Toarmina’s Pizza New Boston

Best pizza in town

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza, Cheese Bread

So about six months ago I left a five-star review for one of my all-time favorite pizza joints. I have to edit this review now, but I feel like I need to preface this by saying that this really hits me in the heart. I’m sad I have to do this because the people who work there are typically pleasant and wonderful humans. I’ve been a Toarmina’s guy for most of my adult life. Owners: if you feel like I’m telling some truths here, please take this criticism as constructive and maybe re-examine some common practices.

The pizza has gone way downhill; like WAY downhill. I’m not talking one specific pie here. The thin crust is a greasy, floppy mess. The regular pizza is doughy and undercooked. The “extra” cheese barely covers a slice. And maybe this is a personal thing, but the flavored crust is wholly unnoticeable. Also, just a minor gripe, but the pies are never sliced all the way. I have to bring these things home and cut them myself. Really, your only saving grace is that giant, 24-inch bad boy…but even that has gone sub-par. I don’t know what specifically has changed, but it just isn’t working. You have to know when you see these things that you wouldn’t be thrilled about eating them yourself, and the fix really could be as simple as that. Take a look while you’re cutting only 75% of the pie; does it look like a good pizza? If it doesn’t, consider the hit to your reputation every time one of these goes out your door.

Again: great people. You guys are not just a staple pizza joint in the area, you’re one of the staple DINNER spots in the area. I hope this helps motivate you to get back on track!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

We ordered the kids a LG peperoni and cheese pizza and a regular cheese bread. Those were great but the pizza we ordered for ourselves was not good. We ordered a Detroit Deep Dish and it looked nothing like the picture. It was burnt and so spicy we couldn't eat it. It was very disappointing.

Food: 2

Our go-to, reliable town pizza place

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We have ordered from here no less than 2 to 3 times a month for the past 2 years. I've left good reviews and have even called the store to thank them when we were received our orders. There have been many times when The order wasn't the best but we never complained. And there have been many many times that the extra sauces we ordered and paid for were not with the order. And again we never complained. But this time the sauces we're not there so that item could not be eaten by that person. So we called and we're told they credit us but they would not deliver them because they were too busy. So I asked for a credit on the cheese bread and was told no they wouldn't do that. if we hadn't already waited over an hour for our food I would have drove it back and got a refund. We dealt with the Torminas on Cherry Hill in Westland for for over 25 years And always had amazing service. I guess they valued their regular customers a little bit more. We will not be ordering from this store again and that bums me out. but I would rather drive to the Wayne road location then support a business that doesn't appreciate or value their customers.

The pizza was so good. And the people are so nice there

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great pizza, very rarely got my order wrong, and a cozy quaint shop

They wouldn't honor an online coupon that was on their website and their explanation was vague and not kind about it. The bottom line is honor the coupon or change the website. Food was good however.

Always good

Always good pizza and nice staff!

Can't brag on this place enough!
We ordered 4 of the large party pizzas and 3 party salads for my daughters birthday and they were a hit! When I called to place the order, they were so helpful with recommendations and options. The quality was awesome and really delicious, especially when somet8mes the party pizzas are less quality.
Highly recommend coming here for any occasion. Thank you for making our day so seamless!

Good was gross. It all tasted like cardboard. No flavor who makes a chicken parm and doesn’t use breaded chicken. 0 out of ten. It’s called salt invest in a bit. It would help tremendously

Offer a take out or delivery service. Have lobby still set up like covid era. Good pizza, and at a good price

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

This small business delivers friendly fast service! They are magic when you call they know the order and have it ready at super speed everytime! The biggest slice of happiness around! My family always enjoy pizza ? night from our favorite place. Bonus they support my sons football team! Go Huron Jr Chiefs ? ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza, Fish

This is my experience from 08/05/2024. The staff was very kind, and attentive. I have no complaints about the service at all.

The pizzas (two 16" super deluxe w/double cheese) weren't fit to eat. None of my guests could handle eating it. I spent around $50.00 on these pizzas and now have to throw away 1.5 of them because I don't have time to take them in.

It seemed like maybe the ingredients were a little past their shelf life or something. It may not even be the pizzerias fault. It very well could be because of their supplier's lack of quality control. I just don't know. All I know is that what I got just wasn't fit to eat and I had always loved Toarmina's Pizza.

All I can suggest is that management will pay more attention to the quality of stuff that they have in inventory, because there was nothing OK about those pizzas.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 5