We loved the pie. Best pie I've ever eaten by a million miles. More importantly I loved the service. Crystal and the crew are very helpful and knowledgeable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pamela Nicholson
The pies are the best ever we had the Dutch apple pie and the cherry pie very great crust my friend bought the pies for Thanksgiving dinner
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shawn Awesome
Friendly service, but French silk pie was terrible
E B
Great service and a fantastic product! Grateful you’re in Oxford!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A E
We stopped by on a Saturday and found out they are closed on Saturdays but opened on Sundays. So we came back on Sunday only to find out they won't have our favorite pie (Banana cream Pie) made for another 8 or 9 days? Odd. I guess it has something to do with production. We did purchase a few things but stock was limited when we were there. We did enjoy our items though.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Brandon Colwell
Stopped in for a sweet treat and got a chocolate cream pie. Caitie recommended the slice and surprised me by how delicious it was. Never had a slice of pie that good before!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
NO SHOW
Great place we go there quite often to get pies and what not? I can never eat a whole pie myself and I’ve always wanted to try the banana split and the banana cream and Izzy was nice enough to show me a piece of banana split and banana cream pie so after I had both of my pot pies, I ate one of my banana split pies and it was the best All the food is great anyways Izzy is very helpful and all about the customer experience and satisfaction. Thank you again. Everything was great banana split. I might have to get a whole one next time.
Matthew Kephart
My wife contacted the store yesterday not knowing they weren't open, yet. Crystal was kind enough to answer and was so incredibly helpful, friendly and kind. Their baked goods truly set the bar of excellence high and the customer service is beyond all expectations. Thank you and thank you!
Grace Martin
There’s something so special about the pies here—it’s like they’re made with love, sunshine, and a little bit of magic. Krystal is an absolute gem. You can feel her warmth the moment you walk through the door, and every pie she makes is a reflection of the care and heart she puts into this place.
Krystal was extremely accommodating of our large pie order for our wedding. She even moved the day the pies would usually be made so they would be as fresh as possible! We are so thankful to Achatz Pie for making our special day that much more magical.
Tammie laboda
I love their food, and everything the owners stand for. I work for a non-profit and they are always donating to our cause.
Art Morley
Super nice people always accommodating with outstanding pies.
Brittany Davis
SO GOOD! We will be back to try more flavors of pie for sure!
Brian Nordin
Top-quality pies with fantastic ingredients and fantastic crusts. Way better than your typical "store-bought" pies. Plus the option to pick up some ice cream from Cook's Farm Dairy makes this place a real treat!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cherry Double Crust, Apple Pie
4 berry pie is the best
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Apple Pie, Cherry Crumb
We loved the pie. Best pie I've ever eaten by a million miles. More importantly I loved the service. Crystal and the crew are very helpful and knowledgeable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pies are the best ever we had the Dutch apple pie and the cherry pie very great crust my friend bought the pies for Thanksgiving dinner
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Friendly service, but French silk pie was terrible
Great service and a fantastic product! Grateful you’re in Oxford!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We stopped by on a Saturday and found out they are closed on Saturdays but opened on Sundays. So we came back on Sunday only to find out they won't have our favorite pie (Banana cream Pie) made for another 8 or 9 days? Odd. I guess it has something to do with production. We did purchase a few things but stock was limited when we were there. We did enjoy our items though.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Stopped in for a sweet treat and got a chocolate cream pie. Caitie recommended the slice and surprised me by how delicious it was. Never had a slice of pie that good before!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great place we go there quite often to get pies and what not? I can never eat a whole pie myself and I’ve always wanted to try the banana split and the banana cream and Izzy was nice enough to show me a piece of banana split and banana cream pie so after I had both of my pot pies, I ate one of my banana split pies and it was the best All the food is great anyways Izzy is very helpful and all about the customer experience and satisfaction. Thank you again. Everything was great banana split. I might have to get a whole one next time.
My wife contacted the store yesterday not knowing they weren't open, yet. Crystal was kind enough to answer and was so incredibly helpful, friendly and kind. Their baked goods truly set the bar of excellence high and the customer service is beyond all expectations. Thank you and thank you!
There’s something so special about the pies here—it’s like they’re made with love, sunshine, and a little bit of magic. Krystal is an absolute gem. You can feel her warmth the moment you walk through the door, and every pie she makes is a reflection of the care and heart she puts into this place.
Restaurantji Recommends
Krystal was extremely accommodating of our large pie order for our wedding. She even moved the day the pies would usually be made so they would be as fresh as possible! We are so thankful to Achatz Pie for making our special day that much more magical.
I love their food, and everything the owners stand for. I work for a non-profit and they are always donating to our cause.
Super nice people always accommodating with outstanding pies.
SO GOOD! We will be back to try more flavors of pie for sure!
Top-quality pies with fantastic ingredients and fantastic crusts. Way better than your typical "store-bought" pies. Plus the option to pick up some ice cream from Cook's Farm Dairy makes this place a real treat!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cherry Double Crust, Apple Pie
Loading...