Whistle Stop

N2190 US-41, Menominee
(906) 864-2664

Recent Reviews

Maddie Golueke

Slow service from the beginning. Ordered prime rib, after 25 minutes they came to tell me they were all out… So I ordered a ribeye. The two ribeyes were ordered medium rare & rare. Both were cooked very well done, no flavor either. Steak was terrible. Told waitress they were not cooked to order and not even a sorry. One customer told me not to be upset I didn’t get the prime rib, because it was also bad.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

M B

Great food. Awesome staff. Will come again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ribs 2 Piece Chicken Twice Baked Potatoe, Soup N Salad

Tom Nuernberg

The absolute best place for dinner.incredible keep up the good

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sharon K.

My steak I ask for medium rare but it felt like it was just super raw and undercooked - I ate it and no digestive issues but it was cold and not how I asked for it at all - the salad from the salad bar was nice- the soup was beef barley vegetable too salty - and dessert was cookies - I didn't know what to expect when I ate here - my date drank a lot and I didn't - the special we got was a tenderloin steak that came with 2 extra large jumbo shrimp on Alfredo pasta - the sauce on the pasta was mild. I would have gotten the fried chicken instead because it looks like a light batter here at the next table and seemed to look nice but it's ok - I at least tried ..gave this place a shot

Bonnie Pottratz

THEY ARE THE BEST RESTAURANT AROUND! GREAT FOOD BEST PEOPLE YOU EVER WANT TO MEET NEVER A BAD MEAL! IF YOU HAVE NEVER BEEN HERE YOU ARE MISSING OUT ON ONE OF THE FINEST SUPPER CLUB AROUND! RATED A PERFECT 10

Adam Biemeret

What an awesome supper club! They were very friendly and the salad bar was fresh and delicious. The prime rib was amazing! The prices were great as well for the portions they served. It was a fantastic dining experience, and we hope to make the trek back someday!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stephanie Fox

Pros: Food was well seasoned/prepared. Lots of appealing menu items. Nice variance of items at the salad bar. It’s good supper club type food.Cons: Atmosphere is nothing to get excited about. Service was okay.I’d stop again if i was in the area.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

Juliette M

I come here whenever I’m in town visiting family. The food is great and extremely reasonable. The best part is the salad bar which has real greens instead of iceberg lettuce. The fish is outstanding and is a go-to for me. Great environment and excellent service.

Jeff Sydow

Hands down the best prime rib I have had. The whole experience was top notch! The staff was very friendly and treated us like family.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Helen Evans-Lecker

The food was excellent; the calamari was to die for.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Zendeeno

I went to a RAVE here in 2001 or 2002. The south side of the building had an amazing venue with tremendous sound that moved all who came. It was a really nice RAVE and a great time. And then walked outside to the northside to get a drink. Lol. Good times!

Gary Richel

Best food in the entire area.I wish they were open all week instead of Thursday thru Sunday.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Hope Borski

I ordered the tenderloin and shrimp scampi. The steak was made just as I had asked, but it lacked flavor. The shrimp scampi surprised me. I've never seen shrimp scampi served with rice?

Stacy J

The inside is very nice, looks to have a great salade bar, clean & fully stocked large bar area. We live up the road & had never tried it so decided to give it a try. Like last reviewer said it's confusing when you walk in, there's a half wall & dining room on left & on right the large bar area. 3 waitresses passed us as we hung in entrance area trying to figure out what to do & none said a word. I asked bar tender if we seat ourselves & she explained you have a drink at bar, she gives you menu & when the waitress comes she will take your order & give you a table number, she warned us it was a bit of a wait for a table but she didn't know how long. We waited maybe 20 mins so not bad. We ordered the fish fry specials, no one said if salade bar/soup included she just asked how we wanted our potatoe. We sat for for over 25 mins before another waitress asked if we wanted waters which we had asked first waitress for when she took our order. 10mins later we got very small glasses of water (think bathroom Dixie cup size). It took 40mins after ordering to get our one piece of fish each with a bowl of twice baked insides. My mahi mahi fish was so over cooked the sides were brown & jerky hard and center very dry. I didn't have salade bar because we didn't know if it was included & we didn't see a waitress for 30mins & we figured food had to be coming by than. There were 6 tables & 5 servers BTW. Prices were $17 & $19, I saw lots of people taking home left overs so maybe we just got a bad meal. Sadly we won't be back. Waitress came to collect our plates & gave us check, no interaction between. One waitress in a dress interacted alot with her table & even offered other tables help but no other staff interacted other than between themselves or seemed friendly (remember 6 tables, 5 servers so not swamped). It's sad because it seems to have great potential and while it wasn't absolutelty the worst experience ive had it wasn't worth a repeat.

Kim Smith

Great food and service! Ribs and fantail shrimp combo was delicious. Very nice little salad bar, very fresh.

Load More