Most delicious pizza in Glen Arbor if you like a Detroit-style pizza. Highly recommend their ice cream and dairy free ice cream options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nomin Erdene
Music choice was so good and pizza was the best. BYO PIZZA was very felixaeble and servers were so cute. Ice cream has so many flavors and strawberry cheesecake was the best.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Claire
Absolutely do not order from here if you want to plan on receiving your food. Ordered a pizza at 6:20pm for my family and paid in full. The order pick-up time was listed on the receipt as 7:30pm. We arrived at 7:20pm to pick up the food and the business had closed. The hours are 12-8. We then stopped by The Mill (same owners) to ask what happened and the manager informed us they closed early because it was slow. Closed early because is was slow but did not fulfill orders paid for in full, made no attempt to contact the customers, or issue refunds. Head to another establishment that actually considers their customers.
Don Goforth
Took an hour to get a pizza. Employees couldn't care less. Pizza was soggy after a 10 min drive. Only reason we came was because bear paw pizza was closed. Definitely avoid
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Skip Bourdo
Ordered hours in advance and got a call that they ran out of ingredients 10 minutes before the order was supposed to be ready. This is the second time Millie’s disappointed this year. Had to scramble for Pizza and Cavanaugh’s. Millie’s doesn’t know how to handle the summer traffic. How do you run out of ingredients at a Pizza Place? Bring back the old owners of Riverside Pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 1
Lily
The pizza was SO good! Marguerite helped us and was super kind. Beautiful view from restaurant and we were able to sit outside.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sydney Flaherty
Great focaccia crust also a wonderful location!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Disney23 T
Done eat here. They have a sign outside that says pizza, sandwiches, salads and ice cream. However the day we stopped in they were only serving individual pizza slices - two options, cheese or cheese and pepperoni. And there was none ready. Not sure how that happens. Took ten minutes. That being said, we paid $5 a slice for something that was maybe worth $3. About 5”x5” slices, so small. If there was sauce on it I couldn’t find it. A total disappointment.
Food: 1
Cassie Ziegler
Our first pizza was inedible so we had to send it back, something I hate doing and never do! But for 30 dollars we had to. The man making our pizza was so rude and mean to us. He made the second pizza incorrectly out of spite just to upset us. It was overpriced, undercooked and just a bad experience overall. The only redeeming thing was the sweet woman working behind the counter.
Food: 1
Dee
Pizza on the picnic table is perfect. Pizza squares and salad delicious
Millie’s pizza was really good. We ordered the Roman Millie (pepperoni pizza). The location is nice to sit and eat outside next to the water.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Cheryl
We had high hopes for Millie’s while visiting Glen Arbor, but left pretty disappointed. The pizza had barely any sauce or cheese—more like focaccia with a couple toppings than an actual pizza. For what they charge, it really missed the mark.
The service didn’t help either. Staff seemed short and uninterested, which made the whole experience feel uninviting.
It’s a cute location and maybe others have had better luck, but based on our visit, it just didn’t live up to expectations.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jeffrey
The pizza is decent unfortunately the cheese bread sucks. Horrible wait times almost 2 hours when they said 50 minutes. Never again garbage don’t waste your time or money go to Empire. Here is the cheese bread.
Amber Coughlin
We ordered and paid for our food and the server never told us to wait or have a seat and they will bring it. After waiting 30 minutes we asked about our food, they finally bring it to us burnt, one tiny slice with nearly no toppings. One small basil leaf thrown in the box must have been the “pesto”? No sauce and nearly no cheese. This experience was highly disappointing and a waste of money. We will now need to find dinner elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Cassandra Robinson
If you are looking for Detroit style, this isn’t it. The dough is more dense and undercooked , it’s very doughy. We also asked for extra crispy. The toppings were good though, but we would not purchase again or reccomend
Most delicious pizza in Glen Arbor if you like a Detroit-style pizza. Highly recommend their ice cream and dairy free ice cream options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Music choice was so good and pizza was the best. BYO PIZZA was very felixaeble and servers were so cute. Ice cream has so many flavors and strawberry cheesecake was the best.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely do not order from here if you want to plan on receiving your food. Ordered a pizza at 6:20pm for my family and paid in full. The order pick-up time was listed on the receipt as 7:30pm. We arrived at 7:20pm to pick up the food and the business had closed. The hours are 12-8. We then stopped by The Mill (same owners) to ask what happened and the manager informed us they closed early because it was slow. Closed early because is was slow but did not fulfill orders paid for in full, made no attempt to contact the customers, or issue refunds. Head to another establishment that actually considers their customers.
Took an hour to get a pizza. Employees couldn't care less. Pizza was soggy after a 10 min drive. Only reason we came was because bear paw pizza was closed. Definitely avoid
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ordered hours in advance and got a call that they ran out of ingredients 10 minutes before the order was supposed to be ready. This is the second time Millie’s disappointed this year. Had to scramble for Pizza and Cavanaugh’s. Millie’s doesn’t know how to handle the summer traffic. How do you run out of ingredients at a Pizza Place? Bring back the old owners of Riverside Pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 1
The pizza was SO good! Marguerite helped us and was super kind. Beautiful view from restaurant and we were able to sit outside.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great focaccia crust also a wonderful location!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Done eat here. They have a sign outside that says pizza, sandwiches, salads and ice cream. However the day we stopped in they were only serving individual pizza slices - two options, cheese or cheese and pepperoni. And there was none ready. Not sure how that happens. Took ten minutes. That being said, we paid $5 a slice for something that was maybe worth $3. About 5”x5” slices, so small. If there was sauce on it I couldn’t find it. A total disappointment.
Food: 1
Our first pizza was inedible so we had to send it back, something I hate doing and never do! But for 30 dollars we had to. The man making our pizza was so rude and mean to us. He made the second pizza incorrectly out of spite just to upset us. It was overpriced, undercooked and just a bad experience overall. The only redeeming thing was the sweet woman working behind the counter.
Food: 1
Pizza on the picnic table is perfect. Pizza squares and salad delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Millie’s pizza was really good. We ordered the Roman Millie (pepperoni pizza). The location is nice to sit and eat outside next to the water.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
We had high hopes for Millie’s while visiting Glen Arbor, but left pretty disappointed. The pizza had barely any sauce or cheese—more like focaccia with a couple toppings than an actual pizza. For what they charge, it really missed the mark.
The service didn’t help either. Staff seemed short and uninterested, which made the whole experience feel uninviting.
It’s a cute location and maybe others have had better luck, but based on our visit, it just didn’t live up to expectations.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
The pizza is decent unfortunately the cheese bread sucks. Horrible wait times almost 2 hours when they said 50 minutes. Never again garbage don’t waste your time or money go to Empire. Here is the cheese bread.
We ordered and paid for our food and the server never told us to wait or have a seat and they will bring it. After waiting 30 minutes we asked about our food, they finally bring it to us burnt, one tiny slice with nearly no toppings. One small basil leaf thrown in the box must have been the “pesto”? No sauce and nearly no cheese. This experience was highly disappointing and a waste of money. We will now need to find dinner elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
If you are looking for Detroit style, this isn’t it. The dough is more dense and undercooked , it’s very doughy. We also asked for extra crispy. The toppings were good though, but we would not purchase again or reccomend
Loading...