You need to order pasties ahead via their Facebook page. It's a local thing. They seem to be winding down their business unfortunately, because I asked why they don't make them every day, "because we don't want to" was the answer.The pasties were delicious ($6 -2022), but they only make one variety (beef,rutabaga,carrot and onion?), the crust is perfectly flaky). I got there early and didn't know about pre orders, but I was able to put in an order and pick up an hour later. But by then the muffins were gone, though they did have a couple of cookie varieties left.I should have taken a picture, but I was hungry!
Barbara Peterson
Good pasties and good crust as well! You should also try a bag or two of cookies...yum!
Bill Stuber
Best pasty I will ever have. Thanks to the local named Pete who I met at Stubbs Bar
April Ann Harsvick
Absolutely love getting a warm pasty and fresh baked goods.
Francesca Jean
I love visiting this little shop when I am home. Best pasties you can buy in Ontonagon and the owners are so friendly!
2Cindy Snow
Easily the best pasties around. Traditional option is standard. Sometimes a nontraditional flavor combination is offered in addition to the traditional one. Absolutely no gristle. Fresh bakery items are often available as well. Mmm...my mouth waters!
Tim Palenske
Great people and food
Teresa Bertossi
Great cookies, and really wonderful people, I enjoyed my visit to the Cookie Store!
Kerry Dennison
a very hard company to get hold of I tried to call them twice and find out their hours of business so far my multiple calls have not been returned I will give them another try I had got one of their products from a third-party they gave it to me and they recommended that I try them
Lynn Hoeppner
Great tasting pasties - get them hot or frozen. Tasty cookies and muffins. I go there whenever I"m camping at Ontonagon. The lady is so sweet.. They are open Saturdays and Mondays. Worth the stop!
Love this place!!! Great people and pasties! The veggie are my favorite but I'll eat anything they make! I stock my freezer every year...
Sandy Walker
Best local pasties....and the best cookies! I'm going to try the fruit pies this summer.....See you in July!
Tinka Johnson
Support this local bakery. These are the nicest people. My mom purchased four dozen cookies for me. The Little Cookie Store shipped them to me in South Carolina. Not one cookie was broken. All four flavors were delicious. Soft and chewy. This is a great hometown business worth our support.
You need to order pasties ahead via their Facebook page. It's a local thing. They seem to be winding down their business unfortunately, because I asked why they don't make them every day, "because we don't want to" was the answer.The pasties were delicious ($6 -2022), but they only make one variety (beef,rutabaga,carrot and onion?), the crust is perfectly flaky). I got there early and didn't know about pre orders, but I was able to put in an order and pick up an hour later. But by then the muffins were gone, though they did have a couple of cookie varieties left.I should have taken a picture, but I was hungry!
Good pasties and good crust as well! You should also try a bag or two of cookies...yum!
Best pasty I will ever have. Thanks to the local named Pete who I met at Stubbs Bar
Absolutely love getting a warm pasty and fresh baked goods.
I love visiting this little shop when I am home. Best pasties you can buy in Ontonagon and the owners are so friendly!
Easily the best pasties around. Traditional option is standard. Sometimes a nontraditional flavor combination is offered in addition to the traditional one. Absolutely no gristle. Fresh bakery items are often available as well. Mmm...my mouth waters!
Great people and food
Great cookies, and really wonderful people, I enjoyed my visit to the Cookie Store!
a very hard company to get hold of I tried to call them twice and find out their hours of business so far my multiple calls have not been returned I will give them another try I had got one of their products from a third-party they gave it to me and they recommended that I try them
Great tasting pasties - get them hot or frozen. Tasty cookies and muffins. I go there whenever I"m camping at Ontonagon. The lady is so sweet.. They are open Saturdays and Mondays. Worth the stop!
Restaurantji Recommends
Love this place!!! Great people and pasties! The veggie are my favorite but I'll eat anything they make! I stock my freezer every year...
Best local pasties....and the best cookies! I'm going to try the fruit pies this summer.....See you in July!
Support this local bakery. These are the nicest people. My mom purchased four dozen cookies for me. The Little Cookie Store shipped them to me in South Carolina. Not one cookie was broken. All four flavors were delicious. Soft and chewy. This is a great hometown business worth our support.