Party of 7. Everything was delicious. Server was attentive and no drinks ran dry.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeff Long
This was our second time dining at Sly’s, and once again, it did not disappoint. We came to celebrate my mom’s 78th birthday and made a reservation for six. From the moment we walked in, we were warmly greeted and promptly seated at our table.
We started with four appetizers, enjoyed drinks, entrees, and finished off with dessert—and everything was absolutely perfect. Each dish was delicious, and everyone at the table kept commenting on how amazing the food was.
The service was just as impressive. Not once did we have to ask for a drink refill or flag anyone down—the staff was attentive without being intrusive. A special touch that meant a lot: the chef even came out personally to wish my mom a happy birthday!
If you're looking for a great dining experience where the staff truly seems to enjoy what they do, Sly’s is the place to go. It really is a hidden gem. I promise—you won’t be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
flyfishguy
Little pricy for a dinner date with a couple drinks . We got the build your own seafood boil and we were not disappointed. Good amount of crab legs and shrimp , the andouille sausage they use was delicious. The girls working the dining area were very nice and personable. Specialty drinks were nicely done and delicious. We were in town for a concert, the place is very small and reservations are probably a must here . Like I said it was a bit expensive but we definitely dint feel like we got ripped off , it was high quality and delicious. We will probably make this a regular dinner when we come back for more concerts.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steven M Schmidt
Food was amazing very understaffed. It started out to be a bad experience, but then the waitress Jaden took over. I think that's how you spell her name or not but anyways she made it a good experience after she took over she held the whole ship together she deserves award or something.. I hope if we ever come back this way again she is working that's for sure. Hats off to you, Jaden.
Scott Moyer
The best crab legs I have ever had out
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Austin White
Wasn’t happy with service for how expensive it is. Definitely not worth it. Never got my drink refilled after I was told I’m getting another one. Was there 2 hours.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Annie Vanderstelt
Brought my husband to try for the first time and we loved it! A gem in paw paw
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Maureen Marthaler
A lovely place to have an up scale dinner. Four of us met prior to attending the Bodeans concert. We started with crab cakes and a bowl of the seafood chowder. The chowder was so so hearty with large pieces of lobster claws and assorted fish 2 of us ordered it as our entree. My husband had the lobster roll that he could not finish. It was that big!! Our friend ordered a pasta dish that had marinara sauce. He asked for a white wine sauce that he said was delicious! Mushroom toast was good as well !
Can't say enough about Sly's! Great place !!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dennis Holder
The service was super slow. Sat at the bar me and my girlfriend was the only two at the bar. Their was 13 customers at the tables so not crazy busy. It took 17 minutes to get our 1st cocktail that was average at best. I ordered oysters Rockefeller for a appetizer they were small but good. My girlfriend order the chicken it was a chicken thigh not a breast for 26 dollars. Way over priced for what we got. I have had their fish specials in the past and they were really good. Not sure if it was just a off night for them or what. It was average food with a high price.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
Flyfishing Zen
This place is a seafood gem for all seafood lovers but they don’t just serve seafood . They serve chicken and steak. Everything is prepared stellar. We were recently surprised that soon after we requested that chef could create a vegetarian dish which was amazing! Thank you Sly’s peeps! Also, Anne Marie thank you for all you do for us and happy b- day! You are awesome as alway and the best restaurant person I’ve ever met! Sorry, but simply best person I’ve met!!!
The decor is awesome. The vibe it gives off is what I think they were shooting for. Moving on: The waitress we had was lacking, literally had to ask for everything. Slow kitchen time, wrong food. Food was bland and mushy. Very disappointed for the amount of money I spent there. The reason I gave 3 Stars is the idea is awesome and the decor. Hopefully things change and I can come back in the future. I much rather support our local business.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 1
Brendon Zabavski
Great food and friendly service.. Highly recommended!!!
Lynn Schiller
Excellent service and wonderful food! Ann was awesome! Walleye and charbroiled oysters were amazing!
