Beer Church Brewing Co.
24 S Whittaker St, New Buffalo
(269) 586-3864
Menu
Photos
+97 photos
+96 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
The beer is good, the pizza is good, service is pretty good. $25 for a carryout 4-pack seems a bit much. And then asking for a tip on that carryout that I got out of the fridge seems a bit beyond the pale. Their beer and pizza are good, as I said, but there's a lot of good beer and pizza in the world. Would come back for another try, but won't be grabbing anymore beer on the way out.
Beer church is a neat atmosphere and has a lot of seating. Their beers are very good. The pizza is amazing 80% of the time, and then 20% of the time it is sloppy and undercooked. When you mention to the staff the same delicious pizza you order every time is undercooked, they make you feel like it’s your fault. They halfheartedly offer to remake the pizza but you leave feeling confused and disappointed. I would recommend because MOSTLY, it is great. But if you are the receiver...
With beers and food named for biblical characters, as well as gelato that promises to make you cry, Beer Church Brewing Co is a must-stop in the quality coastal town of New Buffalo, Michigan. A little more than halfway to Chicago from our hometown Grand Rapids, Michigan, this was the perfect tourist attraction to break up our trip and relieve the rigor mortis setting into our bones. Good food, good beer, darling artwork and merch, but none of the promised gelato tears, we give...
You May Also Like
Hummingbird Lounge - 9 S Barton St
![]()
Cocktail Bar, Lounges
Sonny D's Bar & Grill - 1 N Whittaker St
![]()
American, Bar, Seafood