The Pizza Mill

8485 Holton Rd a, Holton
(231) 821-9991

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Juanita Palmer Hovey

It is amazing food, very friendly staff & a warm welcome place to go!!! Loved it!!!

Tiffany Marshall

Our waitress was one of the best servers that I've ever had. The pizza is always good.
THE OTHER FOOD IS TERRIBLE!!!
Overcooked, extremely small portions and no seasoning. I thought the size of my brother in law's perch was a joke!! Each piece is about a bite. The poor guy had six bites if fish and about ten fries.
I don't know the name of our server, she was working Wednesday evening, two days ago. She is excellent at what she does and is very nice!

Renee Brinkman

Parents ordered food tonight, 3 perch meals. As my dad said, those poor fish died twice. Everything was BURNT to a crisp and absolutely NOT EDIBLE. I thought this place couldn't get any worse but yet again, they proved me wrong. ANDREA'S PIZZA IN GRANT is the best!

Food: 1

Pam Bergey

Had dinner at the Pizza Mill tonight. The food was very good. I had a sub with sweet potato fries and my son had the chicken bowl. He said the chicken strips were the best he’s had. The staff was very friendly and helpful. We almost let an empty parking lot scare us away. I’m definitely glad we decided to go in. Worth the drive.

Russell Burgdorf III

I've tried 5 different times calling earlier every time in the last 2 weeks and they won't even do a pickup order at 730 when they close at 8. Either change your posted business hours or serve your customers until the business hours you have posted. What pizza place closes at 7 pm? This is terrible service.

Janice Karlovich

The best pizza I’ve had in a while! Great service too! Very friendly and spotless inside. Not very busy on a Tuesday night, but so glad we stopped here.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Great Pizza

Teresa

Convenient restaurant, good food, pleasant staff

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: White Fish

Jana Larabee

Only one waitress on a Friday night....no plates or silverware brought to the table, had to ask and wait for service....no refills.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Great Pizza

Stephen “Chewie” Hanna

This pizza is always a hit. Their salads are as big as your chest (forget your head). Servers are usually distracted by either too many tables or answering the phone so refills aren't quick and the orders don't always come out in the right order (such as appetizers getting to your table before your entrée). Dining room is properly spaced so you dont feel like you're sitting on top of other tables when it's busy. We make the drive to go here usually at least once a month.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Great Pizza

Patricia Clark

We drive 25 minutes to get pizza here because we like it best in the area.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Barbie Bower Plecas

We have always had good service and hot, delicious food. the prices are very reasonable.

Jed Hildman

Very disappointed tonight in The PIZZA Mill. Not in the oven long enough and when we told the cashier, she didn't do anything besides tell us the ovens are set at specific settings which we understood but at that point she could have put the pizza back in the oven for a few more minutes but she chose not to. Then we called once we got home and are a piece, the crust tasted chewy like rubber from not being in the oven long enough, same person answered and said the exact same thing again about the oven settings and wasn't going to help again. Very disappointed because we go there often.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Denine Burns

Well they could make a new pizza for their customer when they burn it. But no they tell their customer you have to pay half for another one. That is not good business....

phil doran

Had a Sub there and it was pretty good waitress was nice and polite

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Sandwich

Kevin Massie

We had a large group (14people). Service was great food was very good!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Great Pizza

Loading...