Norman Frey
Food is good. Service good. Prices are a little too high for the neighborhood and the food. Oysters Rockefeller were done wrong but tasty Cajun pasta very good Clam chowder good. As I said good food and service but 200 dollars a little too high. Lower your prices and you will be full every night. This isn’t France or New Orleans. 4stars. Norm
Party of 7. Everything was delicious. Server was attentive and no drinks ran dry.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This was our second time dining at Sly’s, and once again, it did not disappoint. We came to celebrate my mom’s 78th birthday and made a reservation for six. From the moment we walked in, we were warmly greeted and promptly seated at our table.
We started with four appetizers, enjoyed drinks, entrees, and finished off with dessert—and everything was absolutely perfect. Each dish was delicious, and everyone at the table kept commenting on how amazing the food was.
The service was just as impressive. Not once did we have to ask for a drink refill or flag anyone down—the staff was attentive without being intrusive. A special touch that meant a lot: the chef even came out personally to wish my mom a happy birthday!
If you're looking for a great dining experience where the staff truly seems to enjoy what they do, Sly’s is the place to go. It really is a hidden gem. I promise—you won’t be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Little pricy for a dinner date with a couple drinks .
We got the build your own seafood boil and we were not disappointed. Good amount of crab legs and shrimp , the andouille sausage they use was delicious. The girls working the dining area were very nice and personable. Specialty drinks were nicely done and delicious.
We were in town for a concert, the place is very small and reservations are probably a must here .
Like I said it was a bit expensive but we definitely dint feel like we got ripped off , it was high quality and delicious. We will probably make this a regular dinner when we come back for more concerts.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was amazing very understaffed. It started out to be a bad experience, but then the waitress Jaden took over. I think that's how you spell her name or not but anyways she made it a good experience after she took over she held the whole ship together she deserves award or something.. I hope if we ever come back this way again she is working that's for sure. Hats off to you, Jaden.
The best crab legs I have ever had out
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wasn’t happy with service for how expensive it is. Definitely not worth it. Never got my drink refilled after I was told I’m getting another one. Was there 2 hours.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Brought my husband to try for the first time and we loved it! A gem in paw paw
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A lovely place to have an up scale dinner. Four of us met prior to attending the Bodeans concert.
We started with crab cakes and a bowl of the seafood chowder.
The chowder was so so hearty with large pieces of lobster claws and assorted fish 2 of us ordered it as our entree.
My husband had the lobster roll that he could not finish. It was that big!!
Our friend ordered a pasta dish that had marinara sauce. He asked for a white wine sauce that he said was delicious!
Mushroom toast was good as well !
Can't say enough about Sly's!
Great place !!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The service was super slow. Sat at the bar me and my girlfriend was the only two at the bar. Their was 13 customers at the tables so not crazy busy. It took 17 minutes to get our 1st cocktail that was average at best. I ordered oysters Rockefeller for a appetizer they were small but good. My girlfriend order the chicken it was a chicken thigh not a breast for 26 dollars. Way over priced for what we got. I have had their fish specials in the past and they were really good. Not sure if it was just a off night for them or what. It was average food with a high price.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
This place is a seafood gem for all seafood lovers but they don’t just serve seafood . They serve chicken and steak. Everything is prepared stellar. We were recently surprised that soon after we requested that chef could create a vegetarian dish which was amazing! Thank you Sly’s peeps! Also, Anne Marie thank you for all you do for us and happy b- day! You are awesome as alway and the best restaurant person I’ve ever met! Sorry, but simply best person I’ve met!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
The decor is awesome. The vibe it gives off is what I think they were shooting for. Moving on: The waitress we had was lacking, literally had to ask for everything. Slow kitchen time, wrong food. Food was bland and mushy. Very disappointed for the amount of money I spent there. The reason I gave 3 Stars is the idea is awesome and the decor. Hopefully things change and I can come back in the future. I much rather support our local business.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 1
Great food and friendly service.. Highly recommended!!!
Excellent service and wonderful food! Ann was awesome! Walleye and charbroiled oysters were amazing!
Food is good. Service good. Prices are a little too high for the neighborhood and the food. Oysters Rockefeller were done wrong but tasty Cajun pasta very good Clam chowder good. As I said good food and service but 200 dollars a little too high. Lower your prices and you will be full every night. This isn’t France or New Orleans. 4stars. Norm
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Clam Chowder, Lobster Carbonara
The chowder was the Best and I am a World Traveler...
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Loading...