us feel at home !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
haley
I usually never leave a 1 star review but I can confidently say that I was highly disappointed in the service today. We got sat down right away but waited 20 min to get approached by someone to take our drink/food order. I’d understand if the restaurant was busy but it was slow so I didn’t understand what the issue was.
The food is always good when I visit but the service has something to be desired. Servers are slow and inattentive where there are less than 5 tables filled. The kicker is then a 20% tip is expected! Yeah, The food is not worth the cost.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
J H
Cat was our server and her mood was quite irritable. After waiting for about 10 minutes for menus, she proceeded to slam our drinks down. It took about 15 minutes for our food to arrive, and then on top of that, we didn't even get silverware or napkins until I walked up amd asked for them. When I got the bill, I realized she had neglected to tell us of the unchanged for our appetizer. Once I asked for change of my bill, she slammed my change down and walked away with barely a word. I have worked as a server for a long time, this was abysmal to say the least.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Jeff “Jeffr0”
I ordered take Out via Uber Eats. No problem there. The food I got from Buffalo Wild Wings a Mushroom Siss Burger 🍔 with Cheese Curds was ABSOLUTELY DISGUSTING! My mind knew what I was supposed to be eating Burger, Cheese 🧀, Mushrooms 🍄 and Onions 🌰. But tasted Nothing But Pure SALT 🧂! Hours later I'm still Constantly Thirsty!! I won't Even Eat there Again Nor Ever Recommend Anyone!!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
Zach T
If you’d like to wait 15-20 minutes and never have a server assist you (or even get a water), come here
Service: 1
Thomas Kutzli
The manager that was on staff that night was ABSOLUTELY the best restaurant manager that we have ever had. Completely accommodated our large group of kids and went out of her way for us. Thank you.
BEWARE they might tip themselves if you leave the tip amount unmarked.
I was overcharged almost double my order amount. I have called 3 times now and even left my number for the manager and have yet to hear about a refund on my order. This is beyond ridiculous as my order was on 9/8/2025 and I called the day after to get this issue fixed.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
If you're looking for amazing service with a side of wow, then you need to ask for Lindsie . From the moment she walked up to our table, she brought the perfect blend of charm, confidence, and total professionalism — not to mention she’s absolutely stunning. Lindsie knows how to work a room, handle a crowd, and keep every drink filled without missing a beat.
She was quick with the recommendations (all spot-on), had a killer smile that lit up the place, and managed to keep the vibe friendly, flirty, and totally on point. You can tell she loves what she does, and it shows in every detail — from remembering our names to making sure we had everything we needed before we even asked.
Bottom line: Lindsie isn’t just serving — she’s slaying.
10/10 would come back just for her. 🔥
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
I had a very disappointing experience at the Buffalo Wild Wings in Coldwater, Michigan. My order was prepared incorrectly not once, but three separate times before it was finally corrected. This shows a clear breakdown in communication between the wait staff and the kitchen. While mistakes can happen, the repeated errors and lack of attention to detail reflected poorly on both the service and overall management of this location. As a customer, I expect accuracy and professionalism, and unfortunately, this visit did not meet even the most basic standards.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Ruff. Did me dirty on my fried pickles. They were so not done. Food was cold. Made my girl wait 15 for a refill and when she got her drink, it wasn't even the right drink.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Disappointed with food, prices, and kitchen! Overpriced wings (traditional and boneless) for a plate of tiny wings. Asked for celery with both meals and they delivered 3 pieces plus threw in some carrots! Bartender was mortified with the plate and got more. Apparently they were running out at 6:30pm. We waited almost an hour for our food - wings! Place was not busy (Sunday over holiday). Heard staff saying kitchen crew walked outside to take a break - they were over worked! Only good was our Bartender on her first night by herself. Not coming back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Terrible service. The staff have no idea what they are doing
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Had half restaurant empty. Was told they couldn’t even seat us because they couldn’t keep up. There was also a family of four with two little kids that’s was also refused service. As well as a couple that’s was refused as well. Horrible management and service. So we went to Applebees and got seated right away with excellent seevice
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Waitress was friendly! As busy as it was she did an awsome job!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lindsie was amazing ! We are traveling back home and she had such an approachable smile. She took great care of us always checking in. She is a person who will build long lasting relationships here.
Hands down she is an asset to this team.
We live almost 5 hours away and she made us feel at home !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I usually never leave a 1 star review but I can confidently say that I was highly disappointed in the service today. We got sat down right away but waited 20 min to get approached by someone to take our drink/food order. I’d understand if the restaurant was busy but it was slow so I didn’t understand what the issue was.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
The food is always good when I visit but the service has something to be desired. Servers are slow and inattentive where there are less than 5 tables filled. The kicker is then a 20% tip is expected! Yeah, The food is not worth the cost.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Cat was our server and her mood was quite irritable. After waiting for about 10 minutes for menus, she proceeded to slam our drinks down. It took about 15 minutes for our food to arrive, and then on top of that, we didn't even get silverware or napkins until I walked up amd asked for them.
When I got the bill, I realized she had neglected to tell us of the unchanged for our appetizer. Once I asked for change of my bill, she slammed my change down and walked away with barely a word.
I have worked as a server for a long time, this was abysmal to say the least.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
I ordered take Out via Uber Eats. No problem there. The food I got from Buffalo Wild Wings a Mushroom Siss Burger 🍔 with Cheese Curds was ABSOLUTELY DISGUSTING! My mind knew what I was supposed to be eating Burger, Cheese 🧀, Mushrooms 🍄 and Onions 🌰. But tasted Nothing But Pure SALT 🧂! Hours later I'm still Constantly Thirsty!! I won't Even Eat there Again Nor Ever Recommend Anyone!!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
If you’d like to wait 15-20 minutes and never have a server assist you (or even get a water), come here
Service: 1
The manager that was on staff that night was ABSOLUTELY the best restaurant manager that we have ever had.
Completely accommodated our large group of kids and went out of her way for us. Thank you.
Loading...