Never Forgotten Bakery

Me and my cousin's just randomly stopped in while across the street for a funeral - and like we were shocked. Everything is so cute and yummy! Like I've been to random small bakeries where everything tastes to plain or the same - not here. 10/10 highly recommended the st Louis gooey cake!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Gooey Butter Cake

I worked with the bakery via email to create a custom large order of their German-style pretzels and not only were they extremely delicious, but the ease of working with Michelle and the team at Never Forgotten was great! Everyone has positive reviews for the pretzels. We will be ordering again!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nice bakery . Helpful and Pleasant staff.
Chocolate cupcakes delish. The bran and raisin muffins are the best! Carrot cupcakes also good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

The carrot cake was excellent. Very moist. I also bought a loaf of Old World Bread which is also good. The store was clean, the staff very friendly and knowledgeable. I will be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This place was recommended to me for it's pretzels. I grew up in Germany and was looking for something that had a more authentic German or Amish taste. It's not easy to find good pretzels - and places like Auntie Anne's and Wetzel's are too Americanized, that is like saying Olive Garden has authentic Italian food. My daughter and I made it minutes before closing and picked up a couple of their uniquely shaped pretzels. To my surprise, they were delicious and hit the spot. We haven't tried any other products here, but really like the pretzels. The only downside is that we went in the other day and learned the pretzels are only available on Saturdays.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I fumbled the ball on ordering a cake in time for my daughter’s graduation. After realizing my mistake I called a few great places who were of course, booked. And Never Forgotten said hold. Talked to the Baker and made it happen including an additional request for two trays of mixed little pastries brownies cookies and one with raspberry. They are amazing at this shop where I love to snatch the infamous old world bread right off the shelf. Long story short, everything was perfect for my grad and we even called to pick it up a little late-it was “sure thing” in response to every request from start to finish. I’ll be stopping by soon to thank you again. You really make delicious Everything! I now am in love with two bakeries. Heaven help me!

This is a hidden gem of a bakery! The owners and staff are wonderful and friendly, and it’s my go-to for holiday treats. They always have new creations in the cases, but my favorite is the carrot cake cupcakes. The frosting is delectable, and I like that they offer the cupcakes either with or without nuts. Prices are very very reasonable, too. Highly recommended stopping in!

I discovered this bakery through Too Good To Go and I’m so glad I did!
The Garlic Everything Bread was absolutely delicious—flavorful, fresh, and perfectly baked. I also tried the Orange Cranberry Muffin and the Banana Oat Bran Muffin, and both were excellent. The muffins were just right—not overly sweet, but full of flavor and moist.
The staff were friendly and welcoming, which made the experience even better. I’ll definitely be back to try more. Highly recommend if you’re in the area and craving fresh, tasty baked goods!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This place is a true gem. They have so many great things that you can just pop in and buy, along with an amazing and affordable menu of cakes and cookies you can order. I got a tray of brownies and cookies for a work party, so good and at a great price. I also grabbed a bagel while I was picking up the cookies. The bagel was so delicious I will be dreaming about it.

Amazing authentic brezel!

We are so lucky to have this bakery in Farmington.
Freshly baked bread and treats and kind service all around!

Family owned wonderful atmosphere! Everything I have bought from there has been amazing. Would highly recommend ❤️

They supplied cookie platers for our event and I couldn't ask for a better experience. The printed cookies were a hit.

You’re reading this to hear others experience with this bakery. I just had an Apple Oat Bran muffin and Lemon Blueberry Scone. Each one was so flavorful and moist. Absolutely delicious. And the price is better than other bakeries in the area.
This will definitely be my new go-to bakery.

The muffins are fantastic!