Sheldons Street Pizza

3767 S Baldwin Rd, Lake Orion
(248) 791-7111

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jeanine Marie Haradine

I was in town last weekend for my grandsons birthday party. we had Sheldon's Pizza and it was excellent! Definitely one of the best pizzas I've ever had!

Patrick Dean

Received a phone call from Andrew at the Commerce township Michigan location. Andrew called to let me know that they forgot to give me a side order of sauce. He let me know that he was sorry and that he took the price of the sauce off of my card. Andrew thanks for the honestly and the customer service. I've never had a reasturant call and admit an accident. And yes Andrew evening we order was great as usual. Sheldons is are new go to in Commerce.

kim przeworski

I usually get my favorite Greek salad here bc it's so fresh and the dressing is to die for but got a box of fries last night...OMG!! Highly recommend. Crispy on the outside and soft and flavorful on the inside. U can't find these just anywhere! Always delicious treats like cookies for the sweet tooth!! ❤️🍟🥗

Mike Ashley

Excellent quality and delicious- family owned and run. You can tell they are passionate about their products! Solid deep dish too.

Austin Hunter

Amazing service and food. Perfect thin crust pizza. Very Kind staff and owner I give them all the business I can and you should too.

Cortney Leigh

Fresh, hot, and packed with flavor, Sheldon’s Street Pizza totally hit the spot. The thin crust is a perfect NY-style throwback I’ve been craving, and the breadsticks are fluffy carb heaven. You can really taste the quality in everything. Highly recommend!

KnowOneGood

Super friendly and accommodating staff.

Travis D

Awesome 👏 pizza 🍕

Ammar Arshad

Best wings I’ve ever had especially the honey siracha sauce nothing beats it! The owner is super nice the staff is friendly it’s family owned business and everything is great! 100 percent you should go

Erica Jones-Rose

Easily one of the best pizza experiences I’ve had in a long time. Met the owner, who couldn’t have been nicer — super friendly, clearly passionate, and proud of the food he’s serving. He even offered to make any style of pizza, which just shows the level of care and confidence in his product.

We started by ordering a calzone to split and try — and it was so good, we ate it in the car and immediately turned around and ordered a pizza. No hesitation. The crust on the pizza was unreal — perfectly pillowy and crispy at the same time — and every bite made it clear they’re using high-quality ingredients.

We demolished the entire pizza in the car, too. Couldn’t even wait to get home. That really says it all. Can’t wait to come back.

Heather Chapel

Excellent service AND the pizza is delish… not greasy! I just tried it for the first time and is worth it!
We are getting so sick of greasy Jets pizza - Sheldons dough is yummy! I don’t usually eat the crust, but I do eat their crust. And their mini breadsticks are worth a try!

Michele Millar

First time trying Sheldon’s. Best pizza I have had in the area

Haley Watson

Man, this pizza is unmatched!!! My only complaint is that I wish there was one in Macomb County, closer to me :) Sheldon is almost always there when I come in and is always so personable and friendly! 10/10 would recommend

Brandon Williams

Great employees amazing food

Mike Birch

Excellent pizza and delicious fresh salads.

Loading...